Woah, way to go on the defensive. How about we just pretend they're 100% perfect?

 

Can't Speak French is going to #1! Girls Aloud are all world-beating vocalists! Tangled Up is the best album since Thriller!

 

GIRLS ALOUD FTW! :funky:

(And excuse me but you dont need to be a genius to write the "About you know" lyrics btw :P )

 

Then why haven't Girls Aloud had a 4 week number one single which they'd wrote if its that easy -_-

 

Edit : Please can we close this now -_- And I agree with the poster who said about the fans putting them off the artists it does actually happen :lol: I went off Kelly Clarkson because of her die hard fans and the same is gonna happen for GA if this continues and I don't want that :(

Edited February 15, 200817 yr by Simon.

Then why haven't Girls Aloud had a 4 week number one single which they'd wrote if its that easy -_-

 

Because a song is not just all about the lyrics... it's a bit about the MELODY you know...

And because people dont like to listen to essay.

 

You have to be fair and admitt that AYN lyrics are not very inventive or inspired.... ^_^

 

You have to be fair and admitt that AYN lyrics are not very inventive or inspired.... ^_^

 

Tbh I'm not so sure, I think they're pretty clever. You're right about the melody though :D

GA are perfect for some people and not for others, thats how music works, people have different tastes.

 

I adore the sugababes for 1 reason - their music. Some of thier tracks are very high quality and different and proper impact making (ptb).

 

But please stop saying GA need to work with other producers as GA are one of the only true pop acts left and i would hate for them to take any other route than the one they have. Plenty of people enjoy their music and generally enjoy them as a whole entity.

 

The trouble with fans of both bands is, the majority of us don't respect others opinions. I used to buy all the sugababes albums but since visiting the babes board and see how they constantly dig at GA, i havent bought one since and probably wont do now :o

 

Infact i remember being so excited about easy premiering on radio and i LOVED it, then after WTW, i couldnt believe what people were saying and i havent bought anything by the sugababes since, i wouldnt even buy WTW on principal.

Edited February 15, 200817 yr by Robintime11

The trouble with fans of both bands is, the majority of us don't respect others opinions. I used to buy all the sugababes albums but since visiting the babes board and see how they constantly dig at GA, i havent bought one since and probably wont do now :o

 

I can count 1 :unsure:

But please stop saying GA need to work with other producers as GA are one of the only true pop acts left and i would hate for them to take any other route than the one they have. Plenty of people enjoy their music and generally enjoy them as a whole entity.

That is not offensive to anybody and I will say it because that's what I think. :mellow: I enjoy Girls Aloud's music, ffs, I even wrote my bloody coursework piece for English as a review of Tangled Up - but I don't gloss over the flaws of anybody I like.

OMG, this is getting so boring! shut up FFS! If you like GA, good for you, if you like Suga's wow! Gosh -_- like someone said, they are both great, their record sales and chart history show that. Just appreaciate both, and if you don't like one shut up! :arrr: I love both. ^_^

I noticed someone today on sugababes official edited GA's single cover from CSF to 'cant sing'. Why? What is gained from it? Does it make them feel better?

 

I have to say though, from someone who loved the sugababes, THIS WAS started by sugababes fans who thought their band was too good to sing with GA. They are the ones who have ruined this and caused all this friction between the two.

The trouble with fans of both bands is, the majority of us don't respect others opinions. I used to buy all the sugababes albums but since visiting the babes board and see how they constantly dig at GA, i havent bought one since and probably wont do now :o

 

Errr well don't go on the boards then. :mellow:

 

I find it a bit stupid that you don't buy/like the music if you don't like people who don't like the band. There is always going to be people who DON'T agree with you. You can either take it personally or you can just ignore them. If every time somone said they don't like a band that I like I went of them I wouldn't like anything.

 

Both GA and SB fans have been petty in this thread. Not EVERYONE but some people take it to seriously. As I fan of neither of them really I find it all quite stupid that people are falling out of a Poll, and really that's all it is. :P

I noticed someone today on sugababes official edited GA's single cover from CSF to 'cant sing'. Why? What is gained from it? Does it make them feel better?

 

I have to say though, from someone who loved the sugababes, THIS WAS started by sugababes fans who thought their band was too good to sing with GA. They are the ones who have ruined this and caused all this friction between the two.

 

I'm on about on this forum, I like to think of my Sugababes forum as a friendly place which appreciates both bands :(

 

Tsktsk that was like a year ago, this seemed to have only started all these wars when Sugababes released AYN.

I noticed someone today on sugababes official edited GA's single cover from CSF to 'cant sing'. Why? What is gained from it? Does it make them feel better?

One fan. Wow. BIG deal mate. Don't generalise - a lot of us love both groups. Everything I say about both is what I really think, and I'm never too harsh or soft. -_-

 

And 'Sugababes fans started this'? Jesus, you aint two dear.

so you say we should just be friends...

 

siobhan donaghy.

so you say we should just be friends...

 

siobhan donaghy.

:wub:

The reason i dont by sugababes music anymore is coz i cant bare to fund something that i know is gona make some pathetic fans start saying ohhhh we got a number 1 album, we walk allover other girl bands. I cant help feeling that coz you know full well its gona be said.

 

 

You have to be fair and admitt that AYN lyrics are not very inventive or inspired.... ^_^

I don't think a GA fan is in the position to say that really, SNN and SKO are just as bad and five of their singles were covers, one was with the Sugababes though.

The reason i dont by sugababes music anymore is coz i cant bare to fund something that i know is gona make some pathetic fans start saying ohhhh we got a number 1 album, we walk allover other girl bands. I cant help feeling that coz you know full well its gona be said.

 

No one ever says when Sugababes are #01 oh yehhh Sugababes are no.1 girls aloud are down to so and so, which Bertie did in the Box Breakers chart he seemed to make clear Sugababes got pushed down by GA. So don't accuse us of it. GRRR You're beginning to make me fumigate :smoke:

The reason i dont by sugababes music anymore is coz i cant bare to fund something that i know is gona make some pathetic fans start saying ohhhh we got a number 1 album, we walk allover other girl bands. I cant help feeling that coz you know full well its gona be said.

That's plain pathetic. Buy or don't buy an album for the music, not for the fans. That really is lame.

The trouble with fans of both bands is, the majority of us don't respect others opinions. I used to buy all the sugababes albums but since visiting the babes board and see how they constantly dig at GA, i havent bought one since and probably wont do now :o

 

Infact i remember being so excited about easy premiering on radio and i LOVED it, then after WTW, i couldnt believe what people were saying and i havent bought anything by the sugababes since, i wouldnt even buy WTW on principal.

they aren't constantly digged at.

 

a tiny minority of fans do, eg the person who posted the can't sing thing.

 

not buying anything by the suga's coz a couple of fans slagged off your precious GA is sad and pathetic.

 

retarded fans wouldn't ever make me change my mind about buying a song.

 

 

 

 

and just for the record, About You Now wasn't written by the babes ;)

You know someone really should close this thread :(

So poor little children can stop arguing over which band they prefer and f***ing find something better to do with their Friday nights.

 

No decent discussion is being made, just a bunch of freakish obsessives that wont have anything said against their precious 5-some.

 

Really starting to put me off Girls Aloud which is sad really :(