We have very differing opinions then :lol:

 

The three times i've seen them live Keisha's been anything but bland and boring

Jade actually sings them better. She's got more soul! Not as bland as Keisha! :mellow: Keisha should be charged of raping her own songs in my opinion. ;)

 

Um. No.

 

Jade is an amazing singer, technically. Probably better than Keisha. But there is absolutely no emotion in her voice. She's singing Keisha's parts without any soul. Apart from all the drama that's the main problem with the Sugababes cover band. They can sing (except Beige). But there doesn't seem to be any substance.

 

 

I don't know how anyone can say Keisha has no soul in her voice. 6 albums beg to differ.

Um. No.

 

Jade is an amazing singer, technically. Probably better than Keisha. But there is absolutely no emotion in her voice. She's singing Keisha's parts without any soul. Apart from all the drama that's the main problem with the Sugababes cover band. They can sing (except Beige). But there doesn't seem to be any substance.

I don't know how anyone can say Keisha has no soul in her voice. 6 albums beg to differ.

 

He is allowed his opinion. TBH I think Jade does have soul but when you're singing songs written for someone else it's harder portray the different emotions like when Amelle started to sing Ugly live, I just didn't believe it. If you look at Crash & Burn I can really hear the soul in Jade's voice especially in live performances.

Why does every thread in here become Jade vs Keisha? :(

 

(For the record, I'm firmly Team Jade :lol:)

Why does every thread in here become Jade vs Keisha? :(

 

(For the record, I'm firmly Team Jade :lol:)

I dunno :( Like, we're allowed an opinion, but I hate when members get defensive over who they prefer. And then, it goes to Jade VS. Keisha :(

My favourite Sugababes cover is Jo, Rachel and Mario off Big Brother 11 singing 'Freak Like Me' :)