November 27, 201014 yr Double elimination then. Long overdue frankly, 14 performances tonight felt like a lifetime, so 10 next week sounds reasonable. Katie/Mary/Wagner bottom 3? Seems fairly predictable but the other four seem to have done enough to stay for another week.
November 27, 201014 yr Rebecca - 9/10 Mary - 8.5/10 Matt - 8.5/10 Cher - 7.5/10 Katie - 7/10 Wagner - 7/10 One Direction - 6.5/10 I won't bother giving comments for the second performances I'll just list them here: Rebecca - 9/10 Cher - 9/10 Matt - 9/10 Mary - 8/10 Katie - 7.5/10 Wagner - 6.5/10 One Direction 5.5/10 I will say the overall standard of the second performances was much more up and down than the first performances... So then overall: Rebecca - 18/20 Matt - 17.5/20 Mary - 16.5/20 Cher - 16.5/20 Katie - 14.5/20 -------------------- ^ Above my semi finalists Wagner - 13.5/20 One Direction - 12/20 I really like Wagner....and from a talent side of things I want him to go....but really I'd have no problem with him making it to the final to annoy people at the expense of Katie. Edited November 27, 201014 yr by Sabrewulf
November 27, 201014 yr Matts second performance was bloody brilliant tonight and it stole the show for.
November 27, 201014 yr Quickfire rates (no comments :drama: ) Wagner - Creep 5/10 Wagner - Addicted To Love 2/10 One Direction - Summer Of '69 5/10 One Direction - You Are So Beautiful 10/10 Mary Byrne - All I Want Is You 6/10 Mary Byrne - Brass In Pocket 4/10 Rebecca Ferguson - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 6/10 Rebecca Ferguson - I Can't Get No Satisfaction 10/10 Katie Waissel - Sex On Fire 4/10 Katie Waissel - Everybody Hurts 1/10 Matt Cardle - I Love Rock N' Roll 7/10 Matt Cardle - Nights In White Satin 10/10 Cher Lloyd - Girlfriend 7/10 Cher Lloyd - Walk This Way 5/10
November 27, 201014 yr Second round: Wagner, missed him :( Maybe a 6 from the clip at the end One Direction - yeah, not bad, not great but 6/10 Mary - definitely Karaoke but confident 5/10 Rebecca - Don't think her voice worked but OK 5/10 Katie - when she got going, not bad 6.5/10 Matt - actually back on Britney form :o 8.5/10 Cher - predictable, not awful 6/10 Overall tonight: Matt Wagner Katie Mary Rebecca/One Direction Cher
November 27, 201014 yr I wouldn't be at all surprised if Wagner gets through avoiding the bottom three. :lol: I think Katie will automatically go with the least public votes with Mary and possibly Cher again in the bottom 2. I'm sure Matt and One Direction will be safe and I'd hope that Rebecca will go through as well.
November 27, 201014 yr 08.5 Cher - Girlfriend 08.5 Mary - All I Want Is You 08.0 One Direction - Summer Of 69 08.0 Katie - Sex On Fire 07.5 Matt - I love Rock N Roll 07.0 Wagner - Creep 07.0 Rebecca - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 09.5 Matt - Nights In White Satin 09.0 One Direction - You Are So Beautiful 08.5 Katie - Everybody Hurts 07.5 Cher - Walk This Way 07.5 Mary - Brass In Pocket 06.0 Rebecca - I Can't Get No Satisfaction 05.0 Wagner - Addicted To Love OVERALL RANK (TONIGHT) 01st One Direction 02nd Matt 03rd Katie 04th Cher 05th Mary 06th Rebecca 07th Wagner
November 27, 201014 yr I'd really like Katie to stay through. She was absolutely on top form tonight. And of course I'd love my Cher to avoid bottom 3!
November 27, 201014 yr Im assuming the person with the lowest public vote automaticaly goes and then the judges save someone from the remaining 2???
November 27, 201014 yr Rankings- 1. Wagner- only fun 1 and he offends everyone :cheer: 2. Mary- love her :heart: 3-7. Everyone else
November 27, 201014 yr I don't actually think there will be a judges vote tommorow Doesn't that usually stop after Week 7 ?
November 27, 201014 yr I hope Katie oes. shes dreadful Katie/Rebecca/1Direction should go All utter dog poo
November 27, 201014 yr I don't actually think there will be a judges vote tommorow Doesn't that usually stop after Week 7 ? Yeah but we've had more contestants this year so we're a little bit behind.
November 27, 201014 yr Id love Rebecca, Wagner and One Direction in the bottom 3 with Wagner going although i am well aware my choice of top 3 wont happen.
November 27, 201014 yr I don't actually think there will be a judges vote tommorow Doesn't that usually stop after Week 7 ? it does usually- but maybe this year as there is more contestants, they'll limit it- next week they'll be 5 so I think then the two with the least votes will go although it wouldnt surprise me if the two with the least votes did go straight home assuming it does work the same way- I think Mary or Katie will go automatically and the other two will be Mary/Katie and Wagner Edited November 27, 201014 yr by chart wizard
November 27, 201014 yr I would love Katie to be in the final, but I don't want her to win X-Factor and get saddled with $h!te songs, etc, so I suppose I won't be devastated if she goes tomorrow. I'd rather it be via the sing-off though than with her coming bottom. At the end of the day, though Katie obviously has less voters, I think people who are Katie fans are probably very into her and will follow her career avidly, whereas people who vote for, say, Rebecca or Matt, might not buy anything past the first single, certainly the first album. I realise that may be generalising but look at Joe: he must've had, what, at least four million votes or so in the final, yet his album sells about 1/40 of that. Katie has a less generally-marketable style than, say, Leona (who in the Xmas prezzies stakes is marketable to teenage and younger girls and mums as well as just fans: don't know what demographic you'd try to market Katie to). If Katie and Mary leave tomorrow I will still be somewhat happy cos Wagner will have a good chance of making the final (I think he has a good chance of winning floating voters!!!). Ideally it would be Cher and Mary, though I do like Ms Byrne, but out of the supposed 'bottom four' she's only my third favourite. Wonder who would go if it was Katie v. Mary in the sing off :o I think It would surely go to deadlock (Louis and Dannii for Mary, Simon and Cheryl for Katie)
November 27, 201014 yr http://twitter.com/Ianhwatkins Ianhwatkins - Having met Louis Walsh many times over the years ,he still makes my skin crawl! What a sad,desperate,rude excuse for a man!
November 27, 201014 yr I thought Matt and Rebecca were awesome tonight, the best two IMHO. Katie was okay on Sex On Fire, but average on the 2nd song.
Create an account or sign in to comment