Posted November 8, 20159 yr http://images.j-14.com/uploads/posts/image/72903/one-direction.jpg So the album is OUT THERE in full, in decent quality, and it's now time to review your thoughts. This rate will be open for a few weeks, so if you're waiting for the official release, don't panic :heehee: We'll re-do this rate in a few months to see how your thoughts have changed over time, as we know some songs will grow and some will regress. Will be interesting to compare! THE RULES - Rate every song 0-10. - One 11 and one -1 are allowed. - Half marks are allowed but no 10.5 or -0.5 because they're not in the above range. Oh and also no other decimals like 6.2 or something silly. THE SONGS xx.x Hey Angel xx.x Drag Me Down xx.x Perfect xx.x Infinity xx.x End of the Day xx.x If I Could Fly xx.x Long Way Down xx.x Never Enough xx.x Olivia xx.x What a Feeling xx.x Love You Goodbye xx.x I Want to Write You a Song xx.x History xx.x Temporary Fix xx.x Walking in the Wind xx.x Wolves xx.x A.M.
November 8, 20159 yr Author 08.5 Hey Angel 11.0 Drag Me Down 10.0 Perfect 09.0 Infinity 08.0 End of the Day 10.0 If I Could Fly 07.5 Long Way Down 09.0 Never Enough 07.0 Olivia 08.5 What a Feeling 10.0 Love You Goodbye (favourite non-single :heart:) 08.0 I Want to Write You a Song 08.5 History 10.0 Temporary Fix 09.5 Walking in the Wind 08.5 Wolves 10.0 A.M. Very solid :heart:
November 8, 20159 yr 10.0 Hey Angel 11.0 Drag Me Down 07.0 Perfect 07.0 Infinity 10.0 End of the Day 06.0 If I Could Fly 08.0 Long Way Down 09.0 Never Enough 10.0 Olivia 10.0 What a Feeling 09.0 Love You Goodbye 08.0 I Want to Write You a Song 10.0 History 10.0 Temporary Fix 09.0 Walking in the Wind 09.0 Wolves 08.0 A.M.
November 10, 20159 yr 07.5 Hey Angel 10.0 Drag Me Down 11.0 Perfect 08.5 Infinity 05.0 End of the Day 09.0 If I Could Fly 06.0 Long Way Down 04.0 Never Enough 03.5 Olivia 07.5 What a Feeling 10.0 Love You Goodbye 03.0 I Want to Write You a Song 06.5 History 07.0 Temporary Fix 05.0 Walking in the Wind 07.0 Wolves 08.0 A.M.
November 11, 20159 yr This is atrocious compared to their previous lead singles. Really hoping this will grow, but at the moment there's just... nothing there at all. (I shall get doing mine soon x)
November 11, 20159 yr Author This is atrocious compared to their previous lead singles. Really hoping this will grow, but at the moment there's just... nothing there at all. http://i61.tinypic.com/2ephr2b.png
November 13, 20159 yr 07.0 Hey Angel 06.0 Drag Me Down 09.0 Perfect 07.0 Infinity 06.5 End Of The Day 08.0 If I Could Fly 06.5 Long Way Down 08.5 Never Enough 07.0 Olivia 11.0 What A Feeling 07.0 Love You Goodbye -1.0 I Want To Write You A Song 07.5 History 06.0 Temporary Fix 06.5 Walking In The Wind 06.5 Wolves 05.0 A.M. One word to describe this album: dull. WHERE did the pop songs and brilliant choruses go?? Seriously, I can't believe in a year they've gone from 'FOUR' to, this. I shall gladly take an EP of 'Perfect', 'If I Could Fly', 'Never Enough' and 'What A Feeling', but the rest :/ As a body of work, it just seems so, monotonous. I understand the days of 'Take Me Home' are long gone, but 'FOUR' proved you can be grown up and mature whilst still delivering amazing pop songs. This smacks of "real music". 'I Want To Write You A Song' offends me, it is 'Gotta Be You' levels of disgusting. BUT A POSITIVE 'What A Feeling' is one of the best 1D tracks yet, so bravo. 3rd single pls.
November 13, 20159 yr 08.0 Hey Angel 09.0 Drag Me Down 09.5 Perfect 09.0 Infinity 08.5 End of the Day 08.0 If I Could Fly 07.0 Long Way Down 08.0 Never Enough 07.0 Olivia 08.5 What a Feeling 07.0 Love You Goodbye 07.5 I Want to Write You a Song 09.0 History 08.0 Temporary Fix 07.0 Walking in the Wind 07.5 Wolves 08.5 A.M.
November 14, 20159 yr 09.0 Hey Angel 09.5 Drag Me Down 11.0 Perfect 09.0 Infinity 07.5 End of the Day 08.0 If I Could Fly 08.0 Long Way Down 09.0 Never Enough 09.0 Olivia 10.0 What a Feeling 08.0 Love You Goodbye 06.5 I Want to Write You a Song 08.5 History 08.5 Temporary Fix 07.5 Walking in the Wind 08.0 Wolves 08.5 A.M. "I Want To Write You A Song" sounds like it belongs on a Nicholas Sparks novel.
November 17, 20159 yr Never Enough is life. Never has a truer word been spoken. 07.0 Hey Angel 09.0 Drag Me Down 07.5 Perfect 09.0 Infinity 09.0 End of the Day 08.5 If I Could Fly 04.0 Long Way Down 11.0 Never Enough 09.0 Olivia 09.5 What a Feeling 10.0 Love You Goodbye 10.0 I Want to Write You a Song 08.5 History 09.0 Temporary Fix 06.5 Walking in the Wind 04.0 Wolves 10.0 A.M. Another solid album from the boys :D Edited November 17, 20159 yr by MANGØ
November 17, 20159 yr Author Mango can you post here more please? We need more Love You Goodbye stans *.*
November 17, 20159 yr Mango can you post here more please? We need more Love You Goodbye stans *.* Ha, I hardly ever come to the artist forums but I should. I've got Love You Goodbye, A.M. and Never Enough on a repeat cycle at the moment, I literally cannot stop listening to them :blink:
November 17, 20159 yr Author Love You Goodbye and A.M. are incredible songs I think, really can't get enough of them, the former seems very underrated here :( Never Enough is a highlight too!
November 18, 20159 yr Love You Goodbye and A.M. are incredible songs I think, really can't get enough of them, the former seems very underrated here :( Never Enough is a highlight too! Well if people don't have taste, then it's clearly their problem :unsure: that last chorus where everything but the vocals is stripped out for a couple of lines is GORGEOUS :wub:
November 18, 20159 yr THE SONGS 05.0 Hey Angel 09.0 Drag Me Down 10.0 Perfect 07.5 Infinity 06.0 End of the Day 07.0 If I Could Fly 07.0 Long Way Down 11.0 Never Enough 04.0 Olivia 09.0 What a Feeling 05.0 Love You Goodbye 04.0 I Want to Write You a Song 07.0 History 08.0 Temporary Fix 07.0 Walking in the Wind 00.0 Wolves 03.0 A.M. Very, very, very disappointed with this album.
November 18, 20159 yr 11.0 Never Enough Absolutely correct :dance: Very, very, very disappointed with this album. Give it a few listens! Edited November 18, 20159 yr by Mangø
November 18, 20159 yr Author Well if people don't have taste, then it's clearly their problem :unsure: that last chorus where everything but the vocals is stripped out for a couple of lines is GORGEOUS :wub: I agree with this entire post :heehee: The chorus is the best part for sure, any ballad with Harry on lead is basically flawless though :wub:
December 26, 20159 yr Probs missed the rate now, but i thought i'd pop this here anyway. As much as I liked the album, my initial thoughts were it was below the standard they had set themselves over the past 3 albums, maybe it lacked a little Zayn magic IDK. But I've been really binge listening it both today and yesterday, and I have to say I think I was very wrong, it has grown on me so much to the point where I think it might be on par with MM for me as my second fav. Wolves, Temporary Fix, What A Feeling, Never Enough; are all complete jams, and up there with their best album tracks imo. 09 - Hey Angel 10 - Drag Me Down 10 - Perfect 09 - Infinity 10 - End Of The Day 08 - If I Could Fly 09 - Long Way Down 10 - Never Enough 08 - Olivia 10 - What A Feeling 08 - Love You Goodbye 07 - I Want To Write You A Song 09 - History 10 - Temporary Fix 06 - Walking In The Wind 11 - Wolves 10 - A.M. Edited December 26, 20159 yr by Jimmy Jam
