Least Favorite Disney Animated Classic Round 2

Posted November 19, 20159 yr

Welcome Buzzjack to Round 2 of Least fave Disney Animated Classic, and after an overwhelming response to the first round and again thanks guys, we lose the first 5 of the 54 features. Right due to the error of the last round, I didn't count the votes for the last 4 because of I exceeded the maximum of 50 questions. But now that we're down to 49 movies, all votes will count.

There were no surprises really of the ones that went, 4 of them were the Disney propaganda package films which most people probably haven't heard off and the other was "Dinosaur" which was their first fully CGI picture and basically an updated version of "The Land Before Time".

54th Melody Time = 11 Votes

Gaining the most votes and settling for last place is "Melody Time", gaining just one more vote than the other 3 package films that have dropped. This was just basically showing that the company were on hard times during WW 2 and were forced to make these propaganda movies to make the public feel good while the war was going on. While this isn't terrible I do have trouble remembering it, apart from the Johnny Appleseed section.

53rd Saludos Amigos = 10 Votes

Another package film to drop and in fact their first one, this also has the shortest running time out of the lost with just 42 minutes in total and given that Disney lost most of their staff were recruited to the war and plus a strike going on at the same time, you can forgive them for rushing this out quickly. But this one also suffers from the same problems, firstly coming off the back of 5 Disney animated classics (Snow White, Pinocchio, Fantasia, Dumbo & Bambi), this doesn't measure up to those standards whatsoever and the film itself was just a bunch of shorts of people drawing while going on holiday. This is the first of the 3 way tie which all gained 10 votes for the 2nd from last position.

=53rd Make Mine Music = 10 Votes

In joint 53rd position is "Make Mine Music" which follows in the same vein as "Melody Time" and basically trying desperately to be like "Fantasia" by using the same formula, but failing in almost all areas with music that feels dated. There are 2 shorts that are pretty decent in this "Peter & The Wolf" and "The Whale who wanted to sing at the Met", but on the whole the animation was rushed and doesn't match up to the standards from their earlier releases.

=53rd Fun & Fancy Free = 10 Votes

Another package film drops "Fun & Fancy Free", this one features just 2 animated shorts where one features a circus bear experiencing the wild life which is okay and pretty harmless, while at the same time pretty forgettable and then the 2nd one is "Mickey and the Beanstalk" which is definitely the best out of the 2 and features a great scene where Donald Duck goes beserk, while on the whole the film itself may be disjointed, but the 2nd movie more than makes up for it.

50th Dinosaur = 8 Votes

http://resizing.flixster.com/7W1D_EBXk8lL5qY7cwhwh0GBI-M=/353x500/dkpu1ddg7pbsk.cloudfront.net/movie/10/92/08/10920812_ori.jpg

At the #50 is "Dinosaur" the only non propaganda film to drop in this bunch, gaining the lowest out of the 5 with 8 votes. This gained a lot of hype up until it was released and marked a first for Disney in using full CGI characters in real life backgrounds and while adventurous the movie itself was a total letdown, the effects look totally dated now and not very good anyway and the decision to have them talk, basically ruined it from being unique and instead ended up being compared unfavourably to "The Land Before Time".

So now then 49 movies left, same rules apply just vote for up to 5 of your least faves and the 5 with the most votes will be out by the next round which will be on Saturday.

Results So Far

50th Dinosaur = 8/6.96%

=53rd Saludos Amigos = 10/8.70%

=53rd Make Mine Music = 10/8.70%

=53rd Fun & Fancy Free = 10/8.70%

54th Melody Time = 11/9.57%

Edited November 19, 20159 yr by Acidburn