Jump to content

2007 Track of the Year - Round Robin - 6/20 32 members have voted

  1. 1. 2007 Track of the Year - Round Robin - 6/20

    • Nelly Furtado - Say It Right
      4
    • Rihanna - Umbrella
      7
    • Groove Amarda f/ Mutya Buena - Song 4 Mutya (Out of Control)
      3
    • Siobhan Donaghy - Don't Give It Up
      2
    • Fergie - Big Girls Don't Cry
      0
    • Plain White T's - Hey There Delilah
      0
    • Mason vs Princess Superstar - Perfect (Exceeder)
      1
    • Avril Lavigne - Girlfriend
      1
    • Arctic Monkeys - Brianstorm
      1
    • Amy Winehouse - Back to Black
      5
    • Sugababes - About You Now
      6
    • Jack Penate - Torn on the Platform
      0
  2. 2. Retiree Poll: Beyonce f/ Shakira - Beautiful Liar - Rate the song!

    • 10 (Love It!)
      3
    • 9
      3
    • 8
      0
    • 7
      9
    • 6
      7
    • 5
      0
    • 4
      1
    • 3
      0
    • 2
      0
    • 1
      7

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

The fifth poll is over.

 

Before the official results, here are the news:

 

1. Beyonce f/ Shakira - Beautiful Liar

The song has managed to be fifth equal (with three other songs!), yay! So, the song is now officially retired and will definetely be moving to the semis. As promised, five points will be awarded for retiring, one point for being 5th in RR5 and they will have one more poll where it will come from the retiree poll - where you rate the song. The score with the majority votes will be added (for example: if the majority votes goes to "7", 7 points will be added to the song's score).

 

2. Four-way tie and replacement

I am not sure how that is possible, but it is a new record. It is now in a situation where I have to eliminate SEVEN songs if there is a clear Top 5. Normally, the song after the fifth place would take over. In this case, "Timbaland - The Way I Are". However, because there are three songs (excluding the retired song) in fifth equal, that speaks for the sixth place altogether (in terms of ties and stuff). Timbaland would technically be placed ninth, so that song will be eliminated - sorry about this.

 

3. Rihanna - Umbrella

This is the FINAL poll for Rihanna - Umbrella, as the song reached its fifth poll. So, if the song is in the Top 5, it will be retired and of course, it will be considered for semi-finals. But, as a reward for being retired, the song will get extra 5 points (for retiring), something from the bonus retiree poll, and their placing points from RR6. If the song does not get into the Top 5, the song will get 2 points instead (for being in the poll five times).

 

So, here are the official results (Purple denotes being safe, Red denotes being eliminated, Green denotes being retired):

 

Total votes: 52 (as of 11:30pm, October 9 - NOT TAKING ANYMORE VOTES AFTERWARDS AS ROUND ROBIN 5/20 IS CLOSED)

 

It reads like this: Placings. Artist - Song - Votes/Points awarded (chart run) - total points

 

1st= Nelly Furtado - Say It Right - 11 votes/5 points (1-1e) - 10 points (total)

1st= Rihanna - Umbrella - 11 votes/5 points (1-1-2-1e) - 19 points (total)

3rd. Groove Amarda f/ Mutya Buena - Song 4 Mutya (Out of Control) - 10 votes/3 points (3-3-3) - 9 points (total)

4th. Siobhan Donaghy - Don't Give It Up - 5 votes/2 points (4) - 2 points (total)

5th= Beyonce f/ Shakira - Beautiful Liar - 3 votes/1 point + 5 points (for retiring)/retired (1-5-5e-4e-5e) - 15 points (total)

5th= Fergie - Big Girls Don't Cry - 3 votes/1 point (5e) - 1 point (total)

5th= Plain White T's - Hey There Delilah - 3 votes/1 point (5e) - 1 point (total)

5th= Mason vs Princess Superstar - Perfect (Exceeder) - 3 votes/1 point (5e) - 1 point (total)

9th. Timbaland - The Way I Are - 2 votes/eliminated (4e-9) - 2 points (total)

10th. Dame Shirley Bassey - The Living Tree - 1 vote/eliminated (no runs) - 0 point (total)

11th. JoJo - Too Little Too Late - 0 vote :blink: /eliminated (4e-11) - 2 points (total)

 

New Songs this week:

 

Avril Lavigne - Girlfriend

Arctic Monkeys - Brianstorm

Amy Winehouse - Back to Black

Sugababes - About You Now

Jack Penate - Torn on the Platform

 

Waiting List/Coming Soon:

 

Gwen Stefani - The Sweet Escape (in RR7 - Since Gwen competed in RR4 - for the track "4 in the Morning", too soon for RR6)

 

The current status/stats will be on the seperate reply in this post (so it won't take up much space).

 

Also, feel free to nominate any songs which are not on the list.

 

OK now, VOTE!

Edited by buzz_person

  • Replies 12
  • Views 923
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Amy Winehouse :wub:

 

& I rate Beautiful Liar a 6

Edited by Rami

  • Author

As promised, the new update on the status:

 

Current Top 10 - Overall (definitely moving to the semis - currently, nine songs have a clear enough score for Top 10):

 

1. Rihanna - Umbrella (1-1-2-1e/19 points - RR2 to present)

2. Beyonce f/ Shakira - Beautiful Liar (1-5-5e-4e-5e/15 points - RR1 to RR5/currently on retiree poll)

3= Robyn with Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat (2-2-4-7e/10 points - RR1 to RR3/eliminated in RR4)

3= Nelly Furtado - Say It Right (1-1e/10 points - RR4 to present)

5. Groove Amarda f/ Mutya Buena - Song 4 Mutya (Out of Control) (3-3-3/9 points - RR3 to present)

6= Arctic Monkeys - Fluorescent Adolescent (5-3-7/4 points - RR1 to RR2/eliminated in RR3)

6= Alex Guadino f/ Crystal Waters - Destination Calabria (3-5e-7e/4 points - RR2 to RR3/eliminated in RR4)

6= Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No (2-10/4 points - RR3/eliminated in RR4)

9. Kate Nash - Foundations (3-6e/3 points - RR1/eliminated in RR2)

 

Songs still in the game, and in the semi-finals consideration (in the pre-semis poll round):

 

1. Siobhan Donaghy - Don't Give It Up - (4/2 points - RR5 to present)

2= Fergie - Big Girls Don't Cry - (5e/1 point - RR5 to present)

2= Plain White T's - Hey There Delilah - (5e/1 point - RR5 to present)

2= Mason vs Princess Superstar - Perfect (Exceeder) - (5e/1 point - RR5 to present)

 

Songs eliminated, but still in the semi-finals consideration (because they have been in the Top 5 - in the pre-semis poll round):

 

1= Amy Winehouse - Tears Dry On Their Own (4-6e/2 points - RR1/eliminated in RR2)

1= JoJo - Too Little Too Late (4e-11/2 points - RR4/eliminated in RR5)

1= Timbaland - The Way I Are (4e-9/ 2 points - RR4/eliminated in RR5)

 

Songs eliminated, failing to get in the Top 5 altogether - NOT qualified for the semi-finals consideration (with placings/Round Robin that the song was in):

 

Natasha Bedingfield - Soulmate (6th/RR1)

Manic Street Preachers - Your Love Alone is Not Enough (7th/RR1)

David Guetta - Love is Gone (7th/RR1)

Kelis - Lil' Star (7th/RR4)

Feist - 1234 (8th/RR2)

Travis - Closer (8th/RR3)

The Klaxons - It's Not Over Yet (9th/RR1)

The Enemy - Away From Here (9th/RR2)

Amy Mcdonald - Mr Rock & Roll (9th/RR2)

Biffy Clyro - Folding Stars (9th/RR3)

Kasabian - Me Plus One (10th/RR1)

Hard-Fi - Surburban Knights (10th/RR3)

Dame Shirley Bassey - The Living Tree (10th/RR5)

Gwen Stefani - 4 in the Morning (11th/RR4)

Edited by buzz_person

Siohan donaghy, and 1 point for the vile beautiful liar(the remix was good though).
Mason and 7 for Beyonce/Shakira

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.