Jump to content

Featured Replies

I did say at the start that they should've been grouped together!!!

 

I don't find that Dalek 2-parter all that bad tbh :( The Dalek Sec Hybrid was a pretty rubbish idea but I like it otherwise.

  • 5 weeks later...
  • Replies 259
  • Views 16k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

67

 

Boom Town

 

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdeucvvqKq1qih9gi.jpg

 

Okay continuing on with this again seeing as the incredible series 8 is drawing to a close in a matter of days. 'Boom Town' is one of those episodes that is absolutely hilarious in that it really doesn't take itself seriously at all, but at the same time contradicts all the silliness with some very serious and quite dark material at the same time. I think this is the only episode where I'm actually able to take the Slitheen seriously. They posed an alright threat in their first appearance, but it was nothing major that we hadn't seen before, and let's just not mention their appearances in The Sarah Jane Adventures... I suppose for a CBBC show aimed at a younger audience they fitted the bill, but not for its loyal and more mature audience that it drew in from the Who fanbase. Anyway, back to the episode at hand. This episode was Margaret Blaine's time to shine. Probably the only member of the Slitheen family worth focusing on in more depth because the others from 'Aliens of London' and 'World War Three' were all quite forgettable. The scenes in the restaurant were all executed brilliantly, and I will never ever ever not laugh at the scene where she tries to keep hopping out of London while the Doctor just keeps dragging her back. Amazing <3

 

Average 7.167

Highest score 10 (Jester, Iz~)

Lowest score 5 (seantobewild, JosephStyles, Chez Wombat)

 

 

66

 

Human Nature

 

http://www.kasterborous.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/dw-s3-humannature.jpg

 

I can't quite believe this has finished as low as it has considering a) it comes from series 3 which is undoubtedly the worst series since the show's renewal and b) it's one of the three best episodes to come from the series (sitting comfortably in a trinity next to 'Blink' and 'The Family of Blood'). The whole premise of this episode is absolutely beautiful - the Doctor leaving Time Lord life behind to go ahead and life a human life, meet new people, fall in love with somebody, become a school teacher and lead them all into battle against the title enemies - the Family of Blood. I suppose most would say that the idea of using scarecrows as a villain for an episode of Doctor Who could be quite silly and childish and not that scary at all, but even now they still bloody petrify me. The eeriness about them just... there... in a field, by themselves, when you don't even think to look twice at them, who knows when the straw will just start attacking you and leading you to your eventual fate? Some of the beautiful moments from this episode include Martha not being able to cope with the pressure of pretending that she does not know the Doctor, all the while heartbroken that he does not know her. It was all quite tragic really from a dramatic point of view, but I can't feel sorry for Martha at all because it's all just a hollow casket. And then we have the love story of John Smith and Joan Redfern. Absolutely stunning from start to finish, the flash-backs and flash-forwards were all done simplistically and gorgeously, and they made for a wonderful on-screen couple.

 

Average 7.167

Highest score 11 (Severin)

Lowest score -1 (Michael!)

 

 

65

 

The Almost People

 

tumblr_namenerZZX1rzotx3o5_500.jpg

 

I can't really comment on this episode all that much because really, I didn't give much of a shit about it. The first part was considerably better, and this part really did not live up to any of the small expectations that its predecessor left behind. It all got a bit clumsy when the Gangers started developing the ability to manipulate their body form and move around in ways that you wouldn't expect them to. Of course, it added a sort-of Doctor Who twist to the idea of the Gangers, but it just didn't pay off for me, if I'm honest. But anyway, let's get to the exciting part. The part of the episode that got me on the edge of my seat, clapping my hands, smiling and getting bloody READY for 'A Good Man Goes to War' because it was going to be EPIC no matter how it all played out. The closing minutes of the episode sees the Doctor tell Rory that Amy has never been travelling in the TARDIS with them since they were in America, and she's in labour and is having contractions. I mean... WHAT?! It blew my mind and still does to this day. Probably one of the best twists to have come from the show. And then we see Amy wake up on Demons Run, only to see Madame Kovarian appear directly above her and tell her she's about to give birth. It was honestly such a beautiful moment, and led perfectly into the next episode. Seriously the best thing about the episode, and most of it was probably down to Moffat, so we can't really commend the story's actual writer for much at all here.

 

Average 7.182

Highest score 9 (Michael!, Calum Hood, Chez Wombat)

Lowest score 0 (Regina)

 

 

64

 

The Crimson Horror

 

http://www.blueorcadigital.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Preview-Poster-Copyright-BBC.jpg

 

Definitely in the top 3 of series 7, so I fail to see why this has placed so low, but considering when you take this episode out of the equation the only episodes you're left with from series 7 are Moffat episodes, NONE OF YOU CAN MOAN ABOUT HIM EVER AGAIN. Everything about this episode was so very beautiful. The setting was fabulous, the guest cast were all incredible, everything was all just done really well and it's by far and away Mark Gatiss' best script to date. Let's start with the Paternoster Gang shall we? For once, they actually seem less of a joke here and are actually taken seriously (that is of course until we reach 'Deep Breath' where they're at their absolute peak and have never seemed more amazing), but yes... Having the Doctor and Clara intrude on them solving a mystery as opposed to it being the other way around really was great, and it was nice to see Jenny get in on the action a little bit more, something that's only really happened once (this episode) - otherwise she's just been a bit of a spare part who's there to be Vastra's wife. Then of course we have Ada Gillyflower who is definitely one of the strongest of the guest cast for the series, IMO. The vulnerability of her character was just so so beautiful (but painful to watch at the same time considering how Mrs Gillyflower treated her), and Rachel Stirling did the role 100% justice throughout. I guess when we got to the part where Mr Sweet was unveiled, it kind of blew the episode off course for a minute or so. The fact that it was this little lobster clinging onto Mrs Gillyflower's chest and feeding off of salt... well... erm. Let's just end that there. All in all, a fabulous episode with a great premise and a genuine threat (something that series 7 seemed to lack a fair bit of, if being completely honest), and all shot wonderfully. The fact that we landed in the adventure half-way through then were caught up to speed throughout with the flashbacks was a GREAT element to add into the story, something the show could benefit doing more of in the future, but I guess that's part of the reason this episode stands out a bit more, because it's dared to do something a bit different with its storytelling.

 

Average 7.182

Highest score 10 (April)

Lowest score 2 (Regina)

 

Boom Town is one of those stories that starts off brilliantly but gets reaaaallly boring later on. :( A fairly meh section, with Human Nature sticking out like a sore thumb. Why the HELL is that so low??????

 

And NO at the series 3 shade - it's the second best of the new series x

I loved The Crimson Horror! :wub:
  • Author

63

 

The Shakespeare Code

 

http://www.doctorwhoreviews.co.uk/2007-02_files/The%20Shakespeare%20Code%20(4).jpg

 

And another one bites the dust for series 3. It's not faring too well considering there are only three stories left standing (five episodes in total however). Anyway, in sixth place from this uneventful series is 'The Shakespeare Code', one of its highlights. The idea of the story is one that is executed brilliantly, if not with a little too much silliness at times. It does take itself quite seriously though which is good to see. The guest cast in this episode are all fabulous. William Shakespeare himself isn't too boisterous, and as well as that not as in-your-face as most historic characters have been portrayed in the show. And then of course there's Lillith - the head Carrionite. She was such a sassy and fierce bitch villain, and when we finally got to see her in her true Carrionite form, that was a fabulous moment. Most of this episode was, but it was all let down slightly by Martha's constant questions and her inability to just stay quiet instead of being the fussy piece of mould she was for the remainder of the series. Overall an excellent episode with some very clear (but not overpowering) flaws. I think this is the type of episode I like a lot of - a historical that doesn't involve a famous historical figure. One that's just sitting there in history waiting to be played with by the TARDIS team.

 

Average 7.250

Highest score 10 (Severin)

Lowest score 1 (Regina)

 

The Shakespeare Code is BRILLIANT. As is all of series 3, your opinions are incredibly wrong when it comes to this show Calum xx
  • Author

62

 

The Time of the Doctor

 

http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/time-clara-crack-sad.jpg

 

Oh, 'The Time of the Doctor'... There's far too much to say about this episode, it's impossible to cram it all into one paragraph without it turning into a novel. I think this episode is the action-packed end-of-an-era episode that RTD tried to do but did not achieve in the slightest when writing both Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant out of the show. Their Doctors were both magnificent, but their send-offs were not the most satisfying ever, particularly the latter which just dragged... and dragged... And then, oh dear we had the second part to go and it dragged... and dragged. But this episode was magnificent. Not only was it the end of Matt Smith's era and his penultimate episode as the Doctor, we got all the tantalising questions that had been spread out across the era, starting away back in 2010, we got to see the gorgeous, amazing, beautiful, 100% perfect actress Orla Brady make her début in the show, we got a small but satisfying glimpse at Clara's home life, we got to see Matt Smith shirtless which was just a *.* moment because he has never looked finer, and of course we got to see the years-long battle of Trenzalore including Daleks, Cybermen, the Doctor, the Silence, and a bunch of villagers from the town Christmas.

The only unforgivable mistake that they made in this episode, which turned the whole scene into something of a tragic joke was when Matt took his wig off and revealed that he was in fact bald underneath. I suppose it was a nod to the fact that he actually was in real life for an upcoming part in a film, but was it necessary in the slightest? Absolutely not. The episode on the whole is serious, emotional, light-hearted and Christmassy, but that was just like farting and leaving a bad smell lingering for a couple of minutes. Another of the criticisms this episode received was having Handles there in the sense that it kind of degraded the Cybermen and their ruthless nature by having one of them (well, a fraction of one) being kind and a companion of sorts to the Doctor. I for one actually enjoyed the addition, and the scene where Handles identified Trenzalore as Gallifrey, well that was just amazing. Of course, I wasn't expecting Moffat to drop us with the fact that Gallifrey had been found only one episode after it was time-locked and waiting to be rescued, but it was a nice nod. Most would also say it went a bit far when the Doctor was weeping when Handles died - but what state would you be in when it was the only companion you'd had by your side for hundreds of years? It was rather endearing to watch, and it only served to make this Doctor's final episode that bit more emotional.

Anyway, moving onto more positive notes about the episode... ORLA BRADY. Let's just appreciate the fact that she was in this episode and brought every ounce of her sexiness, fierceness and brilliant acting onto the table. Possibly my favourite guest on the show in a long time - possibly since Kylie in 'Voyage of the Damned'. There have been many greats over the years, but I suppose what made me so hyped for her appearance was having watched her in 'Mistresses' and LOVING her back then. A fine acting talent. And speaking of fine acting talent, Jenna was on form in this episode. The one scene that got to me the most was when the Doctor abandoned her back on Earth for a second time. Such effortless acting by Jenna, and you just couldn't help but feel so so sorry for Clara in that moment. And then the other moment Jenna excelled in this episode was when she was speaking to the Time Lords through the crack in time. Finally, we got the answer to all of the burning questions. This episode told us that the crack in time was what was behind the Doctor's door in 'The God Complex' - hence how he knew that he had not escaped its threat after the events of 'The Big Bang'. But yes, when Clara spoke to the Time Lords and told them that the Doctor deserved appreciation, it was just really beautiful.

The battle of Trenzalore itself was all executed brilliantly. I think I cried emotional tears of joy when I was watching it, just because of how excellently shot all of it was, the directing was all fabulous, the musical score is some of the best from the show, and watching the Silence and the Doctor standing side by side in a war when up until this point they had been written as the Doctor's enemy, well, it was just a great moment - one of the other things we discovered in this episode; what "Silence will fall" all stood for, who the Papal Mainframe was, and what the whole idea of the religion was. It all interlinked PERFECTLY. And then of course, the end of the episode gave us the most emotional scenes of the episode. It was time for Matt Smith to leave (part of me was extremely pleased at this because a welcome change is just what we needed to refresh the show a little, but part of me was sad because it was in this Doctor's era that we had the best series the show has ever produced, and we had some moments along the way). Amy's reappearance was STUNNING, an excellent surprise, and one that I certainly wasn't expecting. "Raggedy man, goodnight." And then the show was handed over to Peter Capaldi.

 

Average 7.273

Highest score 10 (Michael!, Calum Hood)

Lowest score 0 (Regina)

 

  • Author

61

 

A Good Man Goes to War

 

http://i1046.photobucket.com/albums/b468/syntaxed/ponds%20daily/doctorreturnstoday.png

 

Well this is awkward... One of the best episodes in Doctor Who's history, and it's only managed to place at #61. This episode has so many good things going for it. We've got Dorium who's just a bit of a loose cannon, we've got Madame Kovarian who's just a queen in her own right portrayed by the wonderfully sassy Frances Barber, then we've got Lorna Bucket - and the whole idea of having somebody there on Demons Run who has met the Doctor only once before, and serves to lead us into the cliffhanger at the end of her episode with her gift to Amy in the form of the blanket - it was all very nice. Apart from Lorna dying though. That was a sad moment, and it just seemed like the Doctor didn't remember her. He probably didn't. Then of course, we have the moment that the Doctor discovered in his showdown with Madame Kovarian that Melody Pond was a flesh avatar, ready to be taken away from Amy's loving arms before she could even get back to the TARDIS. She would go to Earth, live in an orphanage, and become the woman who kills the Doctor - River Song. The cliffhanger at the end is just the most perfect I have ever seen. I remember watching and just being in complete awe. It was seriously the best thing ever. Was it predictable? Yes, but it didn't detract anything at all from the reveal. Such a beautiful moment. And it turns out to the people in the Gamma Forests, the Doctor is a mighty warrior. And the only water in the forest is the river. Not the pond, because they don't have a word for 'pond'.

 

Average 7.318

Highest score 10 (Calum Hood, April)

Lowest score 3 (Regina)

 

  • Author

60

 

Planet of the Dead

 

http://darkaeon.wordpress.com/files/2009/04/doctor_who_planet_of_the_dead_promo.jpg

 

So it was the year of the specials, and we got an Easter special in the form of 'Planet of the Dead'. In the true spirit of things, the episode starts with the Doctor getting on a bus and meeting Lady Christina only to offer her a bit of his chocolate egg (that is not a euphemism). The episode on the whole is a bit dry in parts, if I'm honest, but it has a few good points. Focusing on the good parts, we have Carmen who predicts all of the fate that lies ahead for the Doctor - foretelling that "he will knock four times". We then get a glimpse of that in 'The Waters of Mars' before 'The End of Time' spills everything. I figured out what it meant as soon as she said it though. It was heavily speculated that the Master would return in 'The End of Time', and who can ever forget his infamous four knock beat in 'The Sound of Drums' and 'Last of the Time Lords'? It was just plainly obvious. The other good parts about this episode were that it took place in a desert. It was a very nice location. And the rest all just blended into one big pile of meh for me. The Tritovore were a bit of an embarrassment, the stingrays weren't exactly amazing - even if the CGI did look good.

 

Average 7.364

Highest score 9 (April)

Lowest score 6 (Michael!, Rabbit Heart)

 

 

59

 

The Wedding of River Song

 

http://s3.seriesregular.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/doctorwho-6x13.jpg

 

And another episode falls out for series 6 - a bit disappointing. This episode seemed to get a bit of a mixed reaction, mostly negative. It was a very very good finale IMO. The whole series had focused on River Song, so it was only right that the very end of it had at least half of the conclusion of River's story, no? It was at the end of 'Closing Time' we discovered River was the woman who killed the Doctor, even if it had been blatantly obvious since 'Flesh and Stone'. She refused to do so though, changing a fixed point in time. If she touched the Doctor, she would kill him. Madame Kovarian made a return in this episode also, and she was just as fierce as ever. Although she met a hideous fate towards the end of the episode when Amy killed her in cold blood - albeit in an alternate timeline, so she could still be out there somewhere although that's obviously down to our imagination given where we are now. And then of course, we had the main event... the Doctor and River Song getting married. The Doctor whispered to River telling her to look into his eye, and a bit later on we found out that the Teselecta were at Lake Silencio in place of the real Doctor. The Doctor had become too big, so he went into hiding and didn't want anybody to find out that he was still alive and had survived. On the whole, this was a fabulous episode that wrapped up the most perfect series and answered a few questions but left a few yet to be. I just wish there were about 20 episodes in this series because it really could have been fleshed out even further into the biggest masterpiece Doctor Who has ever given us.

 

Average 7.409

Highest score 10 (Michael!, Calum Hood, Jester)

Lowest score 2 (Regina, Iz~)

 

 

58

 

The Bells of Saint John

 

http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/the-bells-of-saint-john-pics-batch-1.jpg

 

This is one of my favourite concepts for a Doctor Who episode. Steven Moffat really does know how to make us scared of everyday things, and he succeeds every time. The thought of connecting to the internet and not knowing where you might end up or what might happen to you is chilling. This episode gave us the planting of seeds that we had already seen in previous episodes ('Asylum of the Daleks' and 'The Snowmen'), where Clara was given the internet password 'rycbar123' and spelled it out as 'run you clever boy and remember' - forcing the Doctor to come and pay her a visit. Then of course later in the episode when she had to decide upon a password to use while defeating the Spoonheads and their leader Ms Kislet - she meshed Clara Oswald and 'win' together to give 'Oswin'. And the final one - the woman in the shop. Clara was given the TARDIS' phone number by the mysterious woman in the shop, whom we have just discovered is Missy, aka the Mistress, aka the Master. Almost everything about this episode is perfect, I just love the modernness of the whole thing, and the fact that Clara is by far the best companion to date. We had a genuine threat that we could believe in, but the episode's only flaw is that the resolution was a bit too quick, much like the rest of series 7 where each episode probably would have benefited from being an hour in length, at least.

 

Average 7.455

Highest score 11 (Heezus)

Lowest score 3 (Regina)

 

 

57

 

The Snowmen

 

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/--OTY6kVb760/UL-53vMc08I/AAAAAAAAAqE/1SaMF_ToD6E/s1600/timthumb%202.jpg

 

WHY are all of the good episodes falling out?! This is by far and away the best Christmas special there has been. Slays all of the RTD ones, is much better than 'A Christmas Carol' and a thousand miles better than 'The Doctor, The Widow & The Wardrobe'. So once again, we meet a different version of Clara Oswald. We first met her in 'Asylum of the Daleks' where she died (more on that later), but now she's alive again (HOW?! :o) and she's in Victorian London. The impossible girl strikes again. The Doctor never saw Clara in the flesh the first time he met her, so he didn't know what she looked like and didn't know he was onto a mystery. I think this is my favourite version of Clara (as FABULOUS as modern-day Clara is), because she just oozed energy and sass and sexiness, absolutely everything - she had it. The Paternoster Gang were great in this episode. I'm not massive on comedy in Doctor Who, but the scene with Strax and the memory worm was really well done. Vastra was fierce here, and Jenny was just... trying to be fierce. And it was here that we were (re-)introduced to the Great Intelligence. Dr Simeon was a wonderful enemy even though I loathe him so so much (it's probably more the casting decision because it's such a despicable person that you want to hate so so much and he does it so well). The title characters were very underused in this episode I think, which is the only thing I can find flaw with. They were a very eerie and frightening presence, but I wish there had been more of that. All in all, flawless way to spend your Christmas night, and any others throughout the year when you're in the mood to just watch Clara being perfect. WHEN SHE DIED, I was crying. When she said 'run you clever boy' I was DEAD. Almost as dead as her. It was all just such a fanboy moment.

 

Average 7.455

Highest score 10 (Michael!, Calum Hood, April)

Lowest score 0 (Regina)

 

A Good Man Goes To War and The Wedding of River Song are just so hard to follow lol. The Snowmen is MEH. Really like Planet and Bells though.
  • Author

56

 

The Long Game

 

http://www.welovemoviesmorethanyou.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/dw_the-long-game-news.jpg

 

This is a really chilling and terrifying episode. The whole concept of wanting to go to Floor 500 only to be met with a horrifying fate just creeps me out, and more-so the performance that Simon Pegg puts in as the Editor. We get to see Adam in this story as well who really is nothing but a damp cloth. There's nothing interesting about him at all, and I'd much rather have seen Mickey come along for the ride, because while he's not really that tolerable either, he at least has a dynamic with Rose that they could have used to their advantage, but no. Although credit where credit's due, Adam getting home and finding out that he had the chip in his head, that was fabulous. Anyway, moving swiftly on... None of the characters in this episode were really that likeable. The story was amazing, but everything else was just kind of there. The Jagrafess was a good villain, but was kind of just playing second fiddle to the Editor until the very end, but it all came together nicely and gave us a horror story with a Doctor Who spin. One of my favourites from the RTD era, which isn't really saying that much. :kink:

 

Average 7.500

Highest score 10 (Jester)

Lowest score 6 (seantobewild, Regina, Rabbit Heart, Heezus)

 

 

55

 

The Family of Blood

 

http://bowjamesbow.ca/images/humannature01.jpg

 

I'm really surprised to see this drop out so soon after 'Human Nature'. This episode really is fabulous and a bit of an emotional rollercoaster. The one scene in this episode that really gets to me is when they're all preparing their weapons outside of the school and they're standing there ready to commence battle with the scarecrows. The slow-motion building up to it and throughout it, and then everybody crying, and the scarecrows being shot down - everything just fits absolutely perfectly and we're given one of the most beautiful scenes from the show. We're under the impression that there's a lot of friction in the school, but when they're faced with the biggest challenge of their lives, they all come together and fight by each other's sides. I don't really remember a great deal about the rest of this episode because that one scene is such a powerful one that it becomes the best and good thing about it. But I think Martha became a bit more tolerable towards the end, and the things that the Doctor did to each member of the Family of Blood in the end were great to see, particularly trapping the little girl in a mirror for the rest of her life. Kind of mixed emotions about that one? She seemed all innocent, but she was a bit of a bitch in the end. And Iz, if you're looking for somebody to blame here, blame Michael for skewing the average.

 

Average 7.500

Highest score 11 (Iz~)

Lowest score 0 (Michael!)

 

When I saw Human Nature drop out, I knew Family Of Blood wouldn't be far behind and I'm just a bit disappointed. By far my favourite episode/story of the entire show. (bar series 8 as I have yet to see any)

 

There are so many feels (specifically foreboding feels) when watching it.

I can only echo what Iz said about Human Nature/The Family of Blood, excellent two-parter and I don't understand why it's so low.

 

The Long Game feels about right in that position, a nice little story, not the best of series 1 but enjoyable still.

  • Author

54

 

The God Complex

 

http://edwhitfield.files.wordpress.com/2011/09/doctor-who-the-god-complex-promo-pics-4_jpg_627x325_crop_upscale_q85.jpeg

 

I really wasn't that big a fan of this episode to begin with after watching it for the first time, but after repeated views (and many of them) since, it's actually a really good episode. Some of the characters I'm still not that keen on, but Rita is the stand-out guest star in this episode, definitely. When she finally gives in and 'praises' the Minotaur, that was a beautiful moment in the episode, one where you really felt for the character and got behind her even though you knew what was about to happen to her was in no way good. And then we have the rest of the episode... David Walliams, well, you just take him for what he is really. Didn't add much to the story at all, apart from maybe the scene with the Weeping Angel, but other than that he was completely useless. The idea though that there was a room for everybody and their fear was lurking behind the door, it was all quite chilling. And the mannequins sitting in the dining area, that really freaked me out. It was a great episode, and the ending where the Doctor let Amy and Rory go and live their life with a house and a car, that was nice. This probably wouldn't end up that high on my 'favourite episodes of Doctor Who' list, but it is really really good. (Iz, what's your problem with this episode? :o)

 

Average 7.500

Highest score 11 (April)

Lowest score 0 (Iz~)

 

 

53

 

The Girl Who Waited

 

http://m5.paperblog.com/i/72/728768/retro-doctor-who-reviews-vol-117-L-ISPCHr.jpeg

 

Okay, this one I really am dumbfounded by. This is by far my favourite episode of Doctor Who, of all time. Bit disappointed to say the least it's not even managed to rank in the top 50, but oh well. This episode has all of the perfect components. We have Matt Smith taking a bit of a backseat and being grounded to the TARDIS once the episode gets in the swing of things. Amy takes the forefront of the episode, and is separated from the Doctor and Rory from the moment they step foot on Apalapucia. The Doctor and Rory chose Green Anchor, while Amy chose Red Waterfall, and then everything started. Amy was left there for years, ageing to an older woman and expanding her knowledge on how the sinister HandBots worked. It was all just perfect, and the setting for the episode was really really stunning. One of the best visuals I've ever seen on Doctor Who. Then we have, towards the end of the episode, the moment where Rory has to decide whether he wants to keep the older Amy or the younger Amy. They're both the same person, but by keeping them both the paradox inside the TARDIS would be far too big. All throughout the episode I felt myself feeling so emotional and so bad for the older version of Amy, because why wouldn't Rory choose to keep the young Amy, the one that he would spend the rest of his life with? But then when the Doctor locked the older version out of the TARDIS to prevent the paradox from happening, I was GONE. Agh, there's too much to say about this episode and I'm really in the mood to go and sit and watch it again. Such perfection, such divinity. Flawless from start to finish. Tom McCrae really needs to write for Who more often.

 

Average 7.545

Highest score 11 (Calum Hood, Heezus)

Lowest score 2 (April)

 

Booo at The God Complex being so low! It was by far the best of a poor series!
  • Author
The Girl Who Waited should be higher, the shining star of an otherwise shite series :(

you're gonna get smacked in a minute :) x

  • Author
I'm not the one with rubbish opinions on Who xx

whit:

 

-x-

 

Anyway, ladies and gentlemen, I shall now pass you on to Joseph who will be posting some results from here on in! Finally I can get a break from destroying my fingers with commentary! *.*

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.