I'm not really into the whole "reaction" videos thing on Youtube but I do make an exception for these guys who are quite adorable (and the one in the baseball cap is fitttt).

They have reacted to Spice Girls videos in the past which have been shared on here, couldn't find the original thread so starting a new one as they have done a Melanie C Weekly Top 5. Someone nominated her with these songs (which are a rather bizarre choice in some cases but they seem to love the bizarre choices lol), worth a watch.

Melanie C Week! #5 - On The Horizon

Melanie C Week! #4 - Never Be The Same Again (feat. Lisa "Left Eye" Lopes)

Melanie C Week! #3 - Sweat

Melanie C Week! #2 - Here It Comes Again

Melanie C Week! #1 - I Turn To You

Plus a random one they did before:

Melanie C - Goin' Down - Patreon Week 45! #2

It's nice how much they appreciate her versality with her music and they show some major appreciation for the fact she is still going 30 years later. 🥰

What would you have chosen for Melanie C top 5? What would you choose for the other girls... Victoria obviously only has 5 singles lool, and Mel B 7 so they are limited for choice. 😂

Edited May 26May 26 by Spiceboy

I feel like they really didn't care for Mel C's songs at all lol. They were more into the Spice girls' catalogue and Emma's Maybe. They should also do Emma's and Geri's as well.

Emma

1) What took you so long?

2) What I am

3) Free Me

4) I'll be there

5) Baby don't stop

Geri

1) It's raining men

2) Calling

3) Bag it up

4) Mi Chico Latino

5) Look At Me

Victoria

1) Let Your Head Go

2) This Groove

3) A Mind of its own

4) Not such an innocent girl

5) Out of Your Mind

Mel B

1) Feels So Good

2) Tell Me

3) For Once in my life

4) Word Up

5) I want you back

Really? I thought they were very complimentary of On the horizon (which they seemed to love) and I turn to you. Then the one in the cap also said he loved the vocal on HICA. I do agree that with Sweat and NBTSA they spoke more about the videos than the songs so maybe that is an indication they didn't like them as much.

I get the impression they would love a few of those Mel B songs, I want you back, word up and feels so good. Not so sure they would dig the other two.

Edited May 26May 26 by Spiceboy

We should suggest an Emma week! They have done Maybe so they should do:

What Took You So Long

I'll Be There

Free Me

Crickets Sing for AnaMaria

You're All I Need To Get By

I think those are probably Emma's best videos overall after Maybe! Hopefully they stay away from We're Not Gonna Sleep Tonight, Baby Please Don't Stop or Downtown, all terrible videos lol

19 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

We should suggest an Emma week! They have done Maybe so they should do:

What Took You So Long

I'll Be There

Free Me

Crickets Sing for AnaMaria

You're All I Need To Get By

I think those are probably Emma's best videos overall after Maybe! Hopefully they stay away from We're Not Gonna Sleep Tonight, Baby Please Don't Stop or Downtown, all terrible videos lol

Dear god not Crickets or you're all I need! Terrible choices, no covers!

1. What took you so long

2. Take my breath away

3. Free me

4. I'll be there

5. Baby please don't stop

4 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

Dear god not Crickets or you're all I need! Terrible choices, no covers!

1. What took you so long

2. Take my breath away

3. Free me

4. I'll be there

5. Baby please don't stop

Both Take My Breath Away and Baby Please Don't Stop are not great videos, sorry. They are BORING. BPDS was pretty awful lol at least TMBA is pretty.

We want those hunks to have fun, so my list is better!!

3 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

Both Take My Breath Away and Baby Please Don't Stop are not great videos, sorry. They are BORING. BPDS was pretty awful lol at least TMBA is pretty.

We want those hunks to have fun, so my list is better!!

It's not just the videos though it's the actual songs and the YAIN(TGB) video is boring as f*** too!

15 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

It's not just the videos though it's the actual songs and the YAIN(TGB) video is boring as f*** too!

It is NOT BORING it has JADE SEX ON LEGS JONES AND EMMA BEING ALL HORNY ALL OVER EACH OTHER AND ALL OVER BRIDGES AND BUILDINGS IN EAST LONDON!!! IT is stylish and hot!

25 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

It is NOT BORING it has JADE SEX ON LEGS JONES AND EMMA BEING ALL HORNY ALL OVER EACH OTHER AND ALL OVER BRIDGES AND BUILDINGS IN EAST LONDON!!! IT is stylish and hot!

Crap, crap, crap crap!

36 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

Crap, crap, crap crap!

IT'S BETTER THAN ANY VIDEO MELANIE C HAS DONE SINCE WHO I AM!!! AND I WANT JADE TO **** MY ***** AND BEGS FOR MY *******!!

Just now, Mr.X said:

IT'S BETTER THAN ANY VIDEO MELANIE C HAS DONE SINCE WHO I AM!!! AND I WANT JADE TO **** MY ***** AND BEGS FOR MY *******!!

Just now, Spiceboy said:

Blame It On Me was embarassing.

In and Out of Love you can barely see her.

Fearless was

Into You was so low budget it was quite sad

Sweat is tacky

Drum Machine is cute but the black & white doesnt work!!

Listen, Baby Please Don't Stop was embarrassing but La Bunton put her all pussy into the video with Jade. It is gorgeous and fun!

16 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

Blame It On Me was embarassing.

In and Out of Love you can barely see her.

Fearless was

Into You was so low budget it was quite sad

Sweat is tacky

Drum Machine is cute but the black & white doesnt work!!

Listen, Baby Please Don't Stop was embarrassing but La Bunton put her all pussy into the video with Jade. It is gorgeous and fun!

Blame it on me was fun

In and out of love was a bit dark I agree but a funky video

Fearless was adorable especially the wobbly heads on the car

Into you was low budget but well done and she looks sensational

Sweat is the best video any of the Spice Girls have done in years and if we are referring to Emma then since her I'll be there video.

Drum Machine is also brilliant for a low budget video she totally rocks it.

1 hour ago, Spiceboy said:

Blame it on me was fun

In and out of love was a bit dark I agree but a funky video

Fearless was adorable especially the wobbly heads on the car

Into you was low budget but well done and she looks sensational

Sweat is the best video any of the Spice Girls have done in years and if we are referring to Emma then since her I'll be there video.

Drum Machine is also brilliant for a low budget video she totally rocks it.

You have... questionable taste but THEN AGAIN what would one expect from a Melanie C fan who likes Attitude? God damn!...

Even if those were true, 'fun' doesnt make it good. 'funky' does not a good video make lol it was a terrible video... 'adorable' could also be pointed at Crickets video, but you are bias!

Sweat both the song and video are lame, im sorry. She looks great but as a video it does nothing other than being gimmicky. Drum Machine is a missed opportunity, where there could be a good video in there!

When it comes to videos, even if she has less videos, Emma clearly does it better than Mel C. Maybe Geri tops them both with her two first albums' videos (im ignoring the tragedy that are Ride It and Desire).

let’s skip Emma and go straight to the other three first lol. We just want to see those cute boys’ reaction, aren’t we?

4 hours ago, Rebel said:

let’s skip Emma and go straight to the other three first lol. We just want to see those cute boys’ reaction, aren’t we?

I am not sure what you mean? Like, are you speaking a different language here? What is going on?

9 hours ago, Rebel said:

let’s skip Emma and go straight to the other three first lol. We just want to see those cute boys’ reaction, aren’t we?

FINALLY the voice of reason 🤭

We should have Posh next with her top 4.

1. Let Your Head Go

2. This Groove

3. Not Such an Innocent Girl

4. Out Of Your Mind