i love all of these and can't decide between them. ): though i'm sort of leaning towards feldberg / tinashe.

White Hinterland :wub:

Feldberg - definitely the most boring song out of 4.

Tinashe - chorus left me down :no:...it's far behind in terms of amazing comparing to Come On Over

Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros - I can see this one being limited size hit with the people/countries who enjoy indie only.

White Hinterland - THE BEST :wub: love it.

I've actually never heard any of these songs before, and I liked three of them

 

 

Feldberg = Both pleasant and catchy! :D I love the verses at the beginning when they shift from the guy to the girls :wub:

 

Tinashe = Unlike Addy the chorus didn't let me down in any way. I love how the song is all over the place, and how this chorus stands for itself and brings it all together :wub: It might grow too..

 

Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros = I can see the indie limitations for it, and it does last a bit "too" long, although it doesn't stop me from liking it!

 

White Hinterland = I don't like this at all. I think it's the "ooo-oooh-ooh"-parts. Seems so amataur-ish and makes the song last longer than it actually is. Longer than "Home" actually :nocheer:

Edited April 18, 201015 yr by Freeze

crazy different opinions already. ): GUH.

Icarus is an amazing song :wub: I charted it a while back thanks to you :P

Feldberg - Really nice actually, the melody reminds me of a few other songs but this isn't a bad thing. Sounds like a grower too. 8.5/10

 

Tinashe - Not that interesting compared to Come On Over which really stood out for me because it was unique but it's certainly not bad. I find that this is like an electro-acoustic interpretation of Moving by Supergrass. 7/10

 

Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros - Heard this last month too, wasn't blown away but it's nice enough. 7.5/10

 

White Hinterland - My personal favourite although I'm quite bored of it now. Would give you the best result of the four though I reckon. 8.5/10

 

For selfish reasons (i.e. the best discovery for me right now) I'd prefer Feldberg to the others. I might give points to White Hinterland too, wouldn't give points to the other two.

I feel like Feldberg is the way to go tbh. A bit too late to use White Hinterland, Home is too indie and Tinashe isn't as good as Come on Over. I still love it though. Hmm.

what about this?

 

Ooh me like! :D