Jump to content

Featured Replies

Lena: Unser Song Fur Deutschland - Semi Final 2

 

My order so far:

1) Push Forward - 9.5/10 - Strong vocals, big ending, amazing production. Just about perfect!

2) A Million And One - 8.5/10 - Very contemporary with nice production.

3) At All - 8/10 - Pleasant enough, I think it's a grower. Reminds me of Atomic Kitten's You Are.

4) Teenage Girls - 7.5/10 - Nice and gentle, and I agree with the country comparison.

 

  • Replies 177
  • Views 14.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Satellite was by no means an 11/10! 11/10s are by law INSTANTLY AMAZING.

 

I am watching this with mild interest but paying little attention.

1 || A Good Day || 09.5/10

2 || Push Forward || 09/10

3 || At All || 08/10

4 || A Million And One || 08/10

5 || Teenage Girls || 04.5/10

 

Now that's what i'm talkin about! I really really liked that one

Satellite was by no means an 11/10! 11/10s are by law INSTANTLY AMAZING.

 

I am watching this with mild interest but paying little attention.

I didn't take as long to grown on me as it did most people on here

Lena: Unser Song Fur Deutschland - Semi Final 2

 

My order so far:

1) Push Forward - 9.5/10 - Strong vocals, big ending, amazing production. Just about perfect!

2) A Million And One - 8.5/10 - Very contemporary with nice production.

3) A Good Day - 8.5/10 - Love the chorus and message, very pleasant.

4) At All - 8/10 - Pleasant enough, I think it's a grower. Reminds me of Atomic Kitten's You Are.

5) Teenage Girls - 7.5/10 - Nice and gentle, and I agree with the country comparison.

 

Satellite was by no means an 11/10! 11/10s are by law INSTANTLY AMAZING.

 

I am watching this with mild interest but paying little attention.

 

I disagree, it was a 7/10 for me initially but became my favourite song of the year - people are allowed to let songs grow!

 

Similarly, Nadine's Insatiable by that reckoning was an 11/10 but this is false as it turned out to be a 9/10 at best.

Shame my least favourites are clearly being pushed the most here. Hope the German public can at least send one of the two that I love to the final.

 

I appreciate that Stefan and Lena wrote this song, but it's the weakest song on the album for me. Last place in ESC would most certainly be a possibility.

Lena: Unser Song Fur Deutschland - Semi Final 2

 

My order so far:

1) Push Forward - 9.5/10 - Strong vocals, big ending, amazing production. Just about perfect!

2) A Million And One - 8.5/10 - Very contemporary with nice production.

3) Mama Told Me - 8.5/10 - Love the big brass production and a really good song.

4) A Good Day - 8.5/10 - Love the chorus and message, very pleasant.

5) At All - 8/10 - Pleasant enough, I think it's a grower. Reminds me of Atomic Kitten's You Are.

6) Teenage Girls - 7.5/10 - Nice and gentle, and I agree with the country comparison.

 

I definitely think this was the stronger semi final :D

 

Biggest cheers for Push Forward, Mama Told Me and A Million And One :)
Biggest cheers for Push Forward, Mama Told Me and A Million And One :)

 

Seems pretty clear that they'll go further, the audience was completely dead to the other three :lol: Very pleased with the first two - Mama Told Me has grown on me since I keep being subjected to it but I don't think it should be picked for Eurovision by any stretch of the imagination. She doesn't have a winner this year I don't think but Taken By A Stranger, Push Forward and A Million and One won't completely embarrass her, and could be shock top 5's/low top 10's. Maybe, What Happened To Me and Mama Told Me imo would take Germany back to the bottom ten.

Hooray!! Well done German public :D
Great to see those two go forward - if they and Taken By A Stranger can be the top three in the final, with any one of them going to ESC, I'll be very happy!

1 || A Good Day || 09.5/10

2 || Push Forward || 09/10

3 || Mama Told Me || 08.5/10

4 || At All || 08/10

5 || A Million And One || 08/10

6 || Teenage Girls || 04.5/10

 

 

 

Rich and Phil in disagreement Shock. :o

1 || A Good Day || 09.5/10

2 || Push Forward || 09/10

3 || Mama Told Me || 08.5/10

4 || At All || 08/10

5 || A Million And One || 08/10

6 || Teenage Girls || 04.5/10

Rich and Phil in disagreement Shock. :o

 

my 1st, 2nd and 6th favourites went through to the final, your 2nd, 3rd and 5th favourites went through!

 

Not sure what I missed in A Good Day which you loved so much, will have to let it grow on me I think.

Sadly, I thought all of the songs tonight were pretty dull, even Push Forward disappointed me based on what I had read prior to hearing it. It was the best song this evening, but there were four better tracks in the first semi. Taken By A Stranger to win.
1st, 2nd & 3rd favourites through :D Just Good News from the 1st semi missed out for me, so 5 out of 6 is pretty good :cheer:
my 1st, 2nd and 6th favourites went through to the final, your 2nd, 3rd and 5th favourites went through!

 

Not sure what I missed in A Good Day which you loved so much, will have to let it grow on me I think.

It was just a nice funky wee track i thought.

 

 

I'm just listening to the album for the first time now.

 

I still haven't got Me And My Cassette Player :drama:

Sadly, I thought all of the songs tonight were pretty dull, even Push Forward disappointed me based on what I had read prior to hearing it. It was the best song this evening, but there were four better tracks in the first semi. Taken By A Stranger to win.

 

I love it but Push Forward sounded significantly more boring live than on the studio version somehow :lol: This isn't a good sign for Eurovision potential I guess...

 

It was just a nice funky wee track i thought.

I'm just listening to the album for the first time now.

 

I still haven't got Me And My Cassette Player :drama:

 

Well now it's crashed straight out you could send it to BJSC at some point :o

 

My Cassette Player is great, highlights being Satellite, Bee, Love Me, Not Following, Mr Curiosity and My Same :wub: Not entirely sure why Touch A New Day was a single though...

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.