1. Rebecca - 10/10

2. Cher - 10/10

3. Matt - 10/10

4. Aiden - 9/10

5. One Direction - 8/10

6. Mary - 8/10

7. Katie - 8/10

8. Paije - 6/10

9. Wagner - 2/10

WTH at that group song- horrid miming and awful choice :mellow:

 

also :mellow: at Cheryl's dress

Still a bizarre choice of song!

 

They are completely and utterly random this year! And I love it! After the crap Elton John week (must we have this yawn fest every year?), it's nice to see a bit of unpredictability back in song choices. I wish they would just abolish theme weeks, or make the themes less restrictive.

Bizzare choice of group performance but I dont care, 'Cant Stop Moving' is a brilliant record that deserved much better. Paije was disastrous at miming and I think Mary was mollested by one of Wand Erection but othewise I again rather enjoyed it unfortunetly.

Surprised JLS are the first group to sing.

It's sorta hard to take JLS seriously when it looks like they have play dough in their ears. :/

Surprised JLS are the first group to sing.

Surprised JLS are actually singing LIVE.

They seem to be out of key, unless my hearing has gone

Who are these tuneless muppets?

 

Kath

This. Is. Painful. :mellow:

YAWNFEST, it just goes on and on. That song is beyond dull, and they were mostly out of tune.

To quote Louis Walsh, those high notes sounded like cats being strangled in an alleyway. Awful.

'Love You More' is such a disgustingly sickly sounding song. I may or may not have thrown up a little halfway through their song.

 

They appear to get worse with every single aswell, I swear they were quite decent at the begining circa 'Beat Again'.

 

Actually, maybe I'm just a bitter old spinster designed to hate love songs? Probably.

I must admit Cher looks better without all the make up, her personality comes out more rather than looking chavvy

Westlife with yet another 20 bpm ballad. :zzz: First time hearing this and will be gutted if it goes top 5 because - like the majority of their songs - it drags on.

 

'Love You More' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 'Safe'

At least they can drag out the same old montage every year for Westlife's annual appearance with what always sounds like the same song.

 

One thing I will credit them for is that they always sing live, and are always extremely strong vocally. Can't believe they're still together after 12 years though, I was in the first year of high school when Swear It Again was released and all of the girls loved them :drama: Seems like a lifetime ago...

JLS were so dull- and Westlife arent much better, but at least their in tune

Both the westlife and jls songs are boring and i agree dull, what about no wwasnt great but safe is a hell of a lot worse.

It was a very typical Westlife safe performance. :teresa:

 

I think Im the only one who like their new single in this forum.

Edited November 14, 201014 yr by Jason

At least they can drag out the same old montage every year for Westlife's annual appearance with what always sounds like the same song.

 

One thing I will credit them for is that they always sing live, and are always extremely strong vocally. Can't believe they're still together after 12 years though, I was in the first year of high school when Swear It Again was released and all of the girls loved them :drama: Seems like a lifetime ago...

 

I'm actually loving the girl in the audience singing the verses really loud and really out of tune. I'm surprised the singers are able to stay in tune. :lol: