Good write ups.

 

Since U Been Gone is by far the best thing I've heard from Kelly.

 

 

GA rightfully at number 1 - their production team are great. In general the material got better as they went on (ignoring Something New).

Thank you all for your kind words people :) Glad you enjoyed the countdown. I had great fun doing it!

It was a great countdown, really enjoyed it.

 

I agree with Girls Aloud and Leona Lewis being so high.

 

I was really surprised that Samantha Mumba was in line to release Sound of The Underground, until Girls Aloud came along and got the song. I can actually imagine Samanthas voice singing that song. Her career could have been so much different if she released that as the first single from her delayed and cancelled second album. Oh well, I suppose it gave Girls Aloud a great start instead.

Amazing top 5

 

Alexandra >>>>>> the rest though

Thank you Pensmith for doing this, I can see that such a lot of effort has been put into it and its been a real pleasure to read all your commentaries about each act!

I enjoyed this countdown the top 5 are probably spot on althought I do think One Direction should probably have been in the top 10 instead of Diana.

I enjoyed this countdown the top 5 are probably spot on althought I do think One Direction should probably have been in the top 10 instead of Diana.

 

No way! :o The top 10 is mostly fantastic as it is with Diana being the obvious highlight! :wub:

Olly and that picture, ooft :wub: Glad he made top 5, he's one of my favourites here.

 

Disappointed Kelly didn't beat GA in the end but I love them too (it's just Kelly is my ultimate fave). Very glad Carrie made top 10 despite her lack of UK success compared to the others in the top 10, she's my 2nd fave of all time behind Kelly.

 

And thanks for doing this most of all ThePensmith ^_^

Just caught up on this, a fantastic countdown and brilliant write ups. Thanks.

Edited April 14, 201312 yr by Flatcap