Kylie! The Spice Girls song is not very good imo.

Spice Girls

 

neither sogs are that good but i reckon Spice Girls is ok whereas Kylie's song still sounds awful :(

spice song.. is much better

Not overly keen on any TBH.

 

Kylie's new song is awful and looks and sounds like a perfume advert. Spice Girls song has grown on me so I'll say them.

Hmmm, a vote for a shower of pish or a bath full of excrement.......

 

Ooooh, tough choice..... :mellow:

Headlines! I really like it. ^_^

Headlines

Kylie deserve it after all she's been through, however songwise Headlines is better.

Spice Girls, by default.

 

Although I can still see Leona Lewis remain at the chart summit that week.

Both are very poor.

Leona will remain on top this week.

 

I think Spice Girls will be #1 the following week, whereas Kylie might be #1 that week.

 

Anyways, I think that Spice Girl should be number one. It's a great tune.

Kylie deserve it after all she's been through, however songwise Headlines is better.

I hate when people say that :(

 

Just because she was ill doesnt mean she deserves success :lol: If she comes back with $h!t she doesnt deserve it.

Headlines isn't released physically until the 19th :P

 

so there's my answer. The Spicey ones will be #1 on the week beginning 19th, with Leona on the week beginning 12th ^_^

Both comebacks are poor in comparison to their usual stuff, especially the Spiceys. I think most deserving of number one is Kylie, but I really don't want 'Headlines' to miss out!

I think both singles are poor too.

 

I soughta want the Spice Girls to win the No. 1 spot but think it might be a tight call.

Kylie of course! I'm not just saying that as a Kylie fan as I don't think '2 Hearts' is that good compared to most of her singles, however it still beats the AWFUL 'Headlines'. :puke:

I like both..too hard to choose.

Kylie, but I don't think she or the Spice Girls will get to no1 now.

 

 

 

Me neither. Think Leona will hold both off actually.

I wouldn't rule out Leona for a 4th week at Number 1 next week. That said Kylie's song knocks spots off the Spice Girls' disappointing comeback song - starting to wish they hadn't bothered.

 

As such, my vote is for Kylie. However, I think it will be Leona again next week.

 

 

 

I think Kylie should push leona off the number one for a week

 

Then the Spice Girls can have the number one till the *************** winner takes Xmas #1

 

But i think both songs are great and think they both deserve time at #1