April 24, 20169 yr 1) Donna 2) Rose 3) Clara 4) Amy 5) Martha I love that whatever the discussed topic is, Joseph's faves are always the lamest :lol:
April 24, 20169 yr Author Martha is totally underrated, it's such a shame. She wasn't perfect and I wish they didn't have the concept of unrequited love between her and the Doctor but other than that, I definitely don't get the hate, she was a strong character, and she came about at the peak of my love for the show, hence why she is my #1 :wub:
April 24, 20169 yr I don't think anyone hates her. She just didn't seem particularly interesting and was unfortunate to land between Rose and Donna for her tenure as companion.
April 24, 20169 yr 1) Donna 2) Rose 3) Clara 4) Amy 5) Martha I love that whatever the discussed topic is, Joseph's faves are always the lamest :lol: :lol: 1. Rose 2. Amy 3. Clara 3. Donna 5. Rory 6. Rose's Mum 7. John Barryman 8. Mickey 9. Martha Edited April 24, 20169 yr by Virginia's Walls
April 24, 20169 yr 1. Amy (ofc :wub:) 2. Rose 3. Clara 4. Donna 5. John Barryman 6. Martha 7. Rory 8. Mickey 9. Rose's Mum
April 24, 20169 yr I hated that trailer. It was awful. It was so cheesy and so set up, especially the slow turn and questionable acting.
April 24, 20169 yr I'm withholding judgement until I've seen her in a proper episode. There's definitely potential there and she does seem more 'street' than any of the other recent companions which could make for some amusing moments with Capaldi's Doctor (and it's also quite a refreshing change.) Too early to judge so WE'LL SEE.
April 24, 20169 yr RANK RANK RANK 1. Queen Clara Oswald 2. Princess Rose Tyler 3. Donna Noble 4. Martha Jonas 5. Amy Pond The companion looks interesting! Can't really judge by a 2 minute clip, but she seems decent. Edited April 24, 20169 yr by Garyy
May 17, 20169 yr 1) Donna 2) Rose 3) Martha 4) River 5) Clara 6) Sarah Jane 7) Donna's Grandpa 8) Rose's Mum 9) Amy 10) Captain Jack 11) Rory 12) The guy that traveled with The Doctor and Rose for a couple of episodes in Series 1 13) Mickey
May 20, 20169 yr 12) The guy that traveled with The Doctor and Rose for a couple of episodes in Series 1 It was Adam I think? Can't remember his surname. Wasn't that big on him as a character though.
May 22, 20169 yr 01. Rose 02. Donna 03. Martha 04. Clara 05. Amy Rose still ranks the highest being the best companion since 2005. Donna is a close second, with them both having their fair share of scenes which made me cry lol. Martha and Clara were both nice additions to the show, but I feel lacked the personality Rose/Donna captured. Why was Amy even a character, completely dreadful and honestly what made me turn off the show for a while.
May 22, 20169 yr Rose was good in series 1, but I hated the whole fawning over the Doctor version of Rose in Series 2 and Martha in Series 3. It works better when the Doctor had his companion are just good friends. For me, this is why Rose in Series 1 and Donna are the best.
May 23, 20169 yr I never liked Rose with Tennant. She was best with Eccleston. Tennant's best companion was obviously Donna.
June 14, 20169 yr Author Confirmed by the BBC that Matt Lucas is reprising his role as Nardole throughout series 10! Not sure if that means he'll be a head in a robot again or what but he was amusing in the Christmas special I guess, interested to see how it will work.
July 8, 20169 yr Today marks 10 years since Doomsday aired... god I feel old :( Wow, this is more surprising than me than any of the stats in the lounge thread!
Create an account or sign in to comment