With the discussion around Nicki’s part being too long in Woman Like Me, I thought it would be interesting to see what versions of their singles which had collaborators everyone prefers

Edited October 16, 20186 yr by andibob

NMSS is the only one I prefer without the guest, and even then I can go either way tbh. MGK doesn’t really add anything in my opinion

Tbh I’ve liked all of theses features . I prefer the album version of No More Sad Songs but Machine Gun Kelly’s verse is actually ok as well .

I prefer No More Sad Songs with Machine Gun Kelly, but mainly because they buffed up the production a bit, not because of the rap.

I actually prefer all their featured versions, bar Power (I like Stormzy but the girls' middle 8 >>>> his rap).

I struggled with choosing between NMSS. I adore both versions, but I opted for Album Version.

 

The only other one where I prefer without the guest is SLS I adore the Jason one, but I love, love LOVE pt 2.

 

I feel like they've done well with their features. The Missy Elliott version of HYD really propels that song for me. The original version is my least fave from DNA but they've spruced up the production a bit for the single release and it works.

How Ya Doin is the only one i like better with the guest with Hair being the next least bad feature although I still prefer the solo version Sean Paul doesn’t really destroy the song the way the others do.

 

Stormzy ruined Power and they cut off the best part

Solo SLS is better than Jason duet

Nicki destroys Woman Like Me with that awful curry line what she also did something similar in in Side to Side too

 

Edited October 24, 20186 yr by Jordan Lee