Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

I meant to do this ages ago :lol: Since we recently had a rate for Aphrodite I think it'd be nice to do an updated one for X. It won't be a totally fair comparison but we

will have a good idea :D

 

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/38/Kylie_-_X.jpg

 

Rules:

 

Rate each song a score between 1 and 10

Limit of 4 10's

Each song must have a score

One 11 and One -1 may be given, this is optional.

You have until 12th May, 2 weeks today to submit your rate.

Post it here, unless you are toally ashamed in which case, pm me.

Songs:

 

2 Hearts

Like A Drug

In My Arms

Speakerphone

Sensitized

Heart Beat Rock

The One

No More Rain

All I See

Stars

Wow

Nu-Di-Ty

Cosmic

Magnetic Electric

Rippin' Up The Disco

White Diamond (Ballad Version)

  • Replies 28
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

2 Hearts 05

Like A Drug 11

In My Arms 08

Speakerphone 04

Sensitized 05

Heart Beat Rock 04

The One 10

No More Rain 06

All I See 06

Stars 08

Wow 10

Nu-Di-Ty 05

Cosmic 07

Magnetic Electric 09

Rippin' Up The Disco 09

White Diamond (Ballad Version) 06

( love the live fast version)

2 Hearts - 10

Like A Drug - 8

In My Arms - 9

Speakerphone - 8

Sensitized - 7

Heart Beat Rock - 8

The One - 10

No More Rain - 8

All I See - 9

Stars - 11

Wow - 10

Nu-Di-Ty - 7

Cosmic - 8

Magnetic Electric - 9

Rippin' Up The Disco - 8

White Diamond (Ballad Version) - 8

 

I absolutley love this album!! :wub: :wub: :wub:

  • Author

That was quick :o

I get to make a spreadsheet now :w00t:

07 2 Hearts

10 Like A Drug

08 In My Arms

11 Speakerphone

09 Sensitized

03 Heart Beat Rock

10 The One

10 No More Rain

07 All I See

09 Stars

09 Wow

08 Nu-Di-Ty

07 Cosmic

08 Magnetic Electric

09 Rippin' Up The Disco

08 White Diamond (Ballad Version)

 

There is a good album in there, just a few guff tracks too. Speakerphone is my favourite Kylie song though.

2 Hearts - 6

Like A Drug - 7

In My Arms - 10

Speakerphone - 9

Sensitized - 8

Heart Beat Rock - 4

The One - 11

No More Rain - 9

All I See - 7

Stars - 5

Wow - 6

Nu-Di-Ty - 7

Cosmic - 8

Magnetic Electric - 6

Rippin' Up The Disco - 4

White Diamond (Ballad Version) - 8

Edited by Dannyboy

08 2 Hearts

08 Like A Drug

09 In My Arms

07 Speakerphone

08 Sensitized

06 Heart Beat Rock

09 The One

08 No More Rain

07 All I See

07 Stars

11 Wow

07 Nu-Di-Ty

08 Cosmic

07 Magnetic Electric

07 Rippin' Up The Disco

09 White Diamond (Ballad Version)

 

Not a bad album by any means but Aphrodite has nothing below an 8 for me, whereas there are seven less than that on X. The latter three singles were all great though, shame she led with 2 Hearts, which though a decent song, is as far away from lead single material as it gets. I'd personally have included Do It Again on the album, and the uptempo version of White Diamond.

  • Author

Quick thing, can people please follow gooddelta's example of laying out their rate? It is easier for me :lol: Oh and if you change it, tell me.

 

11 | 2 Hearts

08 | Like A Drug

06 | In My Arms

07 | Speakerphone

08 | Sensitized

04 | Heart Beat Rock

10 | The One

09 | No More Rain

07 | All I See

10 | Stars

06 | Wow

09 | Nu-Di-Ty

07 | Cosmic

08 | Magnetic Electric

10 | Rippin' Up The Disco

04 | White Diamond (Ballad Version)

X :wub:

 

6.5 2 Hearts

10 Like A Drug

09 In My Arms

10 Speakerphone

08.5 Sensitized

08 Heart Beat Rock

11 The One

07 No More Rain

07 All I See

07 Stars

08 Wow

08 Nu-Di-Ty

06 Cosmic

06 Magnetic Electric

7.5 Rippin' Up The Disco

07 White Diamond (Ballad Version)

 

 

Quick thing, can people please follow gooddelta's example of laying out their rate? It is easier for me :lol: Oh and if you change it, tell me.

 

11 | 2 Hearts

08 | Like A Drug

06 | In My Arms

07 | Speakerphone

08 | Sensitized

04 | Heart Beat Rock

10 | The One

09 | No More Rain

07 | All I See

10 | Stars

06 | Wow

09 | Nu-Di-Ty

07 | Cosmic

08 | Magnetic Electric

10 | Rippin' Up The Disco

04 | White Diamond (Ballad Version)

 

I have finally found someone that adores 2 Hearts like me! :lol:

 

2 Hearts - 8

Like A Drug - 9

In My Arms - 8

Speakerphone - 7

Sensitized - 7

Heart Beat Rock - 4

The One - 11

No More Rain - 8

All I See - 3

Stars - 9

Wow - 6

Nu-Di-Ty - 1

Cosmic - 4

Magnetic Electric - 9

Rippin' Up The Disco - 6

White Diamond (Ballad Version) - 10

(The live version is too high-pitched, even for Kylie who can easily reach her highest pitch during Your disco needs you performance).

08 2 Hearts

09 Like A Drug

10 In My Arms

07 Speakerphone

05 Sensitized

06 Heart Beat Rock

08 The One

06 No More Rain

06 All I See

06 Stars

09 Wow

05 Nu-Di-Ty

02 Cosmic

07 Magnetic Electric

07 Rippin' Up The Disco

08 White Diamond (Ballad Version)

 

 

 

  • Author

Thanks everyone who has voted so far :cheer:

 

 

Some of the votes are varied but like a drug and the one seem overall very consistant.

 

Same with The One, quite alot of 10s and 11s

09 | 2 Hearts

10 | Like A Drug

07 | In My Arms

07 | Speakerphone

10 | Sensitized

07 | Heart Beat Rock

10 | The One

05 | No More Rain

05 | All I See

08 | Stars

11 | Wow

08 | Nu-Di-Ty

07 | Cosmic

08 | Magnetic Electric

09 | Rippin' Up The Disco

10 | White Diamond (Ballad Version)

2 hearts 7

Like a drug 9

In my arms 7

Speakerphone 3

Sensitized 6

Heart beat rock 4

The One 10

No more rain 6

All I see 6

Stars 7

Wow 8

Nu-di-ty 3

Cosmic 6

Magnetic Electric 9

Rippin up the disco 7

White diamond 9

8 2 Hearts

8 Like A Drug

11 In My Arms

9 Speakerphone

8 Sensitized

9 Heart Beat Rock

9 The One

9 No More Rain

7 All I See

7 Stars

10 Wow

10 Nu-Di-Ty

7 Cosmic

8 Magnetic Electric

8 Rippin' Up The Disco

9 White Diamond (Ballad Version)

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.