Posted March 18, 200619 yr The dvd is out on monday I think the film isnt as good as the last 3. They mised out to many important bits and the scenes where terrible, and i was excited just to see the end voldamort scene, and i thought it was a complete let down
March 18, 200619 yr I disagree, Josh :) I think for sheer cinema, its the best HP film so far. GoF is a huge book, and it should be expected that things should be left out. Even the kids acted well, better than they did in the other films - they were excellent at the Yule Ball scene.
March 18, 200619 yr Author I disagree, Josh :) I think for sheer cinema, its the best HP film so far. GoF is a huge book, and it should be expected that things should be left out. Even the kids acted well, better than they did in the other films - they were excellent at the Yule Ball scene. Lol! So it's a kinda of a 50/50 film :P I thought the dragon scene was good though
March 18, 200619 yr Lol! So it's a kinda of a 50/50 film :P I thought the dragon scene was good though :lol: We are 50/50 here! I thought the Dragon scene was a bit of let down!
March 18, 200619 yr Author :lol: We are 50/50 here! I thought the Dragon scene was a bit of let down! :lol: btw, i'm still gonna buy the dvd :P it wont seem right habing the 1st, 2nd and 3rd but not the 4th
March 18, 200619 yr :lol: btw, i'm still gonna buy the dvd :P it wont seem right habing the 1st, 2nd and 3rd but not the 4th Im deffo going to get it, on Monday! :)
March 18, 200619 yr ive read the book but havent seen the film if I watch it will it spoil my perspective? :unsure:
March 18, 200619 yr ive read the book but havent seen the film if I watch it will it spoil my perspective? :unsure: No, I wouldnt think so, I am a huge fan of the books, and very much enjoyed the film. You just need to realise that they will change things and miss stuff out, and you will be fine!
March 18, 200619 yr Well in honesty I didn't think the first 3 films done the books any justice at all. Ive heard this one is better though so ill probably watch it :)
March 18, 200619 yr Well in honesty I didn't think the first 3 films done the books any justice at all. Ive heard this one is better though so ill probably watch it :) You should! Come back and tell us what you think when you have :)
March 18, 200619 yr Goblet of Fire is the only HP book I haven't read, and I think it is the best of all the films. I was reluctant to watch it, but amazed at how good it was!
March 18, 200619 yr In my poinion its no where near as good as the books. Its still a decent film but they do miss loads out which was to be expexted, but I think they could of added more than one scene with Sirius as he's quite a major charachter in the 5th book.
March 18, 200619 yr Well, it does make me wonder just how much of book 5 they will miss out, in the upcoming film. Thats the best book too, I just hope the film lives up to it!
March 18, 200619 yr It's one of my fave HP books if not my fave - so I was very critical about it. They cut out way too much important stuff which worries me at how they'll deal with related stories in the 5th and 6th books - like Rita, for instance. But the effects were fantastic - and they did quite a good job. I'm definitely gonna buy the DVD on Monday!
March 18, 200619 yr My fav book is the 4th one and thats why I was disappointed about how much stuff they missed out of it. I found the 5th one went on about 150 pages too long and I found Luna Lovgood the most irritating charachter ever, and they will only put the key points of the 5th book in the book, and I hope make Umbridge really really evil.
March 18, 200619 yr it will probaly end up that umbirdge wont appear in the 5th film She is there, she has been cast (I cant remember the actress playing here atm)
March 18, 200619 yr Yeah I heard she was gonna be in it, but i bet she won't have as much screen time as she does in the book. Her along with Sirius are probably two of the most important charachters in that book along with the regular ones like Harry etc.
March 18, 200619 yr How could you not have Umbridge in book 5? Without her, you can't have the whole rebellion with Dumbledore's army! She's crucial to the plot!
March 18, 200619 yr How could you not have Umbridge in book 5? Without her, you can't have the whole rebellion with Dumbledore's army! She's crucial to the plot! Well, she is there, so its ok!
Create an account or sign in to comment