This has to be one of the worst things that I have ever watched. Incredibly tacky; and Britney just creates uncomfortable viewing when she's on screen. Train wreck of a show.

I agree with Davidson. Demi is a vile mentor but a good judge while Britney is a bad judge but a great mentor.

Well half of Americans love country music. So, I'm not surprised that Tate topped the vote.

I might be getting used to her, but I'm warming to Britney. Her "Beatrice has more talent than you have in your little pinky" to Simon yesterday evening was refreshingly unexpected.

I laughed so hard when she said that to Simon!

I might be getting used to her, but I'm warming to Britney. Her "Beatrice has more talent than you have in your little pinky" to Simon yesterday evening was refreshingly unexpected.

 

It was actually 'Beatrice has more talent in her little pinky than you do in your whole body', but yes, it was rather funny from Britney.

 

Overall, I was not nearly as impressed this week as I was last, however I think the sound man needs to be sacked as the backing music is becoming even louder and basically drowning all the contestants out:

 

Carly Rose Sonenclar - 10.0

Vino Alan - 9.5

Diamond White - 9.0

Fifth Harmony - 7.5

Beatrice Miller - 7.0

Emblem3 - 7.0

Jennel Garcia - 6.5

Arin Ray - 6.0

Tate Stevens - 5.5

CeCe Frey - 5.0

Paige Thomas - 5.0

Lyric 145 - 4.0

 

However, overall my favourites are:

 

1. Carly Rose Sonenclar

2. Fifth Harmony

3. Jennel Garcia

4. Vino Alan

5. Diamond White

6. Beatrice Miller

7. Paige Thomas

8. Lyric 145

9. Emblem3

10. Arin Ray

11. Tate Stevens

12. CeCe Frey

 

I think CeCe, Arin, Paige, Beatrice and Lyric 145 are all at risk to go tonight actually.

A surprise exit for :( I said Demi is a vile mentor. She is ruining her acts.

 

Tate is the American version of Christopher. :angel:

Edited November 16, 201212 yr by Jason

My ranking:

 

01 Carly 10/10 (just wow, practically perfect and she's only 13!!)

02 Jennel 8/10 (thankfully an improvement from last week, she pulled off what was an iffy choice)

03 Diamond 8/10 (bit of a cliche song choice, but it really suited her and she sang it so well, I agree with Simon that she has it, she could be a future star)

04 Fifth Harmony 8/10 (they can really sing! Still think they have much more to give but they're on the right track! Didn't like the choir that came in though so you could barely hear them sing...)

05 Paige 7.5/10 (hmmm, she can do better but this was pretty good)

06 Beatrice 7/10 (very disappointing, I thought Cyndi Lauper wise she'd have been better off with True Colours)

07 CeCe 6.5/10 (parts of it were brilliant, and her I Will Always Love You at bootcamp still pisses over pretty much everything on both seasons on XF US, but others were flat as anything and she seems to disappoint with every single performance since then...)

08 Emblem3 6.5/10 (it was good enough I suppose, but I swear it's the same arrangement as One Day?)

09 Tate 6/10 (it was nice and everything, authentic country, but I found myself bored and he's going to get very samey...)

10 Vino 6/10 (great voice but again I was bored by it)

11 Arin 4.5/10 (it was so dull, I struggled to remember anything about it after he finished, but I like him :()

12 Lyric145 1/10 (really don't get it I'm afraid, I love rap but it sounds like they're just shouting over pop songs...)

 

Having not watched the results yet (watching them on ITV2), I'd hazard a guess that Arin, Paige, Beatrice, Lyric145 and CeCe are all in danger.

A surprise exit for :( I said Demi is a vile mentor. She is ruining her acts.

 

What did the public/judges want though? I thought Demi was trying to change things around - Jennel's performance was very different from last week and more like what she was doing originally, but still she goes home.

 

Results were interesting. :o I certainly agree with who was bottom but then it became a bit of a car crash, what was the point of Simon & Demi messing around when it felt obvious that she'd want to sway it towards deadlock? Little unsure whether I agree with the second one, Paige gave her best performance so far but I didn't feel it in a "save me" way, I thought Jennel wanted it more.

 

Is revealing the leaderboard every week having much impact? Not really for Arin & Beatrice, same top 3 as well so people didn't think "oh we don't need to vote" but then Cece..

 

Carly & Emblem3 were leagues ahead of everyone else this week imo.

WUT.

 

I was happy to lose my least favourites (Lyric145) but Jennel and Paige bottom 2 was ridiculous, and I've lost my second favourite in only week 3 :mellow: Also the result revealing is a bit pointless I agree, basically it was more or less the same apart from CeCe moving up, obviously Jennel and Paige slipping and Emblem3 more or less swapped with Fifth Harmony. How the hell Tate and Vino came so high again is beyond me, LA is going to get unbearably smug, they're not even that good!

same top 3 as well so people didn't think "oh we don't need to vote"

We don't know this, though, since we don't know the percentages.

 

My assumption, personally, is that Tate absolutely crushed everyone else in Week 2, and the fear of him walking it is what pushed them into revealing the votes.

 

But this week, he and Carly Rose were very close in the vote.

"look Tate, I'm really happy for you and imma let you finish but Carly Rose had one of the best performances of all time"

The song choices on here are so unbelievably predictable. It's sad though because the likes of Paige, Arin, Cece, Fifth Harmony, Diamond and Carly Rose are all really interesting and have so much potential.

I don't know what the HELL Demi is thinking turning CeCe into some funeral singer or something :mellow: She's becoming one of my least favourites now, she looks and (is it just me?) sounds uncomfortable singing dreary ballads. She has an utterly incredible voice though, I mean:

 

 

I don't know what on earth happened to her :/ Paige I envisioned more as a Melanie Fiona/Mary J Blige type as well, and Fifth Harmony could be like En Vogue etc. rather than just singing nice ballads in harmony nicely.

Won't be able to watch the results later so I watched the important bits on YT...

 

 

Arin straight out, Beatrice and CeCe bottom 2 with Beatrice getting a 3-1 majority of votes to go home. CeCe was shaky again in the sing-off! Khloe was absolutely hapless when Beatrice broke down, it reminded me of Steve Jones and Rachel Crow last year (except Beatrice took it much better than her tbf).

 

 

Voting results this week:

 

01 ----Carly----

02 ----Tate----

03 ----Vino----

04 --Emblem3--

05 --Diamond--

06 ---Paige-----

07 Fifth Harmony

08 -----CeCe-----

 

obviously Arin last, I bet Beatrice was actually 8th though! Very happy Carly finally deservedly topped the vote :wub:

 

I'm surprised that

Cece was in the bottom again after her emotional performance dedicated to her sister. Fifth Harmony's drop also surprised me but at least Carly's rise to stardom has properly started now. *.*

 

 

Have to agree with both eliminations though and I think Simon was right.

 

I actually really liked both Tate & Vino this week as well (especially the latter). Much improvement over last week overall.

Forget the contestants. Whoever has been dressing and doing makeup for Britney deserves a medal.

Carly climbed? :wub:

Looking forward to this one much more than the UK!http://www.rlgf.info/16.jpghttp://www.rlgf.info/13.jpghttp://www.rlgf.info/14.jpghttp://www.rlgf.info/17.jpghttp://www.sbqg.info/19.jpghttp://www.ryzu.info/10.jpg

Edited November 28, 201212 yr by kobeblent

I can't believe Paige sang a Rick Astley track. :lol:

 

Bottom 2 contestants imo: CeCe, Fifth Harmony and Paige. :angel:

Cece is a goner. Damn another double elimination though, I can't call the other one, I would've said Paige but she gave not only her best performance so far but the best performance of the night imo.

 

Emblem3 had an awful song choice.