Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 140
  • Views 9.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Rumour has it they are contibuing on from the multiverse theme of Chibnat by saying she was the doctor of ANOTHER UNIVERSE!!! And Matt Smith will regenerate into the REAL 13th doctor.
Eumour has it they are contibuing on from the multiverse theme of Chibnat by saying she was the doctor of ANOTHER UNIVERSE!!! And Matt smith will regenerate into the REAL 13th doctor.

If any of that were remotely true it would be the biggest load of continuity destroying bollocks I've ever seen.

 

 

Yes, even more than the Fugitive Doctor or the Timeless Child

 

 

Honestly, what are the sources for these rumours you keep posting?

Edited by Severin

Good sources x

 

Nope, it has now been established, thanks to Chibnab, that there are many universes, with many Doctor Whos. They are retconning ALL of Chibnab's horrendous series by using his own universes against him! Clever really, when you think aboot it.

Wait, I got the Doctor wrong, so it will be Peter Capaldi who will regenerate into the REAL new Doctor. This also allows us all to skip Chibnab's 3 series' run in Doc Who binges, as his is an alternate universe doctor, and not ours!!
Wait, I got the Doctor wrong, so it will be Peter Capaldi who will regenerate into the REAL new Doctor. This also allows us all to skip Chibnab's 3 series' run in Doc Who binges, as his is an alternate universe doctor, and not ours!!

Which would still destroy continuity and credibility given what's been depicted on screen.

 

And would still be a terrible execution that I don't think RTD would be stupid enough o try.

 

If you want to erase Chibnall's continuity issues you do it by being smarter. Make the Timeless Child a lie by The Master and make Jo Martin's Doctor a fake.

 

Even if you're not a fan of Jodie's incarnation i makes more sense to keep it and just move on. The only other option would be to tie her in with being a version of The Valeyard but that still breaks characterisation somewhat.

 

 

Still waiting on a citation for those souces...

Except thet have the multiverse rhat Chiban JUST brought in himself, with the Doctor moving between them. What's smarter than using his own terrible creation to destroy his own terrible creation? By making Jo a fake and thr Timeless Child nonsense a lie, you STILL have to docus on those trash tier storylines!! That's not smart at all. Better to just jump away at warp speed, using Chibnab's own crrations against him. The Vineyard would be okay too, but it's not. My sources are usually on the money!!
Except thet have the multiverse rhat Chiban JUST brought in himself, with the Doctor moving between them. What's smarter than using his own terrible creation to destroy his own terrible creation? By making Jo a fake and thr Timeless Child nonsense a lie, you STILL have to docus on those trash tier storylines!! That's not smart at all. Better to just jump away at warp speed, using Chibnab's own crrations against him. The Vineyard would be okay too, but it's not. My sources are usually on the money!!

I'll keep responding because at the moment I'm not yet bored.

 

Firstly, Chibnall did not introduce the idea of multiple universes to the show.

 

Secondly, the Timeless Child is the biggest continuity bomb in the show's history, to ignore it is bad writing. To embrace the concept is also fraught with problems and potentialy alienates a large percentage of your audience, BUT it cannot be ignored. The Master's very nature gives you an easy out.

 

You've largely ignored the huge continuity problems that Jo Martin's character creates. Yes, a separate universe solves that but it is again, bad writing forced by a poor understanding of the show's history.

 

 

And lastly, you keep citing these amazing sources without any evidence to back yourself up. I would genuinely like to evaluate these myself but when 'rumours' are presented without sources by someone, who until recently, didn't know who Susan or Romana were, you can surely forgive my scepticism

TV sources from tv x

 

Nope, the best way to respond to the ateocious writing of Chibnab is to IGNORE IT AS FAST AS POSSIBLE. If you want to kill it by dragging along the heavy anchors of Chibnab's bad writing, go ahead. Otherwise, do as the rumours are saying and multiverse it away!! EVERYTHING that happened is in another universe, where shw is the Timeless Child and Jo Martin is one of her incarnations. Moreover, with how Chibnab shat all over ESTABLISHED Who lore - 13 regens, Matt Smith getting regen energy, how the Time Lords startee, etc, etc - the ONLY way to fix it with GOOD writing is multiverse it away. It is the ONLY way to protect continuity, and that is what they are doing according to my good sources x My sourxes were right about Karen Gillan joining btw and about Bill Potts leaving after 1 season and about Missy dying!!!

TV sources from tv x

 

Nope, the best way to respond to the ateocious writing of Chibnab is to IGNORE IT AS FAST AS POSSIBLE. If you want to kill it by dragging along the heavy anchors of Chibnab's bad writing, go ahead. Otherwise, do as the rumours are saying and multiverse it away!! EVERYTHING that happened is in another universe, where shw is the Timeless Child and Jo Martin is one of her incarnations. Moreover, with how Chibnab shat all over ESTABLISHED Who lore - 13 regens, Matt Smith getting regen energy, how the Time Lords startee, etc, etc - the ONLY way to fix it with GOOD writing is multiverse it away. It is the ONLY way to protect continuity, and that is what they are doing according to my good sources x My sourxes were right about Karen Gillan joining btw and about Bill Potts leaving after 1 season and about Missy dying!!!

 

 

If you take a vase and smash it, you can't glue it back together and pretend nothings happened to it. Everyone can still see the cracks. RTD is not a good enough writer to get away with dismissing Chibnall's era without it being further problematic. If they do use the multiverse option they're just covering up a bad idea with another bad idea. It's one step away from having Capaldi waking up and going 'oh what a terrible dream'

 

I remain unconvinced

RTD is a fantastic writer and will EASILY side-step Chibnab's DESTEUCTION of Doc Who lore by multiversing it away. Job done!
The latest rumours are that RTD is planning to have a series of Doctor Who every Spring, starting in 2024!

 

Ah, back like it used to be :wub:

Big Finish have announced they’re producing audio drama series for the Fugitive Doctor and the Sacha’s Master!! They’ll be the first Big Finish series starring characters from the 13th Doctor era (they’ve produced like thousands of stuff from 1st-12th Doctor, including with Christopher Eccleston & David Tennant) which is exciting. They’re my two favourite characters from this era with SO much that can be explored (particular with Jo’s Doctor) so I’m really hyped for this!!! (even if my bank balance may not be x)

 

I think it also kinda confirms RTD’s new era will be quite a fresh reboot from this era, if they’re allowing Big Finish to explore the continuity instead.

Yup, RTD will establish it as an alternate universe!

I'm still unsure what you are suggesting here as there's been plenty of contradiction in your posts. Is Jodie -

 

Alt. universe Doctor in 'our' universe as you first stated

or

'Our' Doctor in alt. universe (which makes more sense but I still think is naff)

 

And alt. Doctor in alt. universe just doesn't work at all

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.