the rumours are so so so wrong

I'd go with Gamu, TreyC and Rebecca personally. Keri and Raquel clearly stand no chance despite being extremly strong, and Cher is definatly through despite the fact she wasnt very good tonight and that the hype surrounding her has now reached unbearable heights. I dread to say it, but the horror that is Katie will probably be through too.

Its so obvious Cheryl is going to pick Cher, she liked her from the first audition. I just hope Katie is not in the final 3. I rather have Keri/Gamu, Rebecca and the obvious Cher.

So, if you don't make a drama Cheryl doesnt like you. :lol:

 

Correction. If you don't make a drama...the production staff and stage crew...doesn't like you. They wanna make good TV, not good music. :kink:

My favourite of the girls from those performances were Gamu and Treyc - but despite Cher's cock-up, I'd still put her through as I LUFF her. :wub:

I'd choose Keri, Cher & Katie. Katie & Cher werent that good tonight but they are charasmatic. Lots of people will love them, buy their tracks and this is a business in the end.

Edited October 2, 201014 yr by Jason

Guys, you all seem to be missing the obvious point here.

The reason Cheryl has to pick Rebecca, Katie & Cher is because theyre the only three to her.... umm.... tastes!

Cher, Rebecca and Trey-C were my favourites from that group. (yes admittedly Cher was crap tonight, but that's what an illness on you voice does to you, you could clearly hear in her voice she was ill too, unless she's a brilliant actress :heehee: - but she has IT. For me. Whatever that it thing is, she has it.

My favourite of the girls from those performances were Gamu and Treyc - but despite Cher's cock-up, I'd still put her through as I LUFF her. :wub:

 

If you're a contestant and you peak on your first audition and it's rapidly downhill from there onwards, why put Cher through that humiliation and in 5 weeks time become the nations cult hate figure (like Danyl Johnson became last year). I didn't like Cher's version of 'Viva La Vida' last week (nothing to do with the fact she was ill because she wasn't) and I wasn't impressed with her interpretation of 'Cooler Than Me'. She probably forgot her words because she'd never heard the song before and struggled with the lyrics due to lack of familiarity.

 

Will.I.Am made a good point that with the right songs, Cher would be great. Surely that's the case with all the singers. For eg; can you imagine Mary (from the Overs) in Disco week. She's from Ireland, a good singer but clearly only fit for singing big ballads. As soon as Disco week arrives, that'll be the downfall of Mary.

Guys, you all seem to be missing the obvious point here.

The reason Cheryl has to pick Rebecca, Katie & Cher is because theyre the only three to her.... umm.... tastes!

 

Hahaha thats kinda funny

 

cheryl cole is a racist

If anything the only decent two I liked where the two groups put together by the X-Factor.

:puke2: I hate that Katie creature talk about ego she is beyond crap.

I love how Katie was all "There's nobody out there like me." Ummm, are you not aware you are Pixie Lott pt.II?

If anything the only decent two I liked where the two groups put together by the X-Factor.

 

 

That's only because you have an eye for Sophia in Belle Ami ;)

Cher and Katie really fell apart. I'd still pick Cher though

 

She's been my favourite since the auditions, but I'm afraid she has already peaked :(

I'd put her through alongside Rebecca and TreyC

I don't really understand why Katie and Cher are being given special treatment when both of their auditions were total crap this time round. Talk about bias.

 

What is happening with that, last year Cheryl was so harsh on anyone who crumbled at this point so I hope it is not true what the spoilers are saying.Cher is clearly not well and Katie is not talented she makes Ray Quinn look and sound like a Superstar.

They did make it painfully obvious who was going through with the editing, I think the ones where they played they played the interview over their song are all gone tbh

 

of the Boys, I still really like Matt and Aiden is pretty good, I think he could be a dark horse if he gets through- not keen on Tom that much, quite a good category

 

The overs category was awful- its like the auditions all over again, I think Mary, John and Storm will go through, they were by far the only decent ones- Mary may have forgot the words, but the category is so awful I think they'll let it pass :lol: poor Louis, the one year he doesnt get the groups, he still gets the weakest category :lol:

 

The groups were good this year- which makes a nice change, I really liked the Girl Group- those legs! :wub: :o and FYD were good , the boy group I think are certainties even though they werent great

 

and the girls are by far the strongest- although I think most of them messed up though- Gamu picked the wrong song, Katie totally blew it and Cher well- :cry: :cry: :cry: I still think she'll get through, but she just screams 'Diana Vickers' to me, I think she will have similar fate unfortunately and finish around 4th or 5th

 

also, my god at that girl MURDERING Green Day- I was shocked :o

 

from that show, that list looks very accurate

It's shocking how

Both Katie and Cher flopped so badly at the judges houses but they both still made it to the live shows. I've liked them a lot in previous rounds but they were definitely the two weakest links tonight

 

 

All things taken into account based on that I would pick from the girls, Rebecca, Gamu and TreyC to go through.

 

Katie is really starting to annoy me, I liked her at first but her lack of preparation and messups + her cockyness is getting difficult to deal with. :/ She's all talk and no action.

Edited October 2, 201014 yr by Sabrewulf

Katie is really starting to annoy me, I liked her at first but her lack of preparation and messups + her cockyness is getting difficult to deal with. :/ She's all talk and no action.

 

Her cock-ups and lack of preparation are a stage-managed. Don't say you believe that her cock-up a the audition stage was genuine. It was a way to get her noticed ... hey ... it got her more TV time than a lot of the other average performers. She knows exactly what she's doing. She's a professional and she's using all the tricks of the trade that she's accumulated. Good luck to her ... with a voice as average as hers ... she has to use her acting skills.

 

You could see the ONLY act that Will I Am was impressed with at all (quite rightly) was Rebecca.

 

Sadly ... Cher has proved that she is a one trick pony. And I liked her to begin with.

 

Kath