thought i'd give this a bump for the 04-09 votes :)

2004:

Muse 'Butterflies & Hurricanes'

The Walkmen 'The Rat'

Kings of Leon 'The Bucket'

 

2005:

Ladytron 'Destroy Everything You Touch'

Maximo Park 'Apply Some Pressure'

Guillemots 'Trains To Brazil'

 

2006:

Peter, Bjorn & John 'Young Folks'

Jenny Lewis & The Watson Twins 'You Are What You Love'

TV On The Radio 'Wolf Like Me'

 

2007:

The Shins 'Turn On Me'

Hold Steady 'Stuck Between Stations'

Kings of Leon 'Fans'

 

2008:

Mystery Jets ft Laura Marling 'Young Love'

Camille 'Money Note'

PNAU 'Embrace'

 

2009:

Yeah Yeah Yeahs 'Zero'

Animal Collective 'My Girls'

Animal Collective 'Summertime Clothes'