Songs confirmed so far are:

"Your Song" by Elton John

"Say" by John Mayer

"More Than Words" by Extreme

 

No New York in this episode!

 

THE GLEE CLUB FACES THEIR TOUGHEST CHALLENGE YET ON AN ALL-NEW "GLEE" THURSDAY, APRIL 11 ON FOX

 

The members of New Directions are prepping for Regionals, but when an unthinkable event occurs at McKinley High, perspectives are put into order in the all-new "Shooting Star" episode of GLEE airing on Thursday, April 11 (9:00-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. (GLE-418) (TV-14 D, L)

Can't wait to see this, aww no New York :(

 

It would be cool if they showed Quinn at her uni :)

After reading about what was going to happen I was unsure whether they'd be able to pull it off but I enjoyed the episode, it was so emotional and tense in the middle section. I take it this won't be the last we've seen of Sue..? Her first version of events didn't really seem to fit but it all made more sense in the end.

 

The performance of "Say" was great too, up there with the best of the season. :wub:

I thought the shooting was initial distasteful, but the scenes in the choir room/during the aftermath worked really well. I guessed that Becky would have been responsible for the gun - Lauren Potter was fab in her short scenes with Brittany and Sue. I'm guessing

Unique

is the catfish? There's really no one else that it could be!

 

Oh, and songs wise - I didn't care for the Ryder/Sam solos, but "Say" was beautiful :wub:

Edited April 12, 201312 yr by THEO.

I'm guessing

Unique

is the catfish? There's really no one else that it could be!

 

What was said about the

ringtone

shot that down for me, idk.

Kitty

could just as easily be lying.

 

What was said about the

ringtone

shot that down for me, idk.

Kitty

could just as easily be lying.

 

Kitty

wouldn't need to lie about being into someone, plus

she

has

Puck

...

Hated the whole episode, I thought it was ridiculous, the songs were terrible and I just hated that they tried to go from ridiculously cheesy to really deep and powerful in the same episode. Did not work.

I dunno if I liked the episode or not. I thought it was powerful and (very) moving, but at the same time I too thought it was distasteful and I thought it was a little too soon (I know it was months ago now, but at the time they were shooting this episode it would have all been a little, too soon. Surely?) I think it was leveled out a little by the whole Becky/Sue scenario and it didn't seem as disrespectful as it initially felt for me.

What was said about the

ringtone

shot that down for me, idk.

Kitty

could just as easily be lying.

 

Yeah the

ringtone

comment made me question whether it actually was aformentioned person but they could have

changed the ringtone for Ryder to hide their tracks possibly ?

 

 

I'm really intrigued by it now, especially after rewatching the episode

I understand the 'too soon' comments sure, but I agree with the people who say that these kinds of shootings aren't uncommon in America and there would never have been a 'good' time, they were either going to do the episode or they weren't.

I kind of feel a bit more relaxed about this now as I read that writers had apparently written the episode long before the incident (which makes obvious sense :lol:). But still, I think it would have been nice for them to give the families of the victims a little heads up about the episode or something.