What did Leon sing? :o

Dancing In The Moonlight. :lol:

 

Alisha's real good this week. :o

:cheer: That was really good, go Alisha. She's really growing on me now :D

Alisha and Hope were very good tonight.

She did better last week, I'm not too sure if that song suited her to be honest, surely Sharon could have chose a better song for her. Her performance was a bit weak, she could just be in the bottom 3, and survives another day.

Leon - Really great! So well sung, really suited him. Unnecessarily harsh comments from the judges!

 

Alisha - Dodgy vocals here and there but mostly in tune, and she definitely looks the part. I hope she goes far.

Alesha was brilliant tonight- She turned a dull song into something special.

 

Oh god Rhydian next.

Alisha :wub: fab as always.

 

Same Difference are so good.

 

I hope to god Leon goes next week.

Edited November 10, 200717 yr by Simon.

wow Alesha got some good comments!

I'm not keen on this. :(

I hated this version.

 

:mellow:

Performance of the night bar none. Even a standing ovation from all the judges :o

That was the best performance of the night by a MILE. I think Rhydian is amazing ^_^

Hope - Back To Black Better than last week (It could not have got much worse), but Louis, Sharon & Simon are watching/hearing something entirely different to my (& most of Digital Spy members) ears. Apart from Phoebe it is painfully obvious that some of the other girls can not carry a bucket let alone a tune. Way too much of that performance was out of tune & out of sync with each other with little to no choreography. (I say this every week) It is so transparent the judges are trying to fix a Hope XF4 victory they should be made producers of the next series of Big Brother! 4

 

Leon - Dancing In The Moonlight An utterly unloveable song, sung poorly. Anything other than the bottom 2 is way too lenient for that performance. And as for the Dad dancing...... :manson: 2

 

Alisha - Put Your Records On Oh my gawd this is quite good.......

 

......... If this was Stars In Your Eyes with Cat Deeley. However, a slightly flat, quieter Corinne Bailey Rae soundalike is better than the majority of tonight's performances. 6

 

Rhydian - You Raise Me Up The Secret Garden featuring vocals by Brian Kennedy classic written in 2001 as a result of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Later turned into an US Adult Contemporary best selling #1 of 2003 according to the Billboard rankings for Josh Grobam before Louis Walsh got his 4 Irish gimps to emote the life & passion out of the song. If this was a boxing contest they would stop this show now and award the series victory to Rhydian. That performance has reclaimed that song for me. Truly wonderful. No wonder both Girls Aloud, Charlotte Church & The Spice Girls want him to win 10

 

 

I definatly think he will win. Vocally he is excellent, but his actual performances, like the first 3 weeks were just so entertaining. Usually singers like him are just plain boring when it comes to actual performances but he is always one of the best each and every week. He is so weird as well and interesting :lol:

This Rhydian person... How awful :puke2:

 

The thing with 'You Raise Me Up' is that it has been covered/performed so many times it's actually quite hard to do it wrong tbh. And he wasn't that good tbf, He sounded very Low.. too low ;)

Frightening Rhydian is getting better and better, but I can't stand the guy, but he just gave a performance of his lifetime. That song suited him to the ground.

leon and the other solo guy not rhydian should be bottom 2 ,i didnt like Hope tonight at all,i loved there version of umbrella but everything else has been disappointing

 

i still think rhydian and nicki will be the final 2

My verdict this week:

 

Niki - Because Of You - Reasonable performance, but I think she will suffer from being first 8/10

 

Same Difference - I Don't Feel Like Dancing - Pretty good actually. They have a lot of energy :lol: 7/10

 

Andy - Chasing Cars - Boring. Bland. Bleh. 4/10

 

Beverly - You're Beautiful - I really like Bev. This was good. 8/10

 

Hope - Back To Black - I actually enjoyed this more than I thought and much better than last week 8/10

 

Leon - Dancing In The Moonlight - wtf with his 'dancing'? AWFUL! 1/10

 

Alisha - Put Your Records On - Really good cover version - 8/10

 

Rhydian - You Raise Me Up - The best by a mile tonight! Amazing :o 10/10

 

 

I think Andy and Leon will be bottom (if there is any justice). <_>

Rhydian is technically brilliant but difficult to love. I would never buy his record and on that basis dont want him to win.

Rhydian was fantastic, he does have the potential to be in the final. A truly impressive performance :dance:

Edited November 10, 200717 yr by JammerD