Ever since ex-Sugababe singer Siobhan Donaghy fled the band after climbing through a small toilet window on tour & running off into the sunset, the "Don't Give It Up" singer has claimed Keisha Buchanan allegedly bullied her out of the group.

 

With everything taken into account, do you believe there to be some truth to this?

 

I always thought there was SOME truth to it. I say "some" because I believe most of it was because of a) the way they were all put together (I believe they BECAME friends, but they weren't initially) and B) how young they all were.

 

I also believe Siobhan believes she was bullied. Keisha probably is a nice lass, but I bet behind the cameras when things aren't going her way she will split weaves & swear like a pirate.

 

I don't believe Amelle was bullied, although it's now obvious there were problems between her & Keisha. I'm almost positive I read (years ago) there being problems with Mutya & Keisha, too.

 

So...was it nothing more than silly teenage girls squabbling, or did Keisha really make chop suey of that ass where by Siobhan felt there was nothing else to do BUT leave?

Edited September 30, 200915 yr by Annie-May

I agree about there being "some" bullying, I dont think it was as bad as it was made out to be. Ithink Keisha is a very hard working girl and anything that gets in her way, or when she doesn't get her way it could cause alot of problems, not in a spoilt brat way but in a she knows what she wants and will go hard to get it. With amelle, she said she would be supportive and has a lot of respect left for them which seemed nice of her, however Heidi is saying she isn't even replying to her texts, and although people may say she has every right not to, it just seems like shes being fake about respect and support for them still.

I think Siobhan called the shots musically, and Keisha did not like that. Mutya couldn't care whether Monday falls on a Friday as long as she's singing.

 

Siobhan admits the reason they are so successful is because she isn't in the group. If she were, they wouldn't be as big as they are and the music would be like that of the first record. When asked if she regrets leaving in this respect, she answered "not at all".

I think a big part of Siobhan's problem was that she was lumped in with two best friends. K and Mut both were good friends from school, and it ain't the easiest thing to break into a clique.

 

I don't think Amelle was bullied, she appears to be the kinda girl that stands no messin. I just can't see her being bullied. And at 24[5 now] i can't see K being a bully. I think she's highly driven and has an unbeatable work ethic and it may just clash with the way A and H prefer to roll.

I was rather under the impression that it was Siobhan and Mutya who were friends and Keisha muscled in? I do hope that's how it went anyway. Tres fabulous.

Siohban has said she was never friends with Keisha.

I was rather under the impression that it was Siobhan and Mutya who were friends and Keisha muscled in? I do hope that's how it went anyway. Tres fabulous.

No, K and M were best mates from primary school. Known each other since they were 7 or 9. sumthin along those lines.

 

Muts dad met Siobhans manager in a shop and thats how the pair of them got together, Mut brought K along once and the rest as they say is SugaHistory

Nobody really knows what went on apart from them.