Posted August 5, 201410 yr http://i59.photobucket.com/albums/g297/Hitcruiser/Hitcruiser005/Madonna002_zpsdfce4443.png ____________________________________________________________________________© x ketalina x Welcome. Over the course of August, we will be rating, debating, listening, reliving and most of all loving the Queen of Pop, Madonna. I have managed to select the plethora of singles released by the artist and arranged them into albums, with a final miscellaneous section. I have made a few (what i consider to be "minor" cuts), but if there are any glaring omissions then let me know and they can be included. The aim is to whittle this list down, and eventually reveal the TOP 40 Madonna singles as rated by you. As approved by both the Pop forum and Madonna forum mods, we felt it had a place here and hope it can bring in old lovers, current stans and potential newcomers into her dancefloor. Please do not feel compelled to rate every song as i am aware there are PLENTY, but do give the rate your thought and attention and do as much as you can, even if it is just her 10 biggest singles! The album rate is again optional, but any and every score will be appreciated. Provisional deadline is 19th August but this can be brought forward if we have enough by then or delayed if people need more time. Rules Please vote for the songs listed below, ranking them each with a score of 00-10 (you can include half scores also). If you have not heard a song please take the time to listen and then vote, or failing that leave it as a xx (and not a 00 which would count as zero points for the song). I doubt we would get any, but i may void any rates that people deem to be "trolling" (such as giving an entire album's singles a score of 0); i want this to be done properly to really find what songs we rate in our hearts so please refrain from deliberately causing a stir~ In addition to this, you are allocated with 3 x +11 votes1 x -1 votesAlbum Rank Rank the studio albums exactly the same as you did with the singles. Here you are allocated with1 x +11 votesMUSIC: Everybody Burning Up Holiday Lucky Star Borderline Like A Virgin Material Girl Crazy For You Angel Into The Groove Dress You Up Live To Tell Papa Don't Preach True Blue Open Your Heart La Isla Bonita Like A Prayer Express Yourself Cherish Oh Father Dear Jessie Keep It Together Erotica Deeper and Deeper Bad Girl Fever Rain Secret Take A Bow Bedtime Story Human Nature Frozen Ray of Light Drowned World (Substitute For Love) The Power of Goodbye Nothing Really Matters Music Don't Tell Me What It Feels Like For A Girl American Life Hollywood Nothing Fails Love Profusion Hung Up Sorry Get Together Jump 4 Minutes Give It 2 Me Miles Away Give Me All Your Lovin' Girl Gone Wild Masterpiece Turn Up The Radio Who's That Girl Causing A Commotion Vogue Hanky Panky Justify My Love This Used To Be My Playground I'll Remember You'll See You Must Love Me Don't Cry For Me Argentina Beautiful Stranger American Pie Die Another Day Celebration THE IMMACULATE COLLECTION: Madonna Like A Virgin True Blue Life A Prayer Erotica Bedtime Stories Ray Of Light Music American Life Confessions On A Dancefloor Hard Candy MDNA Have fun. And offer your confessions...
August 5, 201410 yr Author [b]SINGLES[/b] [b]xx[/b] Everybody [b]xx[/b] Burning Up [b]xx[/b] Holiday [b]xx[/b] Lucky Star [b]xx[/b] Borderline [b]xx[/b] Like A Virgin [b]xx[/b] Material Girl [b]xx[/b] Crazy For You [b]xx[/b] Angel [b]xx[/b] Into The Groove [b]xx[/b] Dress You Up [b]xx[/b] Live To Tell [b]xx[/b] Papa Don't Preach [b]xx[/b] True Blue [b]xx[/b] Open Your Heart [b]xx[/b] La Isla Bonita [b]xx[/b] Like A Prayer [b]xx[/b] Express Yourself [b]xx[/b] Cherish [b]xx[/b] Oh Father [b]xx[/b] Dear Jessie [b]xx[/b] Keep It Together [b]xx[/b] Erotica [b]xx[/b] Deeper and Deeper [b]xx[/b] Bad Girl [b]xx[/b] Fever [b]xx[/b] Rain [b]xx[/b] Secret [b]xx[/b] Take A Bow [b]xx[/b] Bedtime Story [b]xx[/b] Human Nature [b]xx[/b] Frozen [b]xx[/b] Ray of Light [b]xx[/b] Drowned World (Substitute For Love) [b]xx[/b] The Power of Goodbye [b]xx[/b] Nothing Really Matters [b]xx[/b] Music [b]xx[/b] Don't Tell Me [b]xx[/b] What It Feels Like For A Girl [b]xx[/b] American Life [b]xx[/b] Hollywood [b]xx[/b] Nothing Fails [b]xx[/b] Love Profusion [b]xx[/b] Hung Up [b]xx[/b] Sorry [b]xx[/b] Get Together [b]xx[/b] Jump [b]xx[/b] 4 Minutes [b]xx[/b] Give It 2 Me [b]xx[/b] Miles Away [b]xx[/b] Give Me All Your Lovin' [b]xx[/b] Girl Gone Wild [b]xx[/b] Masterpiece [b]xx[/b] Turn Up The Radio [b]xx[/b] Who's That Girl [b]xx[/b] Causing A Commotion [b]xx[/b] Vogue [b]xx[/b] Hanky Panky [b]xx[/b] Justify My Love [b]xx[/b] This Used To Be My Playground [b]xx[/b] I'll Remember [b]xx[/b] You'll See [b]xx[/b] You Must Love Me [b]xx[/b] Don't Cry For Me Argentina [b]xx[/b] Beautiful Stranger [b]xx[/b] American Pie [b]xx[/b] Die Another Day [b]xx[/b] Celebration [b]ALBUMS[/b] [b]xx[/b] Madonna [b]xx[/b] Like A Virgin [b]xx[/b] True Blue [b]xx[/b] Like A Prayer [b]xx[/b] Erotica [b]xx[/b] Bedtime Stories [b]xx[/b] Ray of Light [b]xx[/b] Music [b]xx[/b] American Life [b]xx[/b] Confessions on a Dancefloor [b]xx[/b] Hard Candy [b]xx[/b] MDNA
August 5, 201410 yr Author Only 3 11's? :( Going to be a bloodbath :drama: (i was considering having ONE 11 first, but realised how gravely impossible this was)
August 5, 201410 yr Without wishing to sound like a swimming pool sign, no hanky panky? Although it would clearly end up towards the very bottom of the results so no great loss I guess. Only Madge could have sent that into the top 2.
August 5, 201410 yr Author Dress You Up appears twice, are there 2 versions or something? [/flopfan] Oops no! Definitely just the one as far as i'm aware. Edited~ Without wishing to sound like a swimming pool sign, no hanky panky? Although it would clearly end up towards the very bottom of the results so no great loss I guess. Only Madge could have sent that into the top 2. If you want it, it's in there, but it was one of my eye-rolling cuts because i like to forget it exists. We will be culling into a top 40 come results time, and i doubt it'd survive there so... Oh what the hey, it's in :magic:
August 5, 201410 yr SINGLES 05 Everybody 08 Burning Up 07 Holiday 7.5 Lucky Star 09 Borderline 09 Like A Virgin 09 Crazy For You 10 Material Girl 10 Angel 08 Into The Groove 06 Dress You Up 10 Live To Tell 09 Papa Don't Preach 06 True Blue 08 Open Your Heart 09 La Isla Bonita 10 Like A Prayer 07 Express Yourself 04 Cherish 08 Oh Father 07 Dear Jessie 05 Keep It Together 09 Erotica 10 Deeper and Deeper 08 Bad Girl 05 Fever 10 Rain 09 Secret 06 Take A Bow 07 Bedtime Story 08 Human Nature 06 Frozen 08 Ray of Light 07 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 10 The Power of Goodbye 06 Nothing Really Matters 07 Music 6.5 Don't Tell Me 10 What It Feels Like For A Girl 10 American Life 09 Hollywood 11 Nothing Fails 10 Love Profusion 09 Hung Up 8.5 Sorry 07 Get Together 09 Jump 11 4 Minutes 08 Give It 2 Me 7.5 Miles Away 8.5 Give Me All Your Lovin' 11 Girl Gone Wild 8.5 Masterpiece 09 Turn Up The Radio 07 Who's That Girl 03 Causing A Commotion 08 Vogue 09 Hanky Panky 5.5 Justify My Love 7.5 This Used To Be My Playground 07 I'll Remember 09 You'll See 09 You Must Love Me 10 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 8.5 Beautiful Stranger 7.5 American Pie 7.5 Die Another Day 10 Celebration ALBUMS 06 Madonna 07 Like A Virgin 07 True Blue 05 Like A Prayer 07 Erotica 06 Bedtime Stories 05 Ray of Light 07 Music 11 American Life 08 Confessions on a Dancefloor 10 Hard Candy 10 MDNA Edited August 7, 201410 yr by Regina
August 5, 201410 yr Doesn't she have her own forum? The genre forums are so full of rates, since when the artists with their own forum are allowed to make rates here too? TOO MUCH. If her forum is dead, then close it and organize the rate here, but you can't have it all: having her own forum and flooding the general forums with useless rates. Edited August 5, 201410 yr by Hayzayy
August 5, 201410 yr 04 Everybody 05 Burning Up 07 Holiday 06 Lucky Star 07 Borderline 8.5 Like A Virgin 11 Material Girl 06 Angel 07 Into The Groove 06 Dress You Up 07 Live To Tell 7.5 Papa Don't Preach 8.5 True Blue 07 Open Your Heart 7.5 La Isla Bonita 5.5 Dress You Up 11 Like A Prayer 8.5 Express Yourself 8.5 Cherish 05 Oh Father 4.5 Dear Jessie 4.5 Keep It Together -1 Erotica 07 Deeper and Deeper 04 Bad Girl 05 Fever 05 Secret 07 Take A Bow 6.5 Bedtime Story 5.5 Human Nature 09 Frozen 8.5 Ray of Light 4.5 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 8.5 The Power of Goodbye 05 Nothing Really Matters 07 Music 05 Don't Tell Me 05 What It Feels Like For A Girl 03 American Life 05 Hollywood 04 Nothing Fails 04 Love Profusion 11 Hung Up 7.5 Sorry 05 Get Together 05 Jump 03 4 Minutes 06 Give It 2 Me 05 Miles Away 05 Give Me All Your Lovin' 03 Girl Gone Wild 03 Masterpiece 04 Turn Up The Radio 08 Who's That Girl 05 Causing A Commotion 9.5Vogue 5.5 Justify My Love 7.5 This Used To Be My Playground 6.5 I'll Remember 09 You'll See 07 You Must Love Me 07 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 07 Beautiful Stranger 06 American Pie 05 Die Another Day 08 Celebration ALBUMS 04 Madonna 07 Like A Virgin 07 True Blue 11 Like A Prayer 04 Erotica 06 Bedtime Stories 10 Ray of Light 08 Music 6.5 American Life 8.5 Confessions on a Dancefloor 05 Hard Candy 2.5 MDNA
August 5, 201410 yr Author We're off *.* An 11 for 'Nothing Fails' is one of the nicest shocks there Regina and i had no idea you were such a fan too. What a beauty especially the second half. 'What It Feels Like For A Girl' too <33 Will be mourning any low scores for 'Jump' btw.. Doesn't she have her own forum? The genre forums are so full of rates, since when the artists with their own forum are allowed to make rates here too? TOO MUCH. Yes, she does have her own forum but as mentioned this was discussed between myself, the pop mods and the Madonna forum mods as i felt this was the optimum place for it because it would attract a lot of casual forum visiters. It's a rate on one of the most well known pop artists of all time, so i think it has a home in the pop forum.
August 5, 201410 yr SINGLES 08.0 Everybody 08.5 Burning Up 08.0 Holiday 07.0 Lucky Star 07.5 Borderline 09.0 Like A Virgin 08.0 Material Girl 07.0 Angel 08.5 Into The Groove 07.0 Dress You Up 06.0 Live To Tell 09.0 Papa Don't Preach 07.5 True Blue 08.0 Open Your Heart 09.0 La Isla Bonita 08.5 Like A Prayer 08.0 Express Yourself 08.0 Cherish 06.5 Oh Father 07.0 Dear Jessie 07.0 Keep It Together 09.0 Erotica 07.0 Deeper and Deeper 07.0 Bad Girl 07.5 Fever 07.0 Secret 08.0 Take A Bow 06.5 Bedtime Story 07.5 Human Nature 11.0 Frozen 09.0 Ray of Light 07.0 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 10.0 The Power of Goodbye 07.0 Nothing Really Matters 08.5 Music 09.0 Don't Tell Me 06.0 What It Feels Like For A Girl 08.0 American Life 08.0 Hollywood 08.5 Nothing Fails 08.0 Love Profusion 06.5 Hung Up 07.5 Sorry 10.0 Get Together 08.0 Jump -01.0 4 Minutes 06.5 Give It 2 Me 10.0 Miles Away 07.0 Give Me All Your Lovin' 10.0 Girl Gone Wild 06.0 Masterpiece 06.5 Turn Up The Radio 07.0 Who's That Girl 06.5 Causing A Commotion 08.0 Vogue 06.0 Hanky Panky 08.0 Justify My Love 07.0 This Used To Be My Playground 07.5 I'll Remember 10.0 You'll See 06.5 You Must Love Me 07.0 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 08.0 Beautiful Stranger 06.0 American Pie 08.0 Die Another Day 09.5 Celebration
August 5, 201410 yr Hausage, everything from American Life deserves an 11 tbh. Doesn't she have her own forum? The genre forums are so full of rates, since when the artists with their own forum are allowed to make rates here too? TOO MUCH. If her forum is dead, then close it and organize the rate here, but you can't have it all: having her own forum and flooding the general forums with useless rates. Jesus, calm down before you burst a blood vessel. Edited August 5, 201410 yr by Regina
August 5, 201410 yr SINGLES 06 Everybody 07 Burning Up 09 Holiday 06 Lucky Star 08 Borderline 10 Like A Virgin 09 Material Girl -1 Crazy For You 07 Angel 10 Into The Groove 08 Dress You Up 06 Live To Tell 10 Papa Don't Preach 07 True Blue 08 Open Your Heart 10 La Isla Bonita 11 Like A Prayer 10 Express Yourself 07 Cherish 09 Oh Father 06 Dear Jessie 05 Keep It Together 04 Erotica 05 Deeper and Deeper 03 Bad Girl 04 Fever 04 Rain 05 Secret 06 Take A Bow 06 Bedtime Story 06 Human Nature 10 Frozen 11 Ray of Light 08 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 08 The Power of Goodbye 07 Nothing Really Matters 07 Music 09 Don't Tell Me 06 What It Feels Like For A Girl 10 American Life 08 Hollywood 09 Nothing Fails 08 Love Profusion 11 Hung Up 10 Sorry 09 Get Together 08 Jump 09 4 Minutes 09 Give It 2 Me 10 Miles Away 07 Give Me All Your Lovin' 08 Girl Gone Wild 10 Masterpiece 08 Turn Up The Radio 06 Who's That Girl 04 Causing A Commotion 10 Vogue 07 Hanky Panky 03 Justify My Love 04 This Used To Be My Playground 06 I'll Remember 07 You'll See 07 You Must Love Me 10 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 09 Beautiful Stranger 10 American Pie 08 Die Another Day 10 Celebration ALBUMS 06 Madonna 09 Like A Virgin 08 True Blue 10 Like A Prayer 03 Erotica 04 Bedtime Stories 10 Ray of Light 07 Music 10 American Life 11 Confessions on a Dancefloor 08 Hard Candy 07 MDNA
August 5, 201410 yr Doesn't she have her own forum? The genre forums are so full of rates, since when the artists with their own forum are allowed to make rates here too? TOO MUCH. If her forum is dead, then close it and organize the rate here, but you can't have it all: having her own forum and flooding the general forums with useless rates. Yes, she does have her own forum but as mentioned this was discussed between myself, the pop mods and the Madonna forum mods as i felt this was the optimum place for it because it would attract a lot of casual forum visiters. It's a rate on one of the most well known pop artists of all time, so i think it has a home in the pop forum. To be fair, they were (sort of) my initial thoughts too Hayzayy but putting them in artist forums does take away a lot of potential raters and seeing as its something we haven't done before we thought we should give it a try for the reasons Haus describes above. However I agree with you again that this is a prime example that the artist forums cut off too much general discussion and should be either closed or be completely reorganised but that's a discussion for another time.
August 5, 201410 yr I will be doing my rate soon. Borderline & Live To Tell for top 10 or this rate is null and void!
August 5, 201410 yr Author Like the Michael Jackson rate, i really have NO idea which was this will go. The obvious ones are probably 'Like A Prayer', 'Frozen' and 'Hung Up' to be in the top 10 but there are a lot of others waiting behind i'm sure. And for dark horses, i'm hoping people forget what album it's from, and rate 'Masterpiece' for the masterpiece that it is <3
August 5, 201410 yr SINGLES 07 Everybody 10 Burning Up 09 Holiday 08 Lucky Star 09 Borderline 09 Like A Virgin 08 Material Girl 08 Crazy For You 08 Angel 08 Into The Groove 10 Dress You Up 08 Live To Tell 09 Papa Don't Preach 04 True Blue 10 Open Your Heart 07 La Isla Bonita 08 Like A Prayer 09 Express Yourself 11 Cherish :wub: :wub: 04 Oh Father 03 Dear Jessie 07 Keep It Together 08 Erotica 09 Deeper and Deeper 08 Bad Girl 08 Fever 09 Rain 07 Secret 08 Take A Bow 07 Bedtime Story 08 Human Nature 10 Frozen 10 Ray of Light 09 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 10 The Power of Goodbye 08 Nothing Really Matters 08 Music 07 Don't Tell Me 05 What It Feels Like For A Girl (The Above & Beyond remix however is a 9!) 07 American Life 09 Hollywood 08 Nothing Fails 07 Love Profusion 08 Hung Up 10 Sorry 08 Get Together 10 Jump 07 4 Minutes 09 Give It 2 Me 07 Miles Away 07 Give Me All Your Lovin' 08 Girl Gone Wild 08 Masterpiece 06 Turn Up The Radio 07 Who's That Girl 05 Causing A Commotion 11 Vogue 04 Hanky Panky 09 Justify My Love 06 This Used To Be My Playground 05 I'll Remember 10 You'll See 03 You Must Love Me 02 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 11 Beautiful Stranger 07 American Pie (slight guilty pleasure) 07 Die Another Day 08 Celebration ALBUMS 09 Madonna 08 Like A Virgin 08 True Blue 09 Like A Prayer 08 Erotica 06 Bedtime Stories 11 Ray of Light 07 Music 06 American Life 10 Confessions on a Dancefloor 00 Hard Candy 08 MDNA Edited August 7, 201410 yr by mr_aly
August 5, 201410 yr Yes, she does have her own forum but as mentioned this was discussed between myself, the pop mods and the Madonna forum mods as i felt this was the optimum place for it because it would attract a lot of casual forum visiters. It's a rate on one of the most well known pop artists of all time, so i think it has a home in the pop forum. My point was that the "forum artists" seem to have it all compared to new-ish/less popular artists. They have their own forums, but now and then they are allowed to go in the genre forums for rates and stuff because they don't have visitors enough. And I love Madonna so I'm not saying it cause it's about her. I would say the same about GA. The thing is the genre forums tend to lose their appeal. I used to come here to find about new sounds and new music, but all you get now is a page full of rates/games and a few obvious threads about songs you can hear everywhere else anyway. That's especially true in the pop forum (and god knows how much I love my pop). New threads/new artists tend to get lost in all of this and I think that's bad. But that's just my point of view and sorry if I sounded a bit rude in my initial post. :) Wouldn't it better to create a separate sub-forum with all the rates and games, and let the genre forums be about the actual MUSIC?
August 5, 201410 yr SINGLES 06 Everybody 06 Burning Up 08 Holiday 08 Lucky Star 09 Borderline 07 Like A Virgin 07 Material Girl 07 Angel 08 Into The Groove 07 Dress You Up 10 Live To Tell 08 Papa Don't Preach 06 True Blue 08 Open Your Heart 10 La Isla Bonita 11 Like A Prayer 09 Express Yourself 10 Cherish 07 Oh Father 08 Dear Jessie 06 Keep It Together 07 Erotica 08 Deeper and Deeper 06 Bad Girl 06 Fever 09 Secret 09 Take A Bow 07 Bedtime Story 07 Human Nature 10 Frozen 09 Ray of Light 06 Drowned World (Substitute For Love) 11 The Power of Goodbye 09 Nothing Really Matters 06 Music 07 Don't Tell Me 06 What It Feels Like For A Girl 05 American Life 06 Hollywood 07 Nothing Fails 08 Love Profusion 11 Hung Up 10 Sorry 08 Get Together 09 Jump 09 4 Minutes 09 Give It 2 Me 07 Miles Away 08 Give Me All Your Lovin' 08 Girl Gone Wild 09 Masterpiece 06 Turn Up The Radio 07 Who's That Girl 07 Causing A Commotion 09 Vogue 06 Hanky Panky 09 Justify My Love 07 This Used To Be My Playground 07 I'll Remember 09 You'll See 07 You Must Love Me 08 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 10 Beautiful Stranger 02 American Pie 05 Die Another Day 10 Celebration ALBUMS 07 Madonna 08 Like A Virgin 07 True Blue 09 Like A Prayer 07 Erotica 07 Bedtime Stories 09 Ray of Light 07 Music 06 American Life 11 Confessions on a Dancefloor 08 Hard Candy 09 MDNA
Create an account or sign in to comment