which the green day/u2 song or westlife

Confession time: I like both :unsure:

but i think it would be amazing if Green Day beat Westlife.

And my personal opinion of this song is U2 killed it. The video is sad :(

I have only heard a bit of it but I didn't really like it.

I think the song is a classic punk tune. The guitar riff is excellent. It's for charity so the vid is meant to be sad. My personal opinion is that Billie joe armstrong singing voice ruins the song for me :(

YA BILLY'S vpoice isnt at what suits him best in this song

I think the song is a classic punk tune. The guitar riff is excellent. It's for charity so the vid is meant to be sad. My personal opinion is that Billie joe armstrong singing voice ruins the song for me :(

Ahhh... a U2 fan, well you would say that :D lol i think Bono killed it tbh. But i like it i bought it on sunday but didn't realise it doesn't count for that weeks chart but at least i help for next week :D

Love the song. The live version is much better.. but I'm not overly keen on the video. And Billie-Joe needs a haircut desperately!!

THE LIVE VERSIONS are always better

The live version is very good but the singing quality isn't so good but i still listened to it non-stop for about 3 hours :D

the single has dropped down th echarts very quick i thought it woul dbe in the top 40 longer

It will teach them not to release c**p in future.

its not c**p it aint tthere best but i still like it

I'd say the only good thing about it is thats the money went to charity.

well that a good point but i like the song also

I blame U2. :D

U2 ARE great :)

But not as good as Green Day :P

Edited January 15, 200718 yr by Mrs Armstrong

true