Posted April 19, 201114 yr What songs do you think that REALLY shouldn't be on the Celebration album set(s). It would be great if you could give a reason too!.
April 19, 201114 yr Author For Me: Burning Up & Borderline Burning Up didn't have a worldwide release and I would take Borderline out because you don't really need 5 singles from one album on GH cd. I would keep Everybody because that was her first ever single and I just prefer Holiday and Lucky Star better than Borderline. Dress You Up It's a classic Madonna song I know and it's iconic too but I don't really like it. (I would put Angel in it's place) Secret For some reason in the last few years the song really bores me apart from her live version from the drowned world tour is excellent. Revolver (ft. Lil Wayne) It's not for me, would of suited Hard Candy better.
April 19, 201114 yr Hmm, I think I'd agree with you SC :D Except for Secret :lol: For Revolver especially, after hearing Broken which would have been a SMASH if released.
April 20, 201114 yr Author Really?. I think American Pie should of been on GHV2 but not on Celebration.
April 20, 201114 yr Justify my Love, Secret, Erotica. I can't stand those songs! So BORING! I would replace them with Give It 2 Me, True Blue (it was a number one, how it didn't appear on the album I'll never know), and Jump. The reason why I would put them on the album - I LOVE them! :wub:
April 20, 201114 yr Author Omg! I love Erotica that's an all time classic for me. Justify My love too just for it's outrage it caused.
April 21, 201114 yr Really?. Yeah lol. I know i'm in the minority but I find it so catchy! Line 'em up and knock 'em down! :wub:
April 21, 201114 yr Only track for me would be 'Burning up' as no international release. They should have put so much more on this album, many classics were missed such as This used to be my playground, True Blue, You'll See and Gambler to mention just a few! Edited April 21, 201114 yr by thtr
April 22, 201114 yr Justify my Love, Secret, Erotica. I can't stand those songs! So BORING! I would replace them with Give It 2 Me, True Blue (it was a number one, how it didn't appear on the album I'll never know), and Jump. The reason why I would put them on the album - I LOVE them! :wub: They're the exact three I'd take off too! And maybe Die Another Day. I think all the songs should've been in their original single versions too, in order to give fans something different from what they've got on the albums and in order to create a bit more space. As much as I love the 6 minute album version of Holiday it's not really suitable for a Greatest Hits package I think.
April 22, 201114 yr Author Is Erotica and Justify My Love that bad then?. I agree about Holiday, Everybody got edited for the album so I can't see why holiday didn't as there are plenty of edits about.
