Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 51
  • Views 6.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Beyoncé and Rihanna. Although I'd be so annoyed if Queen RiRi didn't win :(.

Beyoncé would most likely win it, Rihanna's more of a singles seller than she is an albums seller. Though I would personally buy both the albums. :kink:

Susan Boyle vs Duffy in album chart in November. Who would win?
  • Author
Susan Boyle vs Duffy in album chart in November. Who would win?

 

I would say Susan Boyle (First week sales). Duffy would overtake the week after lol

If Amazon release dates are correct then it's Duffy v Take That albums both out Nov. 29th. Take That will outsell her with all the hype over Robbie re-joining.
I'd like to see U2 vs. Coldplay or Green Day vs. Foo Fighters. I think Coldplay and Green Day would win. Also hows about Beyonce vs. Jay-Z

Edited by laddergoat

Joe x Rage Against the Machine

 

 

:rolleyes:

Leona vs Alexandra

SuBo vs Mariah (xmas versions)

Whitney vs Mariah (not likely to happen Whitney does not look into shape)

Joe vs Olly (impossible)

Alexandra vs Jls (impossible)

Neyo vs JasonDerulo

Taylor Swift vs Miley Cyrus ( taylor :cheer: )

Duffy vs Winehouse

Guetta vs Timbo

Spears vs Gaga vs Perry vs Rihanna --> OMG the BJ server is SO down

Joe vs Miley vs Gummy Bear (and the gummy bear wins)

Kesha vs Gaga

  • Author
I'd like to see U2 vs. Coldplay or Green Day vs. Foo Fighters. I think Coldplay and Green Day would win. Also hows about Beyonce vs. Jay-Z

 

How about Coldplay Vs. Foo Fighters and Green Day Vs. U2? Green Day need to buck up themselves. Was a massive fan of American Idiot but disappointed by 21 century breakdown. Jay-Z Vs. Beyonce could work, once he releases his greatest hits he will have a good solid fanbase that might even rival beyonce (maybe lol)

 

Leona vs Alexandra Alexandra might win atm, got more momentum

SuBo vs Mariah (xmas versions) SuBo, at least for the next couple of years

Whitney vs Mariah (not likely to happen Whitney does not look into shape) Whitney given a song like Million Dollar Bill

Joe vs Olly (impossible) Joe because of the Simon Cowell effect

Alexandra vs Jls (impossible) JLS would win, unfortunately

Neyo vs JasonDerulo Jason would atm

Taylor Swift vs Miley Cyrus ( taylor :cheer: ) Taylor, she just needs to get to #10 :P

Duffy vs Winehouse Duffy in singles, Wino in albums

Guetta vs Timbo Timbo given the right song, Guetta sells on his collabs

Spears vs Gaga vs Perry vs Rihanna --> OMG the BJ server is SO down GaGa would win, hands down

Joe vs Miley vs Gummy Bear (and the gummy bear wins) Miley wuldn't stand a chance

Kesha vs Gaga GaGa

 

I'd like to see Madonna vs Kylie. Just to see how far a lunatic fanbase can get you :P

Would say Madonna v GaGa but atm there'd be no contest.

Beady Eye (Liam's new band) vs Noel Gallagher would be interesting.

Paramore vs 30 Seconds to Mars

Beyoncé would most likely win it, Rihanna's more of a singles seller than she is an albums seller. Though I would personally buy both the albums. :kink:

Depends on the songs really. If Rihanna released something like 'Russian Roulette' then yeah Beyoncé would easily win, but if she released something universally loved like 'Disturbia', 'Umbrella' or 'Only Girl (In The World)' (I know the last example isn't loved on here but it is pretty much everywhere else) then it'd be very close.

Madonna vs. Lady Gaga, Madonna vs. Kylie Minogue Rihanna vs. Beyonce would be a good one too.
  • 4 months later...
  • Author
Leona vs Alexandra Alexandra might win atm, got more momentum

SuBo vs Mariah (xmas versions) SuBo, at least for the next couple of years

Whitney vs Mariah (not likely to happen Whitney does not look into shape) Whitney given a song like Million Dollar Bill

Joe vs Olly (impossible) Joe because of the Simon Cowell effect

Alexandra vs Jls (impossible) JLS would win, unfortunately

Neyo vs JasonDerulo Jason would atm

Taylor Swift vs Miley Cyrus ( taylor :cheer: ) Taylor, she just needs to get to #10 :P

Duffy vs Winehouse Duffy in singles, Wino in albums

Guetta vs Timbo Timbo given the right song, Guetta sells on his collabs

Spears vs Gaga vs Perry vs Rihanna --> OMG the BJ server is SO down GaGa would win, hands down

Joe vs Miley vs Gummy Bear (and the gummy bear wins) Miley wuldn't stand a chance

Kesha vs Gaga GaGa

 

I'd like to see Madonna vs Kylie. Just to see how far a lunatic fanbase can get you :P

Would say Madonna v GaGa but atm there'd be no contest.

Beady Eye (Liam's new band) vs Noel Gallagher would be interesting.

Paramore vs 30 Seconds to Mars

 

Definitely Alexandra Burke Vs. Leona Lewis would be really interesting. My friend has been playing some tracks from leona lewis and i heard she is reinventing herself so that would be one to watch out for.

 

The Duffy Vs Wino would be cool, but as the success of Adele's latest album, it would be awesome to see Wino go up against her. The album charts would be great!

How about Norah Jones Vs Katie Melua?

 

A very old thread, though one I missed at the time, so...

 

The above battle actually happened, in Feb/Mar 2004.

 

Katie was #1 for 3 weeks from 31/1/04, then Norah sneaked in for 2 weeks from 21/2, then Katie fought back with another 3 weeks at #1 from 6/3/04.

 

  • Author
A very old thread, though one I missed at the time, so...

 

The above battle actually happened, in Feb/Mar 2004.

 

Katie was #1 for 3 weeks from 31/1/04, then Norah sneaked in for 2 weeks from 21/2, then Katie fought back with another 3 weeks at #1 from 6/3/04.

 

Well i got both of those albums and found it fun that they were sharing the top spot. Im more of a norah jones fan :D

 

I wonder what the equivalent for this decade would be?

 

Rumer Vs. Laura Marling?

Edited by soundseekerz

Lily Allen Vs Katy Perry :lol: (Not sure, right now, katy perry?)

 

Adele Vs Duffy (Duffy would win)

 

Lady Gaga Vs Madonna (Gaga!)

 

Jason Derulo Vs Ne-Yo (Hard one, not sure, jason derulo has had better material judging the latest stuff)

 

The Script Vs OneRepublic (The Script would win)

 

Take That Vs Westlife (Take That would win)

 

Mariah Vs Whitney (Whitney would win)

 

Girls Aloud Vs Saturdays (GA would win)

 

I do not remember posting this in the slightest, what was i think saying Duffy would win I definitely meant Adele! WTF! lol

 

Rihanna V Beyonce would be good to see, but would want both #1, both big album sellers!

JLS V One Direction V The Wanted :lol:

Leona V Alexandra, Leona would win obv.

Matt V Olly

..loads more.

 

It really depends on material and support from TV/Radio and promo obviously...and the fanbase!

Edited by Karma

I'd love to see the top three acts from each of the seven seasons of X Factor release singles on the same day. So we would have:

Steve Brookstein v G4 v Rowetta (I think she may have came third - or maybe it was Tabby?) v Shayne Ward v Andy Abraham v Journey South v Leona v Ray Quinn v Ben v Leon Jackson v Rhydian v Same Difference v Alexandra v JLS v Eoghan Quigg v Joe McElderry v Olly Murs v Stacey Solomon v Matt Cardle v Rebecca Ferguson v One Direction

 

I guess I'd also have to throw in Diana Vickers (even though she came fourth) and Cher Lloyd (cos she's prob gonna have a post-X Facter chart career)

 

And, they'd all have original songs.

 

Who would make the top 5/10/40/75?

  • Author
I'd love to see the top three acts from each of the seven seasons of X Factor release singles on the same day. So we would have:

Steve Brookstein v G4 v Rowetta (I think she may have came third - or maybe it was Tabby?) v Shayne Ward v Andy Abraham v Journey South v Leona v Ray Quinn v Ben v Leon Jackson v Rhydian v Same Difference v Alexandra v JLS v Eoghan Quigg v Joe McElderry v Olly Murs v Stacey Solomon v Matt Cardle v Rebecca Ferguson v One Direction

 

I guess I'd also have to throw in Diana Vickers (even though she came fourth) and Cher Lloyd (cos she's prob gonna have a post-X Facter chart career)

 

And, they'd all have original songs.

 

Who would make the top 5/10/40/75?

 

Crikey that would one mad chart week lol

 

Top10 (In no particular order - cop out i know lol)

 

JLS

Alexandra Burke

Leona Lewis

One Direction

Olly Murs

Cheryl Lloyd (Depends on the material - More likely a rap artist featured)

 

 

Top 20

 

Shayne Ward

Matt Cardle

Rebecca Ferguson

Joe McElderry

Stacey Solomon

Diana Vickers

 

 

Top 21 - 40

 

Journey South

Andy Abraham

Eoghan Quigg

G4

Leon Jackson

 

 

Top 41 - 75

 

Rowetta

Steve Brookstein

Ray Quinn

Same Difference

 

 

Fail To Chart

 

Rhydian

Ben Mills

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.