Posted December 26, 20204 yr Figured it would be fun to see how people rank the albums for the group and each of the girls... post yours here: Spice Girls: - Spice - Spiceworld - Foever Melanie C - Northern Star - Reason - Beautiful Intentions - This Time - The Sea - Stages - Version Of Me - Melanie C Emma - A Girl Like Me - Free Me - Life In Mono - My Happy Place Geri - Schizophonic - Scream If You Wanna Go Faster - Passion - Man On The Mountain (leaked album) Melanie B - Hot - LA State Of Mind Victoria - VB - Open Your Eyes (I know not an official album but we need something to compare with and it’s better in its current form than most of the rest of the girls work 😂) Edited December 26, 20204 yr by spiceboy
December 26, 20204 yr Author Mr ranking would be SPICE GIRLS 1. Spiceworld 2. Spice 3. Forever MELANIE C 1. Northern Star 2. Melanie C 3. Beautiful Intentions 4. The Sea 5. Reason 6. Version Of Me 7. This Time 8. Stages EMMA 1. Free Me 2. Life In Mono 3. A Girl Like Me 4. My Happy Place GERI 1. Man On The Mountain 2. Passion 3. Scream If You Wanna Go Faster 4. Passion MELANIE B 1. LA State Of Mind 2. Hot VICTORIA 1. Open Your Eyes 2. VB Geri is the only one who I think each album is actually a stronger body of work than the previous album! 😮 Edited December 26, 20204 yr by spiceboy
December 26, 20204 yr Spice Girls - 1. Spiceworld 2. Forever 3. Spice Melanie C - 1. Northern Star 2. Melanie C 3. Beautiful Intentions 4. The Sea 5. Version Of Me 6. Reason 7. This Time 8. Stages Emma - 1. Free Me 2. Life In Mono 3. A Girl Like Me 4. My Happy Place Geri - 1. Schizophonic 2. Passion 3. Scream If You Wanna Go Faster 4. Man On The Mountain Mel B - 1. Hot 2. LA State Of Mind Victoria - 1. VB 2. Open Your Eyes
December 26, 20204 yr Spice Girls - 1. Spiceworld 2. Spice 3. Forever Melanie C - 1. The Sea 2. Melanie C 3. Northern Star 4. Version Of Me 5. Reason 6. Beautiful Intentions 7. This Time 8. Stages Emma - 1. Free Me 2. A Girl Like Me 3. Life In Mono 99. My Happy Place Geri - 1. Schizophonic 2. Scream If You Wanna Go Faster 99. Passion 9999. Man On The Mountain Mel B - 1. Hot 2. LA State Of Mind Victoria - 1. VB 2. Open Your Eyes
December 26, 20204 yr Spice Girls: 1. Forever 2. Spiceworld 3. Spice Melanie C 1. Northern Star 2. Melanie C 3. Beautiful Intentions 4. Version Of Me 5. Reason 6. This Time 7. The Sea 8. Stages Emma 1. Free Me 2. Life In Mono 3. A Girl Like Me 4. My Happy Place Melanie B 1. Hot 2. LA State Of Mind Victoria 1. VB 2. Open Your Eyes
December 26, 20204 yr Yes at the love for Forever! It's their best album overall. Spice literally falls to #3 because of the inclusion of Mama and Wannabe. Spiceworld suffers from Do It and it being too pop imo. Forever just flows better, is better produced, sang, written and overall quite incredible. I have found myself going back to it more and more over the years whilst the other two have started to sound quite 'of their time' for me :blink:
December 26, 20204 yr Author It's their best album overall. Spice literally falls to #3 because of the inclusion of Mama and Wannabe. Spiceworld suffers from Do It and it being too pop imo. Forever just flows better, is better produced, sang, written and overall quite incredible. I have found myself going back to it more and more over the years whilst the other two have started to sound quite 'of their time' for me :blink: STOP RIGHT NOW with the Do it hate ✋ ✋ THANK YOU VERY MUCH!
December 26, 20204 yr Spiceworld Spice Forever ☆ Schizophonic Man on the Mountain/Album 4 Passion Scream ☆ Northern Star The Sea Reason Beautiful Intentions Version of Me Melanie C This Time Stages ☆ Free Me A Girl Like Me My Happy Place Life In Mono ☆ Hot LA State of Mind ☆ Victoria Beckham Open Your Eyes/Album 2 My top 5 Spiceworld Schizophonic Northern Star Spice Free Me :music:
December 26, 20204 yr STOP RIGHT NOW with the Do it hate ✋ ✋ THANK YOU VERY MUCH! It's not my fault it's absolute shite :puke2:
December 27, 20204 yr Do It is my fav album track on SW !!! Mel C adlibs 👍🏻. I find it hysterical that she can no longer stand it! 1. Spice 2. Spice World 3. Forever (at time of release this was my fav) 1. Northern Star 2. The Sea 3. Beautiful Intentions 4. Melanie C (this could rise) 5. This Time 6. Reason 7. Version Of Me 8. Stages 1. Free Me 2. My Happy Place 3. AGLM 4. LIM 1. LA State Of Mind 2. Hot 1. Schizophonic 2. Scream 3. Passion
December 29, 20204 yr Spice Girls Spice Spice World Forever Geri Schizophonic Scream If You Wanna Go Faster Man on The Mountain Passion Emma Free Me Life in Mono A Girl Like Me I don't have the fourth one (yet?) Victoria VB Open Your Eyes Mel B Hot I don't want her other one
December 29, 20204 yr Author It's not my fault it's absolute shite :puke2: :lol: Really interesting to see people's rankings!
December 30, 20204 yr Not heard the leaked albums, and most of the solo albums are off one listen, but here we go! Spice Girls 1 Spiceworld 2 Spice 3 Forever Melanie C 1 Melanie C 2 The Sea 3 Northern Star 4 Beautiful Intentions 5 Version Of Me 6 This Time 7 Reason 8 Stages Emma 1 Free Me 2 A Girl Like Me 3 My Happy Place 4 Life In Mono Geri 1 Schizophonic 2 Scream If You Wanna Go Faster 3 Passion Mel B 1 LA State Of Mind 2 Hot Victoria 1 Victoria Beckham :magic: :lol: (it's a nice album, not a classic but not bad!)
December 30, 20204 yr I must be one of the bigger Reason fans here :lol: I've found a great new appreciation for it in recent years. It was very well produced and I enjoyed all the single choices. Water is still one of my top Mel moments. :wub:
December 30, 20204 yr Spice Girls: 1. Spiceworld 2. Spice 3. Forever Melanie C: 1. Melanie C 2. Version Of Me 3. The Sea 4. Northern Star 5. Stages 6. Reason 7. Beautiful Intentions 8. This Time Emma: 1. Free Me 2. Life In Mono 3. A Girl Like Me 4. My Happy Place Geri: 1. Schizophonic 2. Man On The Mountain 3. Scream If You Wanna Go Faster 4. Passion Mel B: 1. Hot 2. LA State Of Mind Victoria: 1. VB 2. Open Your Eyes
December 30, 20204 yr Author Melanie C - 1. Northern Star 2. Melanie C 3. Beautiful Intentions 4. The Sea 5. Version Of Me 6. Reason 7. This Time 8. Stages Swap Version of me and Reason and ours are the same :wub:
December 30, 20204 yr Author I must be one of the bigger Reason fans here :lol: I've found a great new appreciation for it in recent years. It was very well produced and I enjoyed all the single choices. Water is still one of my top Mel moments. :wub: Tbf I love Reason it has some absolutely beautiful songs... I just think Do I and Soul boy really let it down. With them coming after Positively somewhere and Melt too it's too much slowness, she really needed to have something more upbeat after Melt. Also she had a very weird choice of songs with some of her B-Sides being way stronger!? I would call some of them single worthy. 1. Here it comes again 2. Yeh, yeh, yeh 3. On the horizon 4. I love you without trying 5. Positively somewhere 6. Reason 7. Let's love 8. Water 9. Living without you 10. Love to you 11. Home 12. Knocked out 13. Wonderland Give me this tracklisting for the album and it becomes my second favourite Melanie C album :wub:
December 30, 20204 yr Tbf I love Reason it has some absolutely beautiful songs... I just think Do I and Soul boy really let it down. With them coming after Positively somewhere and Melt too it's too much slowness, she really needed to have something more upbeat after Melt. Also she had a very weird choice of songs with some of her B-Sides being way stronger!? I would call some of them single worthy. 1. Here it comes again 2. Yeh, yeh, yeh 3. On the horizon 4. I love you without trying 5. Positively somewhere 6. Reason 7. Let's love 8. Water 9. Living without you 10. Love to you 11. Home 12. Knocked out 13. Wonderland Give me this tracklisting for the album and it becomes my second favourite Melanie C album :wub: Yes it does get a bit tired in the middle. I like your tracklisting.
December 30, 20204 yr Author Yes it does get a bit tired in the middle. I like your tracklisting. Thank you. :wub: Tbh even a rejig of the current tracklisting would be better, spread out the more upbeat songs as there isn't any bar On the horizon until you get to water. 1. Here it comes again 2. Yeh, yeh, yeh 3. Reason 4. Lose myself in you 5. On the horizon 6. Positively somewhere 7. Melt 8. Water 9. Do I 10. Soul boy 11. Let's love 12. Home
