Posted February 28, 200817 yr Who saw it? They sang Denial... live....obviously Amelle wasnt great it seemed way too high pitched? the chorus was ok though
February 28, 200817 yr My goodness, i thought it was very uncomfortable. The worst bit was heidi and amelles as heidi was way too high pitched and amelle was way too low and i didnt like how heidi kept flitting in and out. Keisha looked like she didnt want to be there aswell. She didnt look very happy, none of them did really. Dissappointed :angry:
February 28, 200817 yr u're well talking out ur but, keisha looked fine. amelle sounded far far far too quiet, not a match to the album chart show tho
February 28, 200817 yr Will you please just shut up and have your own opinion. I will think what i like. Half of what you say is rubbish but i dont pull you up on it all as i just think let him get on with it. Edited February 28, 200817 yr by Robintime11
February 28, 200817 yr fine u think what you like, but keisha did not look unhappy, they all looked fine. If you wanna state an opinion, thats fine. as long as you are prepared for others who don't share it Edited February 28, 200817 yr by f1mad
February 28, 200817 yr Can i just confirm then that i cannot post criticisms of an act in the acts own thread even if i am being honest? If thats the case, i wont say anything atall here as i feel quite strongly about people being allowed to express theirselves honestly.
February 28, 200817 yr Constructive Criticism, Yes. Plain Rude Comments, No. i wasn't insinuating that you were attempting to offend, i think we have our wires crossed here. I agree entirely with your first line, it wasn't a good performance. what i didn't agree with is the second line. i think i shall make my last post clearer and less aggressive, so to speak.
February 28, 200817 yr So i'm only allowed to say things that you agree with? I could list a dozen sugababes performances that were complete perfection and inspiring but as i like a whole variety of acts, i judge them for their individual merit. And also, i would prefer you not to threaten me by asking me to "watch my ass"
February 28, 200817 yr what do you mean things i agree with? you can post your damned opinion whether i agree with it or not, thats the entire point of a forum. i'm just strongly objecting to the 'bored look' they supposedly had. its nice to see that some of their performances were inspiring, i certainly feel that way about many. I do agree that each performance should be assessed on its own merits and not just saying it was great because they are your fave act. ;) that comment has gone. IMO it wasn't that polite, or quite what i had intended to say
February 28, 200817 yr What i meant was, you said, i agree with your first comment, it wasnt good but not with the second as though i am only allowed to say what you agree with. And i know what the point of a forum is, which is why i was offended by your comment. Its so annoying when you try to say an honest comment and everyone jumps on you just because it wasnt what they wanted to hear.
February 28, 200817 yr Shut up! Say nothing at all if you can't agree. One of you thinks it was poor, one doesn't. -_-
February 28, 200817 yr Shut up! Say nothing at all if you can't agree. One of you thinks it was poor, one doesn't. -_- but i also think it was poor
February 28, 200817 yr Actually i have watched it again and she doesnt look as unhappy as i thought, it must have been when i looked up. But as a performance :no:
February 28, 200817 yr oh yeah, the mics were well dodgy. Amelles far too low, and heidi's too high. i don't think i could watch it again :(
February 28, 200817 yr I didn't like Keishas hair, Heidi looked Ok and i really like her voice, poor Amelle's microphone :( it just wasn't a good performance but i think they made the best of a bad situation.
