I think Hope will definetley be in the bottom two.

Beverley and Hope bottom 2 i reckon

When do they start singing two songs each?

 

 

Niki and Beverley in bottom 2 tonight!

After listening to all the acts now, I think the bottom 2 will be Leon and Niki, Same Difference will probably be very close, I think Niki will go home tonight, based on tonight's performance.

 

Rhydian best performance on the nite.

I think Hope deserve to go after that - even over the dullness of Leon :o

When do they start singing two songs each?

 

I think its next week, because its down to the final 5, otherwise it be a quick show.

 

Beverly - Shes good but i want her out lol - 6/10

 

Same Difference - These are my favourite, if they won we'd get bubblegum pop back :P, the girl cant sing as good as the guy though - 9/10

 

Niki - Amazing song, she did a reasonable performance - 8/10

 

Rhydian - Hes not going to be selling records, no point in being on the x factor, great at what he does though - 7/10

 

Hope - Whats the point in them being a group pfft, the girl is good if solo - 5/10

 

Leon - Not my kind of music but it was good - 7/10

Phoebe has a brill voice, she should go on by herself.

 

Note to myself: Go to doctor's on Monday and ask for a referral to the local "Ears R Us" shop! Because I simply cannot hear what everyone else is hearing in Phoebe's voice. She is absolute pants! If she had have been chosen solo - she'd have gone the first week. Its only the fact that the other four are so awful ... she sounds reasonable!

 

Rant over!

 

Kathy ... stop knocking on the wardrobe door! I know you're dying to get out and be nasty!

 

Norma

I think this the first time I have ever totally agreed with one of your posts :lol:

 

Awwwww :cry: :wub:

 

 

*Crying in a very special Dannii way*

 

My ratings:

 

Beverly - was ok, but not that good 7/10

 

Same Difference - a bit forgettable, tbh 7/10

 

Niki - Messed it up a bit, but was good nonetheless 8/10

 

Rhydian - Completly amazing! 10/10

 

Hope - Fair play to Phoebe for giving it a go, but was baaaaad! 4/10

 

Leon - zzzzzzzz 6/10

Mine would be similar to yours. :lol:

 

 

Beverly - The fact that she made it original made up for not having the power and range to belt out the song. 8/10

 

Same Difference - Tonned it down a bit with the whole camp/cheese and both have good voices. 7/10

 

Niki - The woman is awful. WHY, HOW and WHAT do people see in her? She sings like a cat. 1/10

 

Rhydian - He HAS to win. 11/10

 

Hope - Bleeeugh. Next Pussycat Dolls? No f***ing way. They murdered an amazing song. 0/10

 

Leon - Yawn. Ray Quin in a Season 4 Form. 0/10

Hope - Hurt

You take on a song made famous by an artist who sings with more passion & emotion than Celine, Mariah or Whitney will ever manage, than you are heading for a fall. Despite that being easily Hope's best vocal performance. The lack of gimmicks (multi-tracking backing vocals, ridiculous clothes & hair that belongs to strip clubs, corny choreography, etc) this week has exposed their ridiculous hype ("Better than any UK girl group around today". Yes my arse are they better than the Sugababes, Girls Aloud or the Spice Girls 8 years past their sell by date) over talent. 5

 

Leon - You Don't Know Me

A good Michael Buble impersonation. Personally I'd rather stick to the real thing. He messed up at the beginning but got a lot better. 6

 

PS. Has Dannii been on Sharon pre-show drinks or what tonight?

 

Btw, Simon did not choose the song for Hope, it was the band's decision to sing that track.

My tonight performance top :

 

Leon - 8

Same Difference - 7

Nikki - 7

Beverly - 6

Rhydian - 5

Hope - 4

 

my ratings...

 

Beverley 4/10 shouted and screeched her way through it :arrr:

Same Difference 9/10 brilliant loved it :heart:

Niki 7/10 struggled alot tonight which was a shame

Rhydian 6/10 quite good i guess

Hope - 5/10 Whorebe sang it ok but i want the others to get a chance to sing once in a while...

Leon 6/10 didnt know the song sounded quite goo though ^_^

Edited November 24, 200717 yr by ArcticJim

Hope were ABSOLUTELY AWFUL. Complete and utter murder of one of my favourite songs in recent years.

 

Rhydian was the best by far.

Mine....

 

Beverley 5/10 She has done better perfomances

Same difference 9/10 cheesy but great together

Niki 10/10 ...I want her to win

Rydhian 15/10 LOL Theres ur winner right there

Hope 4/10 That poor girls carrying all the others

Leon 9/10 He did well tonight

 

 

 

My ratings for the evening:

 

Beverley - 6/10

Same Difference - 8/10

Niki - 5/10 (doesn't help that I hate that song even when Jennifer Rush sang it)

Rhydian - 12/10

Hope - 3/10

Leon - can't rate - missed his performance.

 

But my betting for the final 2 leading to Xmas - Hope & Rhydian. The only way to prove that this show isn't fixed is if Hope and Rhydian get bottom two places tonight! Which they won't. Hope may (should) - but they'll still be saved.

 

Norma

 

Note to myself: Go to doctor's on Monday and ask for a referral to the local "Ears R Us" shop! Kathy ... stop knocking on the wardrobe door! I know you're dying to get out and be nasty!

 

Norma

 

 

*Crying in a very special Dannii way*

:lol: and :lol:

Mine are...

 

Beverley = 6/10

Same Difference = 9/10

Niki = 9/10

Rhydian = 10/10

Hope = 3/10

Leon = 6/10