August 21, 201014 yr EDIT: I watched the votes and found out that the Saturdays are REALLY overranked. I won't bitchslap them or even put them down in my list (they will still be at #15), but if they are above Sugababes or Girls Aloud in final, the rank will be a laughing stock, at least for me.Whilst I see why you may be annoyed, if The Sats finish higher than SB and/or Girls Aloud, however I personally think it's time for The Sats to be cut some slack. They've lasted far longer than people originally thought and there is still demand for them and stuff. They've had two and a half albums now and people are still treating them like they haven't proved their worth and are still newbies or whatever. I have ranked them higher on my rank than Girls Aloud and Sugababes, because I personally feel, their first three albums have been very consistent and I like them more than my favourite GA & SB albums. If I were to rank each groups albums I would have SB 'Change' 1st, then Sats 'Headlines' 2nd & then either 'Wordshaker' by The Sats or 'Out Of Control' by GA 3rd/4th and then The Sats 'Chasing Lights' 5th. So in just 3 albums, The Sats have occupied my Top 5 albums of the three girl groups...
August 21, 201014 yr Whilst I see why you may be annoyed, if The Sats finish higher than SB and/or Girls Aloud, however I personally think it's time for The Sats to be cut some slack. They've lasted far longer than people originally thought and there is still demand for them and stuff. They've had two and a half albums now and people are still treating them like they haven't proved their worth and are still newbies or whatever. I have ranked them higher on my rank than Girls Aloud and Sugababes, because I personally feel, their first three albums have been very consistent and I like them more than my favourite GA & SB albums. If I were to rank each groups albums I would have SB 'Change' 1st, then Sats 'Headlines' 2nd & then either 'Wordshaker' by The Sats or 'Out Of Control' by GA 3rd/4th and then The Sats 'Chasing Lights' 5th. So in just 3 albums, The Sats have occupied my Top 5 albums of the three girl groups... Atomic Kitten's 1st and 3rd albums rank above all of these for me :kink: I prefer all of the Saturdays albums to any Sugbabes album though personally...and I own all of them apart from One Touch now.
August 21, 201014 yr Oh ok. Btw, I was slagging of Sugababes 4.0 - not the first three. I actually loved the second line-up. Their sound and image was so edgy and British. They were quality from 2000-2005. Dare I say that Amelle actually ruined the group. She's too commercial and "glam" to be in the Sugababes. The musical direction completely changed when she joined. AYN and 'Change' were great pop records but there wasn't as much of an edge to them as FLM, RR, 'Stronger', HITH, RD and CIAM. Then the C&S era was the first proper nail in the coffin. The sound seemed to be a copy of the Amy trend. Then Sweet 7 ruined the band and made them more of a brand. Can you really picture the original/2.0 Sugababes singing 'Get Sexy' or 'Wear My Kiss'? That's my problem with the "Sugababes". :) TS don't have anything unique about them but the thing that they have that the Babes don't is a bit of chemistry. I can't believe there is not at least ONE original member in the Babes now and they still use the name. Do they think that they can sell on name alone? Yep, Amelle indeed ruined the group. Although I don't consider it as Amelle's fault as she's definitely talented and unique by some means but Mutya's departure has done it all. They had a golden formula with the 2.0: music quality from Mutya, edge from Keisha and 'pop' from Heidi. With Mutya's departure the 'quality' factor has gone and they've become much more trend-following rather than trend-making as they were during 1.0/2.0 times. And that is the main problem about 3.0. The whole 'Sweet 7' era was recorded for Keisha's vocal so I can't blame 4.0 for the album and singles from it massively, I still consider it as another 'trend-following 3.0 album'. As for 4.0, the main problem it's not clearly the Sugababes. :kink: Only Heidi IMO can be called a proper Sugababe of all them but it's not enough. And yes, maybe Sats have the thing called chemistry. But when I did my ranks, rates etc. I took (and always take) into account only the factors of music quality, involvement in the writing process, the singing abilities, uniqueness. I don't take into account the personality factor at all as I can't judge all of them by what I can see from outside. Whilst I see why you may be annoyed, if The Sats finish higher than SB and/or Girls Aloud, however I personally think it's time for The Sats to be cut some slack. They've lasted far longer than people originally thought and there is still demand for them and stuff. They've had two and a half albums now and people are still treating them like they haven't proved their worth and are still newbies or whatever. I have ranked them higher on my rank than Girls Aloud and Sugababes, because I personally feel, their first three albums have been very consistent and I like them more than my favourite GA & SB albums. If I were to rank each groups albums I would have SB 'Change' 1st, then Sats 'Headlines' 2nd & then either 'Wordshaker' by The Sats or 'Out Of Control' by GA 3rd/4th and then The Sats 'Chasing Lights' 5th. So in just 3 albums, The Sats have occupied my Top 5 albums of the three girl groups... Well, it's fair enough. :) You like the Sats material more so you put them higher. It will be sad for me if only overall result has Sats above SB/GA. The Saturdays indeed have a 'newbie' problem. In the days when there were a lot more girl-bands they would be treated much more positively. I think it's due to the fact that we have had a Sugababes / Girls Aloud competition duopoly for the good amount of years. The quality of both of the groups used to be very, very high! Besides, both groups (SB/GA) are in the music industry for FAR more time then were their predecessors. Girls Aloud will eventually record their 6th album while Sugababes are about to start write their 8th. Of course with two veterans like these you will be considered as the newbie even after two albums (and a half) which all came out in the last two years. Another problem about the credibility of the Saturdays is the fact that they don't have their own distinctive sound. Sugababes (pre-C&S eras) and Girls Aloud have it while anyone can record the Saturdays' stuff and not a lot of people (I talk about the casual buyers) will notice the change in quality. They release nice pop songs, what do you need more? - you can ask. Yes, their material is really good quality-wise. And they are honoured enough for doing it: all of their singles have (bar 'Missing You' but it'll have them in one or two weeks) very good 100k+ sales, 'Chasing Lights' has gone platinum IIRC and 'Headlines' is set for their first top-5 album. But if they want to step into the Sugababes/Girls Aloud league they need something special in their music which will tell the audience "Yes, this is the Saturdays, no, it's not another nice pop song by some girl-band, it's a song by the Saturdays". The other way is to keep making nice pop mainstream albums and they will gain credibility simply with their age. They will definitely not fade away like Girls Can't Catch so I'm looking how they and their material wii grow in the future. :) Well, it's how I see it anyway.
August 21, 201014 yr Tbh GA, the 'Babes and The Saturdays all shouldn't be really high. There are far better groups out there than those three - even in terms of girl-groups. :smoke: Destiny's Child are extremely underrated in terms of rankage. They have outstanding vocals individually, incredible harmonies, great choreography and dancing ability, great music, they (co-)write their own music, they have a unique style and probably a far better name yet they are criminally constantly ranked lower than the three aforementioned girl-groups. So people can be annoyed that the Sats might rank higher than the 'Babes and GA but IT'S A CRIME if DC rank lower than JLS-femminage (note: age is pronounced arjjjjjjjj for French effect and I'm talking about the Sats). :kink:
August 21, 201014 yr Author It's scaring me that Girls cant catch will chart high ! 2 singles and there high up !
August 22, 201014 yr Destiny's Child have always been overrated for me, personally. Bar a handful of songs, i've always thought they've been pretty much awful. :lol: Don't see the appeal whatsoever. They're all better as soloists... And Rich, I agree about 'Ladies Night' being better than those (bar maybe 'Change' for me), but I didn't include AK as they don't get involve with the whole GA vs. SB vs. Sats debate that goes on here :heehee:
August 22, 201014 yr 1. Girls Aloud 2. Black Eyed Peas 3. Destiny's Child 4. Spice Girls 5. S Club 7 6. B* Witched 7. Busted 8. Sugababes 9. Atomic Kitten 10. The Veronica's 11. Evanescene 12. Big Brovaz 13. Glee Cast 14. Pussycat Dolls 15. Scissor Sisters 16. All Saints 17. S Club Juniors 18. Mis-Teeq 19. McFly 20. Steps 21. Scouting for Girls 22. Vengaboyz 23. The Saturdays 24. MGMT 25. All Saints
August 23, 201014 yr 1. The Veronicas 2. Black Eyed Peas 3. Paramore 4. Green Day 5. N-Dubz 6. The Killers 7. Destiny's Child 8. Maroon 5 9. Evansecence 10. All American Rejects 11.Blink 182 12. Fall out Boy 13. Kings Of Leon 14. The Script 15. The Pussycat Dolls 16. The Saturdays 17. One Republic 18. The Kooks 19. Pendulum 20. La Roux 21. Arctic Monkeys 22. The Fray 23. MGMT 24. Big Brovaz 25. Glee KK:Mcfly
August 23, 201014 yr The Wanted have had 1 single ffs! Once again the idiocy and shallowness of Buzzjack shines through :/ 01 My Chemical Romance 02 Foo Fighters 03 Green Day 04 Guns and roses 05 Evanescence 06 The Killers 07 Paramore 08 Abba 09 Muse 10 Linkin Park 11 Lostprophets 12 Blondie 13 Queen 14 Pendulum 15 All American rejects 16 Blur 17 S Club 7 18 Spice Girls 19 Erasure 20 Journey 21 Scissor Sisters 22 Suede 23 Girls Aloud 24 Take That 25 The Veronicas KK: The Wanted
August 23, 201014 yr 1.Destiny Child (25pts) 2.Mcfly (24pts) 3.JLS (23pts) 4.Glee (22pts) 5.Boys To Men (21pts) 6.N Dubz (20pts) 7.Busted (19pts) 8.Sugababes (18pts) 9.Black Eyed Peas (17pts) 10.Scouting for Girls (16pts) 11.The Pussycat Dolls (15pts) 12.Jonas Brothers (14pts) 13.Take That (13pts) 14.Bon Jovi (12pts) 15.Boyzone (11pts) 16.One Republic (10pts) 17.The Jackson 5 (9pts) bs= girls aloud
August 23, 201014 yr Author The list will not be counted until 30th August, feel free to edit as much as possibile! I believe The Wanted, Girls cant catch do not deserve to be in the top 100, nevermind the top 50!
August 24, 201014 yr Destiny Child Black Eye peas Mis Teeq Girlicious N Dubz The Pussycat Dolls Glee Tlc Boys to men Sugababes Spice Girls Big Brovaz The Jackson 5 S Club 7 The Saturdays S Club Juniours Girls Aloud Jls The Wanted Atomic Kitten Jedward (for a laugh lol) Bs Girls Cant Catch
August 24, 201014 yr 1. Girls Aloud - Best 2. Spice Girls 3. S Club 7 4. The Saturdays 5. Stereophonics 6. Muse 7. Sugababes 8. Evanescence 9. Destiny's Child 10. ABBA 11. JLS 12. Queen 13. Liberty X 14. B*Witched 15. The Pussycat Dolls 16. Black Eyed Peas 17. OneRepublic 18. Blondie 19. Scissor Sisters 20. Glee 21. The Script 22. Girlicious 23. Mis-Teeq 24. N-Dubz 25. Girls Can't Catch KK = Green Day Edited my list, GCC and Glee moved down, The Wanted Out, N-Dubz in, Destiny's Child, OneRepublic, Scissor Sisters, Mis-Teeq and The Script all up! Also changed my KK
August 24, 201014 yr 1. Girls Aloud - Best 2. Spice Girls 3. S Club 7 4. The Saturdays 5. Stereophonics 6. Muse 7. Sugababes 8. Evanescence 9. Destiny's Child 10. ABBA 11. JLS 12. Queen 13. Liberty X 14. Black Eyed Peas 15. The Pussycat Dolls 16. Aerosmith 17. B*Witched 18. OneRepublic 19. Blondie 20. Scissor Sisters 21. Glee 22. The Script 23. Girlicious 24. Mis-Teeq 25. N-Dubz KK = Green Day Edited again, I'd forgot about Aerosmith! :o
August 25, 201014 yr 01' t.A.T.u 02' The Prodigy 03' Spice Girls 04' Muse 05' Sugababes 06' Bloc Party 07' S Club 7 08' B* Witched 09' Scissor Sisters 10' Linkin Park 11' All Saints 12' The Cardigans 13' The Pussycat Dolls 14' TLC 15' Girls Aloud 16' The Saturdays 17' Massive Attack 18' Sigur Ros 19' Steps 20' Destiny's Child 21' Pendulum 22' The Corrs 23' Mis Teeq 24' Radiohead 25' Glee Bitch Slap: U2
August 26, 201014 yr 1. Girls Aloud 2. Black Eyed Peas 3. Oasis 4. Spice Girls 5. Queen 6. The Script 7. Take That 8. Sugababes 9. Destiny Child 10. The Killers 11. The Saturdays 12. Misteeq 13.Coldplay 14. Kings of Leon 15. The Pussycat Dolls Karate Kick: JLS
Create an account or sign in to comment