The top 41 by averages is so much more fair given the number of non-rates for many of the films by lots of posters. I'm going to claim THAT as the real results.

Me two, even if it means Peter Pan and Alice in Wonderland are even lower :cry:

In my opinion the totals represent the popularity of the movies with all of the voters, while the averages only by the few that have seen them.

That is the main reason I chose for the totals in this countdown, as I wanted it to represent all of the votes

I believe there is a way that can be done where you average out and then divide by the number of votes you get or something (I can't remember what you have to do so I never bother with it! :lol:)

Yeah taking the average of who did vote for that movie is the only truly fair metric, people who haven't seen a movie will lower the average score of it and present and inaccurate result.

 

Sorry for bitching though, you did an excellent job hosting and running this Tim so don't let my pedantry put a dampener on it.

Yeah taking the average of who did vote for that movie is the only truly fair metric, people who haven't seen a movie will lower the average score of it and present and inaccurate result.

 

Sorry for bitching though, you did an excellent job hosting and running this Tim so don't let my pedantry put a dampener on it.

Oh don't worry about that, that's why I put both results in my post to show both sides

I really enjoyed doing this, it allowed me to relive some of my favourite Disney movies and childhood memories

mulan deserved better.

I'm a bit bemused by the love for 101 Dalmations - it's not that great a story really. I do like Jasper and Horace though. Same with the Aristocats - although the bits with the butler and Napoleon and Lafayette are comic gold. Because of the general age of buzzjackers, the resultant top 3 was almost inevitable. At least they're well-made films...but only The Lion King is really worth putting on...and I really don't like Beauty and the Beast at all.

 

Here's how the films are rated via IMDB btw - some of the more recent films quite high up.

 

(I added in the Black Cauldron and Basil, the Great Mouse Detective which should really have been on this rate!)

 

1. 8.5 - The Lion King

2. 8.1 - Beauty & The Beast

3. 8.0 - Aladdin

4. 7.9 - Frozen

4. 7.9 - Tangled

6. 7.8 - Fantasia

6. 7.8 - Wreck-It Ralph

8. 7.7 - Snow White & The Seven Dwarfs

9. 7.6 - The Jungle Book

9. 7.6 - The Little Mermaid

9. 7.6 - Pinocchio

9. 7.6 - Robin Hood

13. 7.5 - Mulan

14. 7.4 - Alice in Wonderland

14. 7.4 - Bambi

14. 7.4 - Lady and the Tramp

14. 7.4 - Peter Pan

14. 7.4 - Sleeping Beauty

19. 7.3 - The Brave Little Toaster

19. 7.3 - Cinderella

19. 7.3 - Dumbo

19. 7.3 - The Emperor's New Groove

19. 7.3 - The Fox and the Hound

24. 7.2 - 101 Dalmations

24. 7.2 - Basil, the Great Mouse Detective

24. 7.2 - Hercules

24. 7.2 - The Princess and the Frog

24. 7.2 - The Sword in the Stone

24. 7.2 - Tarzan

30. 7.1 - The Aristocats

30. 7.1 - Lilo & Stitch

32. 7.0 - Bolt

33. 6.9 - The Rescuers

34. 6.8 - The Hunchback of Notre Dame

35. 6.7 - Brother Bear

35. 6.7 - Oliver & Company

37. 6.6 - Pocahontas

38. 6.4 - The Black Cauldron

38. 6.4 - Dinosaur

40. 6.4 - The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride

41. 5.8 - Chicken Little

42. 5.6 - The Brave Little Toaster Goes to Mars

43. 5.4 - Home on the Range

Poor underappreciated Home On The Range :(

Edited April 28, 201411 yr by BarbaricSissyTIM

Beauty and The Beast will forever top The Lion King for me, I love both but I always found the latter a tad overrated, It would probably be in my Top 10 but not in my Top 2.