As ever, COADF is overrated here -_-

Crazy For You ridiculously low! :cry: Adore it. :heart:

Crazy For You ridiculously low! :cry: Adore it. :heart:

 

It got generally really good scores but there were a couple of trolly scores that brought down the average massively.

Crazy For You's key role in 13 Going On 30 made me love it more than I did tbh.

It's a shame you included grifs ridiculous votes . There was more than enough full entries to not warrant this .

 

Therefore one member only has had a massive impact on the results .

 

After ruining the thread purposefully he has not made another contribution.

Edited March 29, 20169 yr by vibe

Jesus calm down.

Be quiet Regina what i said makes complete sense ! I am not being irrational in anyway. Running pools like this is s tremendous amount of work yet one member has basically made the results futile.

Edited March 29, 20169 yr by vibe

His results were very unlike the rest of the site but at the end of the day its not fair to exclude him for that reason.

I mean, I'll never understand that 0 for CFY, which is one of Madonna's best ballads - but you can't trust someone who's never heard Like a Virgin anyway ;) . But as annoying the rate may have been, there's not really any grounds to exclude them, you'll be hard pushed to find a rate that doesn't have at least one weird rate that causes some upset.

I mean, I'll never understand that 0 for CFY, which is one of Madonna's best ballads - but you can't trust someone who's never heard Like a Virgin anyway ;) . But as annoying the rate may have been, there's not really any grounds to exclude them, you'll be hard pushed to find a rate that doesn't have at least one weird rate that causes some upset.

Yeah we all know your one had a fair few :rolleyes:

Anyone giving Hung Up anything over a 6 deserved to have their rates voided tbh.

i gave it a 7 but i think i should have scored it lower tbh.

*Any rates with a Hung Up score less than 10 should've been voided. -_-

*Any rates with a Hung Up score less than 10 should've been voided. -_-

Yes, what are you on Regina? :wacko: serious tune! :music:

Hung Up is one of her worst songs.

 

 

I'm Going Bananas >>>>>

Toby speaks truth.

:no:

Regina, hun, I love you and all but JUMP OFF A CLIFF INTO A NEST OF VIPERS please xox

Like, WHY is Hung Up so bad? I mean I can just about comprehend people thinking it's 7 worthy, it's still an incorrect opinion and I feel sorry for their existence, but I can accept it. I've never quite understood your hatred though? Like what is so bad about it? I promise to try and be open minded and listen to what you have to say.

 

(I can't promise not to rip your larynx out and feed it to a piranha afterwards, but SURPRISE ME)

I think that it relies far too much on its sample and is only so highly regarded because of it. The whole "ABBA not allowing people to sample their music" thing made HU seem more impressive than it was. Without it, bobody would love it as much. I realise that a sample is used to enhance a song but in this case it just overtakes it and doesn't leave room for anyting else about the song to shine, not that theres much. Also it samples one of ABBA's poorer sonsgs.

 

It being so loved makes me kinda hate it too, an artist's best loved/successful song tends to fall into this trap.

Edited March 29, 20169 yr by Regina