Which brings us back to the question..... WHY. MENTION. GA GA. AT. ALL....? I think the point could just as easily have been made simply by saying "we're gonna do a really sexed-up video for our next single...". What do you think....?

 

I.A with that. sexed up is sexed up, but when you bring Gaga into it - they'll just be hated for ripping her off!

GaGa is the same but without the breaking up.

 

Well, that really all depends on if she develops a Bowie-esque split personality mate..... :lol: He almost totally cracked up at the height of his fame and couldn't tell where Ziggy ended and David began (mind you, the drugs may have had a hand in it too :lol: )....

 

Girls Aloud solo efforts will probably be absolutely pointless, we all know full well that Xenomania is responsible for their tunes.... Do any of the members of GA really have a style of their own....? It's absolutely impossible to tell, at least with the Spice Girls you could actually tell which ones of them might do well with a solo career.... I can perhaps see Cheryl Cole becoming a full-time TV presenter more than anything, and maybe Sarah doing, er, something...

 

That's a tacky of The Saturdays. Surely they'd be more appreciated if they stuck to originality.

Girls Aloud have contract for 3 more albums, first in 2010 ;)

 

Contacts are not concrete, they can still be dropped or split up.

i like their own style anyway! That's original

Yeah, so tiring which is why it's gotten so many replies... :rolleyes: Couldn't just be because it's NOT a "let's all kiss the Saturdays arses" thread could it...? Bugger off back to the Saturdays Arse-licker forum mate because you clearly cannot handle a bit of criticism about your "idols"........ This is the POP Forum mate, we're not obliged to kiss Mollie or Frankie's sodding buttcheeks here...... Which is why you wont see ME near anywhere near your wretched Forum.....

 

Yes, but how many are actually agreeing with your view? Not many..

There's nothing to handle, because your argument is flawed. You're going off what a tabloid has printed about one of them saying that the look in their next video would "give GaGa a run for her money"

You're making out like they've said they're going to wipe the floor with her and have the best selling single this year.

They made a jokey remark about how they will look in their video.

 

And you are correct, this IS the pop forum.

So why you feel the need to keep making references to metal/indie/rock bands when they all have entirely different markets makes me question whether it's actually you that doesn't realise this is the pop forum.

 

I'm glad we won't see you anywhere near our forum, because any posts like the one I'm quoting would be just be deleted.

It's unnecessary tittle-tattle and it's stupid.

^ what an innapropriate comment about "arse-licking Saturday's fans" - what's the point in arguing with saturdays fans? That's like someone calling your heavy metal stars "hairy p*** eaters who can't sing" in the Rock forum!

Edited May 4, 200916 yr by LiamDeBarge

I'm glad we won't see you anywhere near our forum, because any posts like the one I'm quoting would be just be deleted.

It's unnecessary tittle-tattle and it's stupid.

 

Well, obviously it's not unnecessary because it's had a LOT of replies.... If you think it's SOOOOOOO unnecessary, why are you wasting your time and replying to it, and increasing the post count for such an unnecessary thread..... Pillock... :P

^ what an innapropriate comment about "arse-licking Saturday's fans" - what's the point in arguing with saturdays fans?

 

You're right, there probably is no point in arguing with Saturdays fans.... They simply dont respond to things like criticism, or debate, or even gentle humour directed at the objects of their saddo, fanboy idol-worship.....

 

Honestly, I've never met such an irony-free, humourless bunch in all my life..... God, they make the die-hard Nashville Elvis obsessives seem reasonably balanced by comparison.....

 

And people say us Goths or Metalheads dont have a sense of humour..... :rolleyes:

Well, obviously it's not unnecessary because it's had a LOT of replies.... If you think it's SOOOOOOO unnecessary, why are you wasting your time and replying to it, and increasing the post count for such an unnecessary thread..... Pillock... :P

 

It is all unnecessary, but reading your incessant put downs annoys me.

All you've managed to do is pit the GaGa fans against The Saturdays fans.

I'm aware it wasn't you who started this thread, but you two say almost the same thing each time, you may as well be the same person.

 

 

You're right, there probably is no point in arguing with Saturdays fans.... They simply dont respond to things like criticism, or debate, or even gentle humour directed at the objects of their saddo, fanboy idol-worship.....

 

Indeed.

And you take all of my criticism in your stride, right?

This is why you've spent half of your afternoon arguing back to me.

The only response anybody ever seems to get from you is an argumentative one.

Seems you get somewhat of a buzz from it.

And I'm pretty sure right now I'm responding to your criticism, debating and your apparent humour.

All you've managed to do is pit the GaGa fans against The Saturdays fans.

.

 

Oh, that tension was there LONG before I ever posted a fukkin' thing about it.... You've never read any of Kath's posts have you, she's been FAR more vicious than even me and Rob concerning the Sats in the past.... :rolleyes:

 

Frankly, it's irrelevant to me if it was The Sats who said it... I'd say exactly the SAME thing if this news story was about Girls Aloud or Pussycat Dolls or Sugababes, my objections are to bandwagon jumpers IN GENERAL, always have been, regardless of the genre of music (I thought you MAY just have been intelligent enough to discern that when I namechecked other bands and musical movements from the past, obviously I gave you WAY too much credit)....It just so happens that it the Sats that are the ones doing the jumping at the moment, last week it was Paris bloody Hilton, next week, it'll undoubtedly be someone else looking to horn in on Ga Ga's thunder, and I'll slag them off too.... I've been just as critical about Paris Hilton and her attempts to "do" Ga Ga if you care to actually read my criticisms on the relevant thread in the Lady Ga Ga forum, and on this topic....

 

In any case, in the words of Hal 9000, "I really think you ought to relax, take a stress pill and think things over"..... :lol:

 

Oh, that tension was there LONG before I ever posted a fukkin' thing about it.... You've never read any of Kath's posts have you, she's been FAR more vicious than even me and Rob concerning the Sats in the past.... :rolleyes:

 

Frankly, it's irrelevant to me if it was The Sats who said it... I'd say exactly the SAME thing if this news story was about Girls Aloud or Pussycat Dolls or Sugababes, my objections are to bandwagon jumpers IN GENERAL, always have been, regardless of the genre of music (I thought you MAY just have been intelligent enough to discern that when I namechecked other bands and musical movements from the past, obviously I gave you WAY too much credit)....It just so happens that it the Sats that are the ones doing the jumping at the moment, last week it was Paris bloody Hilton, next week, it'll undoubtedly be someone else looking to horn in on Ga Ga's thunder, and I'll slag them off too.... I've been just as critical about Paris Hilton and her attempts to "do" Ga Ga if you care to actually read my criticisms on the relevant thread in the Lady Ga Ga forum, and on this topic....

 

In any case, in the words of Hal 9000, "I really think you ought to relax, take a stress pill and think things over"..... :lol:

 

I personally don't have an opinion on Kath, but I've heard a lot of others opinions on her, and they don't put her in the nicest light.

You think way too highly of yourself to think I go reading what you've said in other AFs.

I do my best to try and not read anything you say, seeing as it's all negative garbage.

I do my best to try and not read anything you say, seeing as it's all negative garbage.

 

So, if you try your best not to read anything I post, how do you know it's all negative (and you seem to totally disregard the fact that I've made very positive posts about Ga Ga in this thread, so all negative, eh?)... So, if I'm negative about the Sats, that means everything I do or say is negative does it...? You really are a clown, and a total Saturdays loon.... :lol: You're funny dude, I'll keep replying to you because, frankly, this is the best laugh I've had today.... :lol:

I like Lady G... but jesus christ. She is no Lennon/Jagger/Bowie. She certainly thinks she is though. Her Look is cool and avant garde.

 

But thats all be done before Grace Jones is her obvious muse.Mixed with 80s new romantic types.She is a brilliant plaigarist though

 

But she trys way to hard to be cool. And have you heard how bad eh-eh nothing else I can say actually its absolute tosh makes "Up" look like a classic.

 

Plus she collaborated with Akon :puke2: :puke2:

 

She is good but quality control was off on a good few of the tracks on The Fame.

 

But Back on topic why cant the The Sats copy her. She Lady G has copied her own style almost vampire-like from other artists Bowie Jones and New wave/New romantic acts.

I like Lady G... but jesus christ. She is no Lennon/Jagger/Bowie. She certainly thinks she is though. Her Look is cool and avant garde.

 

But thats all be done before Grace Jones is her obvious muse.Mixed with 80s new romantic types.She is a brilliant plaigarist though

 

But she trys way to hard to be cool. And have you heard how bad eh-eh nothing else I can say actually its absolute tosh makes "Up" look like a classic.

 

Plus she collaborated with Akon :puke2: :puke2:

 

She is good but quality control was off on a good few of the tracks on The Fame.

 

But Back on topic why cant the The Sats copy her. She Lady G has copied her own style almost vampire-like from other artists Bowie Jones and New wave/New romantic acts.

I agree with what you've said for most of this, especially the bold bit.

Well, obviously it's not unnecessary because it's had a LOT of replies.... If you think it's SOOOOOOO unnecessary, why are you wasting your time and replying to it, and increasing the post count for such an unnecessary thread..... Pillock... :P

 

Obviously you care enough about this topic to keep reading, welcome to the fan club!

 

BTW this topic NEEDS to close - it's unnecassary and is sparking quite a few arguments!

Obviously you care enough about this topic to keep reading, welcome to the fan club!

 

BTW this topic NEEDS to close - it's unnecassary and is sparking quite a few arguments!

 

Because its not a Saturday's w*** fest it needs to be closed ? :wacko:

 

I thought some of the Kelly Clarkson fans were crazed dribbling loons but Saturday's fanboys take obsesion to a whole new level :o :o :o

 

 

Because its not a Saturday's w*** fest it needs to be closed ? :wacko:

 

I thought some of the Kelly Clarkson fans were crazed dribbling loons but Saturday's fanboys take obsesion to a whole new level :o :o :o

 

I'm not in love with the Saturdays... I only like one of their songs if I'm honest. I just think this thread is inappropriate and can do more harm than good! Look at the controversy already!

I'm not in love with the Saturdays... I only like one of their songs if I'm honest. I just think this thread is inappropriate and can do more harm than good! Look at the controversy already!

 

I wasn't talking about you in particular lol or even about you don't take it personally I was talking in general

 

The fact that the Saturday's mod gave Kate 10% for a joke, the fact that not the slightest negative ccomment about the Saturday's is allowed, the fact that some of those in this thread can't accept the slightest bit of criticism of thrm, it takes worshipping to extreme levels that is what I was referring to

 

If any of the Saturday's fanboys died do you think any of the Saturday's would give a damn ? if any of the Saturday's were in the street would they give the extreme fanboys the time of day or even a glance ? they wouldn't, that is why I don't understand fanboyism, sure appreciate the music or whatever but to get all frothed up about people who wouldn't care about them is beyond me

Edited May 4, 200916 yr by B.A Baracus