Well Matthew sounded better than the studio version but he's a shoe in for last place surely.

I finished work early to make sure I could watch and I was so engrossed watching Muder she wrote I missed the first 30 mins!:(

Well Matthew sounded better than the studio version but he's a shoe in for last place surely.

Really? I thought it was far worse than the studio version. If we pick this, it's going to be a contender for last place in Stockholm.

Disappointed with Until Tomorrow live, whoever was trying to harmonise throughout that was flat the whole time trying to do so. I'm not convinced that is the wisest winner at all, as nice as it is. Definitely the best so far though.

This is by FAR the best song so far, really lovely and pretty instant. The vocals were a bit off at times sadly, they'd really need to work on that if they went to Eurovision.

Matthew was boring.

 

I enjoyed Darline.

Omg that as SO GOOD live!! I can't see it now, it would work so well at Eurovision, so sweet so pure!! They've got my vote so far and I've hated it before!

Just saw that the vocals were off on the broadcast, this would be a good winner though, they sounded brilliant here!

That was nice and quite good, but it was missing something :(

 

Dulcima 8/10

Matthew James -1/10

Darlene 8/10

Mr Lund seems to have precisely zero stage presence.

Well that was painful and dull and went nowhere

 

Dulcima 8/10

Matthew James -1/10

Darlene 8/10

Karl 0/10

That felt a lot more... eh live. I just can't shake the feeling the whole song should really be Guetta'd up, Without You springs to mind. He is very easy on the eye and the song has potential but he's not totally there. I think he's the most nervous so far and I'm not sure.

He's got a good voice but the song and performance are not emphatic enough, it all feels a tad limp.

Karl was good but it felt incomplete. Darline have this so far.

'Miracle' desperately needs a revamp but is it just me or the BBC really wants this to win?

Did the judges really watch the same performance that I've just seen?

It's like when dance acts have "candelight remixes" of their songs... only there isn't even another version of it to bring it to life.

Everything so far has just been 'nice', sums up this selection perfectly.

This sounds so much like a Parade track!

This Bianca song doesn't sound as bad as it did when I first listened to it. It's still not that good though.

To me, 'Shine A Little Light' is the best so far. A very good vocal, she has stage presence. Is it a fantastic, unique song? No, but she can definitely deliver it and I wouldn't be embarassed to have this represent us.