July 13, 201312 yr Quitter, Undo It, Jesus Take The Wheel, Good Girl, Last Name, Inside Your Heaven and Jesus Take The Wheel are all amaze :wub: See You Again absolutely should NOT be this high. Still great, but definitely her weakest single. I will cut a bitch if it's higher than the second best song ever Before He Cheats :wub:
July 13, 201312 yr Author Quitter, Undo It, Jesus Take The Wheel, Good Girl, Last Name, Inside Your Heaven and Jesus Take The Wheel are all amaze :wub: So good you named it twice? :P It's a really strong top 10 IMO, not sure Ever Ever After should be *quite* this high (sorry Regina) but I do still like it so I can't moan.
July 13, 201312 yr Ever Ever After and See You Again shouldn't even be top 20 but I do like them. Aside from that, all 8 would probably be in my Carrie top 20! Absolutely HAS to be Before He Cheats, but it clearly be Blown Away. Before He Cheats > Cowboy Cassanova > Just A Dream > I Know You Won't > Blown Away
July 13, 201312 yr Author My ideal order for the top 10: 1. So Small 2. All-American Girl 3. I Know You Won't (literally my Carrie top three) 4. Blown Away 5. Cowboy Casanova 6. Before He Cheats 7. See You Again 8. Just a Dream 9. Temporary Home 10. Ever Ever After
July 13, 201312 yr 01 Before He Cheats 02 Cowboy Cassanova 03 Just A Dream 04 I Know You Won't 05 Blown Away 06 So Small 07 Temporary Home 08 All-American Girl 09 Ever Ever After 10 See You Again The bottom 2 are still 8s but the top 9 are all 9 or 9.5s, the top 5 are definite 10s <3
July 13, 201312 yr Ever Ever After to win or I start hurting people. http://s23.postimg.org/jhjwmaeij/tumblr_lkjecredl_J1qdidu8.gif
July 16, 201312 yr Author 10. See You Again I can hear those echoes in the wind at night, calling me back in time, back to you... vTnWFT3DvVA http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/SeeYouAgain.png 10. 9.33 See You Again || Blown Away (no 11s, same 10s, fewer 9.5s) Highest score: 10 (Calum, Rossco, Ryan) Lowest score: 8 (Regina) 9. Just a Dream Baby why'd you leave me, why'd you have to go, I was counting on forever, now I'll never know... luJcsPRngNE (music video: http://vimeo.com/1469346) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/JustaDream.png 9. 9.33 Just a Dream || Carnival Ride (no 11s, same 10s, more 9.5s) Highest score: 11 (Calum) Lowest score: 7 (Regina) So the first song to drop out in the top 10 is the fourth single from Blown Away - See You Again. It was the only song in the top 10 that failed to receive at least one score of 11. It's my personal least favourite single of Blown Away but it's still a great song, possibly a little too high but it's brilliant nonetheless. Next up is Just a Dream, which annoyingly does not have its music video on YouTube. The music video outlines that she is meant to be walking down the aisle at her wedding, but instead is doing so at the funeral of her loved one who died at war. Calum seems to love this song but unfortunately Regina's not a fan. Clearly a tactical thing so Ever Ever After can win. ;)
July 16, 201312 yr New Carrie fan here... quite liking how the results have panned out except for the god-awful I Know You Won't. Every time I listen to it, it seems to drag on for about twenty minutes!
July 16, 201312 yr Author New Carrie fan here... quite liking how the results have panned out except for the god-awful I Know You Won't. Every time I listen to it, it seems to drag on for about twenty minutes! At least SOMEONE'S (mostly) happy with the results. :lol: Buzzjack voted for this so they can't moan too much lol I Know You Won't is one of my favourite Carrie songs though, I want it to be top three. :wub:
July 16, 201312 yr I didn't actually vote though..... If I had, While We're Young And Beautiful would NOT be last place!
July 16, 201312 yr Author I didn't actually vote though..... If I had, While We're Young And Beautiful would NOT be last place! Oh I wasn't referring to you in particular! :kink: It was a general statement, not even just for this rate, for all on this forum. We're Young and Beautiful is a pretty worthy last-placer IMO, it's not all that good. Although, she has a few that are worse.
July 16, 201312 yr I haven't actually looked yet (and I daren't in case it is bottom 3) but one of my favourite non-singles is I Ain't In Checotah Anymore... I'll go look now! Edit: Not too bad to be fair! I like that someone else gave it an 11!! Edited July 16, 201312 yr by Jamesy
July 23, 201312 yr Author 8. So Small Sometimes that mountain you've been climbing is just a grain of sand... nEQj6RrQbgA http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/SoSmall.png 8. 9.39 So Small || Carnival Ride Highest score: 11 (Joseph, Rossco) Lowest score: 7 (dannjohn) 7. All-American Girl And when they got married and decided to have one of their own, she said "be honest, tell me what you want" and he said "honey you ought to know..." m36xv75MJ4U http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/All-AmericanGirl-1.png 7. 9.44 All-American Girl || Carnival Ride Highest score: 10 (gooddelta, Joseph, Rossco, Regina, Ryan) Lowest score: 8 (dannjohn) OK seeing as Umi is getting impatient I have put my life plans (lol) on hold for you lot. :) At #8 is So Small, my personal favourite Carrie song. It's about realising that love means more than anything, and it makes everything else look "so small". Such a powerful song and the video is brilliantly done also. Turns out I lied in the last results post, All-American Girl also received no 11s, but it had more 10s and therefore it goes ahead of So Small here. Another really sweet song, detailing the life of a "beautiful, wonderful, perfect all-american girl" right from what her dad hoped before she was born (a boy, awks) to the point where she wanted a baby of her own.
July 23, 201312 yr Both amaze and fully deserving of top 10 :wub: Really should have given AAG a 10, I underrate it until I listen to it again tbh.
July 27, 201312 yr Author 6. I Know You Won't I buy into those eyes, and into your lies... 4aa0jVO_zFc http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/IKnowYouWont.png 6. 9.56 I Know You Won't || Carnival Ride Highest score: 11 (Regina) Lowest score: 8.5 (Calum, gooddelta, SlimJim) 5. Before He Cheats I dug my key into the side of his pretty little souped up four wheel drive..." WaSy8yy-mr8 http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/BeforeHeCheats.png 5. 9.61 Before He Cheats || Some Hearts (fewer 11s) Highest score: 11 (Liam) Lowest score: 8 (Regina) So up first here we've got I Know You Won't, a song about not trusting your partner: "You say you'll call but I know you won't". Carrie's vocals on this song are SUBLIME and your faves really could neva. Next up, Liam dead at Before He Cheats only making it to #5. It's fairly self explanatory, it's about getting sick of your partner cheating and ending the relationship. Liam gave this its only 11, whereas the song at #4 received one more 11 meaning it places higher. (that has to be the dullest commentary I've written so far) The remaining songs: BLOWN AWAY COWBOY CASANOVA EVER EVER AFTER TEMPORARY HOME PREDICTIONS PLEASE!
July 27, 201312 yr what. the. actual. f***. Ever Ever After above the 2nd best song of all time? Ok then... Cowboy Cassanova to win now, my 2nd fave Carrie song :wub: It will clearly be Blown Away though, which is also fab. Want: 04 Ever Ever After 03 Temporary Home 02 Blown Away 01 Cowboy Cassanova Think: 04 Ever Ever After 03 Temporary Home 02 Cowboy Cassanova 01 Blown Away
July 27, 201312 yr Author 4. Cowboy Casanova He looks like a cool drink of water but he's candy-coated misery... oM7NQQ0Lfu4 http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/CowboyCasanova.png 4. 9.61 Cowboy Casanova || Play On (more 11s) Highest score: 11 (Liam, Regina) Lowest score: 8 (Calum) 3. Temporary Home This is just a stop on the way to where I'm going, I'm not afraid because I know, this is my temporary home..." LraOiHUltak http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/TemporaryHome.png 3. 9.72 Temporary Home || Play On Highest score: 11 (Calum, SlimJim) Lowest score: 9 (gooddelta, Joseph, Rossco, dannjohn) Both remaining Play On songs fall out here! Cowboy Casanova is first (only one 's' in Casanova, Liam :kink:), one of my personal favourite Carrie tracks. The song has one five awards for Carrie, including "Female Single of the Year" and "Female Music Video of the Year" at the 1st American Country Awards. In third place is single #2 from Play On, Temporary Home. This song is initially about spending time in carehomes, etc. but verse three is about an old man who is about to die, and sees earth as his temporary home. Beautiful song, one of the first Carrie songs I heard. So that means #1 is between BLOWN AWAY and EVER EVER AFTER! Find out who wins tomorrow!
Create an account or sign in to comment