I'd be happy with Kelly, Gary and Louis.. Tulisa would be the wrong move though. Surely they could find someone better ?

Kelly Rowland seems like a great choice if it's true, she's always been my favourite member of Destiny's Child, she just comes across as incredibly likeable and she could definitely pick up where Dannii left off. Could do a lot for her UK profile too, she's always sort of been 'there' but not somebody you could call a household name despite her growing clutch of hit singles. Be interesting to see her on the front page of the newspapers day in day out.

 

Tulisa definitely isn't the way to go for the fourth judge, I really hope they find somebody else.

Out of The Saturdays I'd like to see Una Healy there, she comes across as the most mature of them all.

 

This is exactly what I was thinking the other day, I think she'd be really good as a judge! :)

 

Apparently Kelly Rowland has been confirmed as the new judge, say the Sun if its true

I'd be happy with Kelly. A bigger star even now than Tulisa I'm sure, and let's not forget her Destiny's Child days. She's essentially Cheryl in 5-10 years, except DC were much bigger than GA. I do like a sassy black woman too, and with judges as DULL as Gary and (possibly) Tulisa it'd be her I tune in for.

Tulisa will be probably get Dappy to help her with selections at the judges house stage it probably be a large garage :D that's if she gets to be a judge.

I would love Kelly Rowland to be a judge! I can see her becoming a public favourite, and it'd be a fantastic profile boost for her upcoming album. :wub:

Tulisa will be probably get Dappy to help her with selections at the judges house stage it probably be a large garage :D that's if she gets to be a judge.

:lol:

 

If Kelly does become a judge, she'll be the only reason I'll watch it.

I would love Kelly Rowland to be a judge! I can see her becoming a public favourite, and it'd be a fantastic profile boost for her upcoming album. :wub:

 

 

It'd almost be like J-Lo and American Idol i.e a female singer who has been flopping getting a spot on a successful show and turning their career around :D

Now that Gary is a judge - hopefully this will be the end for take that.

Now that Gary is a judge - hopefully this will be the end for take that.

 

I'd have thought Take That were calling it a day anyway after this album and tour. They've come full circle now that Bobby's back! They can hardly go back to a four and I can't see Williams wanting to commit himself to being part of a group again after this.

 

Kath

Now that Gary is a judge - hopefully this will be the end for take that.

 

He can easily persue a music career while being on the X.

 

It'd almost be like J-Lo and American Idol i.e a female singer who has been flopping getting a spot on a successful show and turning their career around :D

Or it could be more like Dannii Minogue?! :lol:

I read an article a couple of days ago that suggested Robbie Williams is already helping to write songs for the next TT album...

It's going to be such a yawnfest.

Jamelia would be simply AMAZING

Jamelia would be simply AMAZING

Doubt it :lol:

Jamelia would be the tits no doubt about it. I mean she gave birth to the legendary quote:

 

"...she is though isn't she?"

 

HBIC.

So glad Cheryl has left and we are replacing her with someone actually talented, Kelly Rowland :wub:

So glad Cheryl has left and we are replacing her with someone actually talented, Kelly Rowland :wub:

I think this is one of the most sensible posts you've made Shelli!