Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 138
  • Views 8.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Ps totally forgot to vote in this, wish I had done :cry:

 

Mine would have been:

1. Melanie C

2. Victoria Beckham

3. Geri Halliwell

4. Emma Bunton

5. Melanie B

6. Nicola Roberts

7. Lisa Left Eye Lopes

8. Cheryl Cole

9. Nadine Coyle

10. Mutya Buena

11. Siobhan Fahey

12. Sarah Harding

13. Kelly Rowland

14. Sarah Dallin

15. Tionne Watkins (T-Boz TLC)

16. Jesy Nelson

17. Melanie Blatt

18. Keren Woodward

19. Leigh-Anne Pinnock

20. Rozonda Thomas (Chilli TLC)

21. Jade Thirwall

22. Perrie Edwards

23. Liz McClarnon

24. Molly King

25. Shaznay Lewis

 

(A little Spice heavy at the beginning but they will always be my ultimate members lol)

 

Edited by Spiceboy

  • Author

18th Place - 88 Points

 

Jesy Nelson - Little Mix

 

after successfully all making into the Top 20, we lose two Little Mix Members in succession.

 

Perhaps the groups most inspiring member, Jesy Nelson takes 18th place in this countdown.

 

throughout Jesy’s time in Little Mix, she’s been endlessly bullied and harassed through social media - but in winter 2019 she took matters into her own hands, and released her own BBC documentary which has been viewed over 7 MILLION times (it’s live broadcast on BBC 1 gained more viewers than ANY episode of this years two X Factor seasons) and is nominated for a National Television Award next month.

 

 

Little Mix Members Placings:

 

Jesy Nelson - 18th

Leigh-Anne Pinnock - 19th

Jade Thirlwall - TBA

Perrie Edwards - TBA

Ps totally forgot to vote in this, wish I had done :cry:

 

Mine would have been:

1. Melanie C

2. Victoria Beckham

3. Geri Halliwell

4. Emma Bunton

5. Melanie B

6. Nicola Roberts

7. Lisa Left Eye Lopes

8. Cheryl Cole

9. Nadine Coyle

10. Mutya Buena

11. Siobhan Fahey

12. Sarah Harding

13. Kelly Rowland

14. Sarah Dallin

15. Tionne Watkins (T-Boz TLC)

16. Jesy Nelson

17. Melanie Blatt

18. Keren Woodward

19. Leigh-Anne Pinnock

20. Rozonda Thomas (Chilli TLC)

21. Jade Thirwall

22. Perrie Edwards

23. Liz McClarnon

24. Molly King

25. Shaznay Lewis

 

(A little Spice heavy at the beginning but they will always be my ultimate members lol)

What a fab top 10

 

  • Author

17th Place - 95 Points

 

Mutya Buena - Sugababes

 

Mutya was 1/3 of Sugababes original line up, and stayed with them for 7 years before her departure in 2005.

 

After leaving Sugababes, Mutya went on to achieve the UK Number 2 single Real Girl alongside two solo albums - Mutya has now returned to the ‘babes after appearing on shows such as Celebs Go Dating and Celebrity Big Brother.

 

 

Sugababes Members Placings:

 

Mutya Buena - 17th

Siobhan Donaghy - 30th

Amelie Berrabah - 31st

Heidi Range - 32nd

Jade Ewen - 40th

Keisha Buchanan - TBA

Little Mix have really sold over 50 million records?? Wow I did not know that, pretty incredible!

 

Nope! Mostly fake streams. Fifth member Cowell is behind the manufactured corporate sales.

  • Author

16th Place - 97 Points

 

Keisha Buchanan - Sugababes

 

coming out on top of the six ever changing members of Sugababes, it’s Keisha.

 

The longest serving Sugababes of 13 years racked up 97 points to finish in 16th Place on this countdown - and rightly so.

 

Keisha achieved 16 UK Top 10 singles, 6 UK Number 1’s and MILLIONS of record sales - and once our final original Sugababe ‘left’ (was kicked out) of the group, the group really lost their momentum from the public, and only released one further album before calling it a day and fizzling out.

 

 

Sugababes Members Placings:

 

Keisha Buchanan - 16th

Mutya Buena - 17th

Siobhan Donaghy - 30th

Amelie Berrabah - 31st

Heidi Range - 32nd

Jade Ewen - 40th

Edited by miichaelking21

Would have thought both Mutya and Keisha would have been top 15. Glad that all 5 of the Spices are yet to come and 3 of GA
  • Author

15th Place - 98 Points

 

Nicole Scherzinger - Pussycat Dolls

 

the final lady in our countdown to sit just outside the 100 Points club, is none other than Miss PCD herself Nicole Scherzinger

 

Nicole is known for being the lead singer of Pussycat Dolls, alongside her work as a judge on multiple seasons of The X Factor, which saw her mentor winning contestant James Arthur in 2012. Outside the PCD, Nicole has released two solo albums and achieved a UK Number One single with the huge banger Don’t Hold Your Breath.

 

Nicole and the rest of PCD will embark on a huge UK & Australian reunion Tour this year - and their new single React will be released at the end of the month

 

 

Pussycat Dolls Members Placings:

 

Nicole Scherzinger - 15th

Ashley Roberts - 38th

Melody Thornton - 69th

Jessica Sutta - Did Not Place

Kimberly Wyatt - Did Not Place

Carmit Bachar - Did Not Place

  • Author

14th Place - 102 Points

 

Rochelle Humes - The Saturdays

 

first up in the 100 Points club of this countdown, and the second highest placing member of The Saturdays... it’s Rochelle Humes.

 

During her 7 years with The Saturdays, Rochelle was usually overlooked by many fans, but since entering hiatus in 2014 - Rochelle’s career has flourished.

 

perhaps becoming one of the most successful UK girl group solo stories of all-time really, Rochelle has gone on to host prime-time TV Shows on both BBC One and ITV 1 with The Hit List, Ninja Warrior UK and This Morning. Alongside Rochelle’s Television CV, she is also a best-selling children’s author and the owner of TWO companies (HIGlow & My Little CoCo).

 

 

The Saturdays Members Placings:

 

Rochelle Humes - 14th

Una Healy - 26th

Vanessa White - 27th

Frankie Bridge - 29th

Mollie King - TBA

Thought Nicole would be a bit higher but realised I forgot to vote her myself 🙈
Surprised to see that Mollie will be the top out of The Saturdays. Hope she's out next 🤭
  • Author

13th Place - 103 Points

 

Kelly Rowland - Destiny’s Child

 

X Factor Judge. Singer. All Around Icon.

 

who will ever forget when Kelly jetted back to LA halfway through X Factor ‘sick’, just to phone in on Sunday and send Sophie Habbibis packing? did somebody say ICONIC?

 

Kelly has had a string of huge hits since the demise of Destiny’s Child including the UK number one ‘When Love Takes Over’ with David Guetta.

 

 

Destiny’s Child Members Placings:

 

Kelly Rowland - 13th

Michelle Williams - 57th

Beyoncé Knowles - TBA

LaTavia Roberson - Did Not Place

LeToya Luckett - Did Not Place

Farrah Franklin - Did Not Place

I wish I took part .

 

Melanie C would be number 1 !!

So who’s left? All five spice girls, beyonce, molly, perrie & jade from lm, who else?

 

Edit: forgot about girls aloud lol.

Edited by cantthinkofaname

  • Author

12th Place - 108 Points

 

Perrie Edwards - Little Mix

 

as we have a tie in 10th Place, it means that Perrie will just be missing out on a Top 10 finish by a margin of 10 points (ironic really).

 

Perrie became the best known member of Little Mix very early on due to her high profile relationship (and eventual engagement) to One Direction’s Zayn Malik - which eventually ended very messily in 2014, inspiring the groups Number 1, MILLION selling single Shoutout to my Ex.

 

Perrie has one of the strongest and most recognisable Girl Group voices of recent, and allegedly was offered the opportunity to begin a solo career in late 2018 by Simon Cowell, but declined and remained loyal to Little Mix - and this friendship really must be the secret to their long history and continuous success (something no other X Factor winner can claim).

 

 

Little Mix Members Placings:

 

Perrie Edwards - 12th

Jesy Nelson - 18th

Leigh-Anne Pinnock - 19th

Jade Thirlwall - TBA

  • Author

Your Top 10

 

Spice Girls

 

Melanie C

Melanie B

Geri Halliwell

Victoria Beckham

Emma Bunton

 

Girls Aloud

 

Nicola Roberts

Nadine Coyle

Cheryl Tweedy

 

Destiny’s Child

 

Beyoncé

 

The Saturdays

 

Mollie King

 

Little Mix

 

Jade Thirlwall

 

can you predict how the Top 10 will look? :w00t:

Edited by miichaelking21

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.