Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Author
5 years on :o Where has the time gone, seriously. Did ANYONE expect this to do as well as it did off the back off Perfect Illusion? It's one of her highest streamed songs and the way it smashed into the top 5 on Billboard after the Superbowl :cheeseblock: :clap:
  • Replies 260
  • Views 24.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

it's completely amazing and one of her signature songs these days. She also worked so hard to sell the song to audience and I think it kind of saved the era in the end? One of my absolute faves!
  • Author
I hardly ever return to the music video :tearsmile: the song grew on me so much over time though! Now it's a beautiful ballad and a key part of her journey to redeeming her chart success after a few quieter moments on the charts!

The video is perhaps in her bottom 5. It does, however, give us the trademark and most distinctive Joanne look.

 

Her live performances of the song are so good, especially the Royal Variety one.

Edited by Sour Candy

A-YO should have been the lead single instead of Perfect Mess.
Remember when trolls wanted A-Yo to be a single over this!? :tearsmile:

 

Didn't Gaga even want that at some point? I swear I remember that being the case. It's like the 'Venus' of this era.

 

This song definitely feels waaaay bigger than its chart peak suggests in the UK, it's far outsold 'Perfect Illusion' hasn't it?

Yes, Gaga was torn between A-YO and MR, but as MR performed better with the audience, she chose the latter to work on, like Venus and DWUW in 2013.
Didn't Gaga even want that at some point? I swear I remember that being the case. It's like the 'Venus' of this era.

 

This song definitely feels waaaay bigger than its chart peak suggests in the UK, it's far outsold 'Perfect Illusion' hasn't it?

 

Yep, this is certified gold, PI silver.

 

Gaga promote this a lot in the UK, bizarre that it didn't take off. Maybe it's just "too country".

 

One of her best singles and I love how many performances there are to watch! A true gem. Although shame about the video, truly awful for her standards.
  • Author
Love that! It's really the little engine that could - went against all odds and became a bonafide hit in the US. I thank it a lot for getting support back to her from radios/streaming after Perfect Illusion killed a lot of it off!
  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author
I just listened as part of the album because i'm doing the Joanne rate and it's such a restrained beauty. A centrepiece for the album in a way! :heart: Happy 5 years of not stressing that she was going to choose A-Yo over it as 2nd single :rofl:

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.