Maybe (and hopefully) it's not for a regular judge, and just a guest one instead? Although from what I've seen they use to be BIG names, big enough to not needing the job and too busy to take it full-time.

If this is true (which I highly doubt), why aren't they considering Rochelle? She's had the same amount of experience as Frankie, and is girlfriend to a running-up xfactor group - thee biggest and successful group to come out of xfactor, JLS's Marvin. I can picture Rochelle doing a better job than Frankie any day.

 

The press are just choosing to say Frankie's gonna be a judge because of the Cheryl comparissons. Time will tell, I guess.

If this is true (which I highly doubt), why aren't they considering Rochelle? She's had the same amount of experience as Frankie, and is girlfriend to a running-up xfactor group - thee biggest and successful group to come out of xfactor, JLS's Marvin. I can picture Rochelle doing a better job than Frankie any day.

I agree, I think Rochelle would do a lot more for the bands image as a judge then Frankie would. No offense to Frankie but she just seems a little immature, which is fine but just not right as a reality tv judge/mentor. Plus Rochelle's also got tv experience that Frankie doesn't have from doing 'Smile'

Edited April 17, 201114 yr by kimkamkim

Plus Rochelle's also got tv experience that Frankie doesn't have from doing 'Smile'

 

OMG I completely forgot about that! Ahh I used to watch that back in the day :)

Would LOVE for this to be true! It practically guarantees The Saturdays a slot if it IS true :wub:

 

Oh and LOL at people thinking Rochelle would be the best replacement for Frankie :mellow: The public will find it a lot harder to warm to Rochelle than Frankie, so those claims are ludicrous, imo :lol:

Would LOVE for this to be true! It practically guarantees The Saturdays a slot if it IS true :wub:

 

Oh and LOL at people thinking Rochelle would be the best replacement for Frankie :mellow: The public will find it a lot harder to warm to Rochelle than Frankie, so those claims are ludicrous, imo :lol:

 

Why would they find it harder to 'warm to Rochelle'?

Tbf I think the idea that any of The Saturdays will get within a sniff of a part on the biggest TV show in the UK is laughable! If any of this turns out to be true I will be pleased to see them getting some exposure but this sounds like a total work of fiction to me. They're a big success yes, but I'm sure most of the UK would struggle to name a Saturday - having them on X Factor as any sort of replacement or fill-in would be akin to getting someone from The Wanted to replace Louis!

Why would they find it harder to 'warm to Rochelle'?

I dunno. She just gives off the sort of vibe where I feel the public won't warm to her as much as they would with Frankie. I think they'd find her bitchy and stuff. I guess that's just me, but I dunno. I believe Frankie will be the easiest for the public to sympathise with, particularly with her very public break up with Dougie and her new relationship etc. I dunno. That's just the impression I get.

I believe Frankie will be the easiest for the public to sympathise with, particularly with her very public break up with Dougie and her new relationship etc. I dunno. That's just the impression I get.

 

So your suggesting she should be a judge because she's been in the public eye after a break up? Now that's ludacris.

 

I don't see any of this happening anyway tbh.

I dunno. She just gives off the sort of vibe where I feel the public won't warm to her as much as they would with Frankie. I think they'd find her bitchy and stuff. I guess that's just me, but I dunno. I believe Frankie will be the easiest for the public to sympathise with, particularly with her very public break up with Dougie and her new relationship etc. I dunno. That's just the impression I get.

She won't get much sympathy for that. She got all of the blame when Dougie went to rehab.

The only blame she got was from McFly fans :lol: If it was Frankie who went to Rehab, Saturdays fans would be blaming Dougie etc.

 

@2ndAdventure, I'm not suggesting that at all. I'm saying that because she's in the public eye more than the others (topping Sexiest polls/coming highest out of the Saturdays etc. too) the public have some sort of connection with her. Rochelle, to me personally has a pretty hard exterior. I find her hard to like at times.

I find her hard to like at times.

 

On 24/7 when they were in LA being filmed by the pool, Frankie didn't really rub off that great did she. She abrubtly puts an end to Mollies ping-pong game by throwing the ball off the table (or something like that) followed by "Nobodies giving me any attention!" :mellow:

 

She comes across really immature at times.

On 24/7 when they were in LA being filmed by the pool, Frankie didn't really rub off that great did she. She abrubtly puts an end to Mollies ping-pong game by throwing the ball off the table (or something like that) followed by "Nobodies giving me any attention!" :mellow:

 

She comes across really immature at times.

I haven't seen them 24/7 episodes, so I wouldn't know :lol: But I'm assuming that's a show that goes back stage and behind the scenes etc.? I'm pretty sure we'd all see a completely different side to Cheryl if they were following her for a week 24 hours of the day or whatever. We all have immaturities in ourselves and I see what you're saying but for when it matters, I personally believe Frankie will be the easiest and most accessible Saturday for the public to get and warm to etc.

On 24/7 when they were in LA being filmed by the pool, Frankie didn't really rub off that great did she. She abrubtly puts an end to Mollies ping-pong game by throwing the ball off the table (or something like that) followed by "Nobodies giving me any attention!"

 

She comes across really immature at times.

 

I loved Frankie for that reason - We do see a different side to her! It wasn't selfish it was just her being her. I respect her for that and everyone is immature she has the best personality of all the Saturdays - I do agree with Jonjo Frankie is the best option followed by Una.

 

I also remember reading last year that Simon said he loved Simon and she was backstage at MANY Xfactor shows!

Edited April 18, 201114 yr by lee wallace

It wont happen anyway. They've got more high-profile people like Mell B in the running who practically confirmed she's got the job a week or two ago.

It wont happen anyway. They've got more high-profile people like Mell B in the running who practically confirmed she's got the job a week or two ago.

 

considering Cheryl is definitely leaving i highly doubt that.

In the Uk i'm sure many people would rather see Frankie over Mel B

 

But i think it's fair to say it will be between (Mel B, Frankie, Pixie Lott from The Simon's View) I think he will want to have a UK girl on the panel still.

Mel B would be fantastic! (Far better than that mess Geri was on Popstars) I really love her and she is a true personality who will tell it like it is. She was particularly amazing on Celebrity Juice this week :wub:

Mel B would be fantastic! (Far better than that mess Geri was on Popstars) I really love her and she is a true personality who will tell it like it is. She was particularly amazing on Celebrity Juice this week :wub:

Yes she would be great!!! She was so funny on Celebrity Juice :D (When are the Sats going on there anyway . . . . ) But please no Pixie, she was rubbish as a guest judge. I can just remember her being a really boring.

Pixie was stunning.