Posted March 22, 200817 yr Kerrang had a big poll on their website where you could vote for the best band all all time, i don't have the full 100 but here is the top 10. No one really deserves to be in it except Queen and the Top 5 is just a joke, haven't Elliot Minor had like 2 songs?? I'm guessing all the 13 year old 'emos' voted about 100 times each for some of these bands. 10. Bowling For Soup 9. Queen 8. Avenged Sevenfold 7. Paramore 6 Evenscene 5. Elliot Minor 4 Nine Inch Nails 3 HIM 2 30 Seconds To Mars 1. My Chemical ROmance
March 22, 200817 yr LOL. :rofl: Not ONE of them bands in there deserve to be Top 10. :lol: (Well Queen do, because I find them amazing), but.. :lol: EDIT: Actually, I was watching this on TV yesterday, and I was really p/ssed to see Enter Shakiri a few places above AC/DC. :/
March 22, 200817 yr Author None of it made sense, Red Hot chilis where only top 40 when they are better song writers than most of these bands. I just want to know where Sum 41 finished.
March 22, 200817 yr LOL what an awful list. How in gods name are Elliot Minor who just sound like a 'emo' Mcfly to me be No 5 ahead of bands like Queen and RHCP. Pretty bad tbh. :heehee:
March 22, 200817 yr I do like MCR, but being voted as 'The Best Band Of All Time' is pretty shocking. :heehee:
March 22, 200817 yr That is pretty terrible. The only band I'm remotely pleased to see there is perhaps Nine Inch Nails. Do you have a link to the full list or anything?
March 22, 200817 yr Author I've been looking around but haven't found it yet, they never reeased the list on the website or there would be no incentive to watch their c**p countdowns.
March 23, 200817 yr hahahahaha stupid emo kids NIN and Queen are the only worthy bands saying that, i havent seen any NIN on Kerrang since 'The Hand That Feeds'
March 25, 200817 yr Author Someone made this on antoher site but they didn't catch the rest. 100 - Ozzy Osbourne (A Shot in the Dark) 99 - Reel Big Fish (Sell Out) 98 - Terrorvision (Tequila) 97 - Airbourne (Too Much Too Young Too Fast) 96 - The White Stripes (7 Nation Army) 95 - Judas Priest (Breaking the Law) 94 - Meatloaf (Bat Out of Hell) 93 - Lamb of God (Redneck) 92 - Hole (Celebrity Skin) 91 - Lacuna Coil (Swamped) 90 - 36 Crazyfists (At the End of August) 89 - Apocalypica (I'm Not Jesus) 88 - +44 (When Your Heart Stops Beating) 87 - The Killers (Somebody Told Me) 86 - The Who (My Generation) 85 - The Clash (I Fought the Law) 84 - Faith No More (Epic) 83 - Hellogoodbye [Here (In Your Arms)] 82 - Limp Bizkit (Rollin') 81 - Bloodhound Gang (Bad Touch) 80 - Papa Roach (Getting Away with Murder) 79 - Cradle of Filth (Nymphetamine) 78 - Funeral for a Friend (Oblivion) 77 - Jimmy Eat World (Always Be) 76 - Velvet Revolver (Slither) 75 - Queens of the Stone Age (No One Knows) 74 - Sex Pistols (God Save the Queen) 73 - Coheed and Cambria (Running Free) 72 - Kiss (Crazy Crazy Nights) 71 - Megadeth (A Tout le Monde) 70 - Killswitch Engage (My Curse) 69 - Pink Floyd (Another Brick in the Wall) 68 - Taking Back Sunday (Twenty Twenty Surgery) 67 - Biffy Clyro (Who's Got a Match) 66 - Alice in Chains (Would?) 65 - Pantera (I'm Broken) 64 - Alice Cooper (Poison) 63 - Extreme (Get the Punk Out) 62 - Tool (Schism) 61 - Atreyu (Doomsday) 60 - ?? 59 - ?? 58 - Rage Against the Machine (Sleep Now in the Fire) 57 - Placebo (Nancy Boy) 56 - Motley Crue (Girls Girls Girls) 55 - New Found Glory (Hit or Miss) 54 - Sum 41 (In Too Deep) 53 - Billy Talent (Red Flag) 52 - Trivium (The Anthem) 51 - The Smashing Pumpkins (Today)
March 25, 200817 yr Bunch of c**p, haha. Queen yes, but the rest no. (NIN would be top 100 but not top 10).
March 26, 200817 yr I'm sorry, but Queen "deserve" to be in the Top 10???? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: Fukk that!!! You want to talk about 'over-rated, pompous sh!te', well the very definition of that is "Bohemian ©Rhapsody" by Queen as far as I'm concerned..... Toe-Curling fukkin' AWFULNESS!!!!! I'd place Queen round about 70 or 80 tbh..... And purely on the strength of Freddie Mercury.... If this is a list of All-Timers, well NIN (as much as I may love them...) are waaay too highly rated also IMHO (I'd probably put them about 20 personally...). An ALL-TIME Top 10 Hard Rock/Metal list should look something like this folks..... 1. Led Zeppelin 2. Black Sabbath 3. Jimi Hendrix Experience 4. The Velvet Underground/Lou Reed 5. Pink Floyd 6. David Bowie 7. The Clash 8. Thin Lizzy 9. The Doors 10. Deep Purple ------------------------------------------------ Bubbling Under (in no particular order)... Metallica Iron Maiden Tool Nine Inch Nails Slayer Sonic Youth Pixies Smashing Pumpkins Opeth Ministry Anyone gonna argue...?
March 26, 200817 yr See THAT is what a list SHOULD look like for Hard Rock/Metal, not f***ing My Chemical Romance. :lol: I personally wouldn't put Black Sabbath that high though, as they turned pretty awful when Ozzy was kicked out..
March 27, 200817 yr I personally wouldn't put Black Sabbath that high though, as they turned pretty awful when Ozzy was kicked out.. Still doesn't stop them from being a totally seminal band though Josh... Sabbath's material from '70 to '79 is pretty much the blueprint from which all of Metal and its sub-genres are carved from, Ronnie James Dio being sh!t will never ever change that fact... Tommy Iommi's riffage is the stuff of legend... Sabbath were/are probably the most important band for anyone who wants to form a Metal band (you can almost certainly hear their influence very clearly in the likes of Mastodon, Opeth, Pantera or Lamb of God; even Iron Maiden and Metallica...), I honestly cant think of a single Hard Rock or Metal act who doesn't pay Sab (and indeed Zep..) respect....
March 30, 200817 yr Well obvs I'm pleased MCR won cos well they are the best imo. :kink: But no Green Day, Nirvana, Iron Maiden, Foo Fighters, Funeral For A Friend,Smashing Pumpkins, RHCP, Guns N Roses, Jimmy Eat World,Placebo? All favourites of mine and all deserve a place in the top 10 overe the dross that's there.
April 9, 200817 yr I'm sorry, but Queen "deserve" to be in the Top 10???? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: Fukk that!!! You want to talk about 'over-rated, pompous sh!te', well the very definition of that is "Bohemian ©Rhapsody" by Queen as far as I'm concerned..... Toe-Curling fukkin' AWFULNESS!!!!! I'd place Queen round about 70 or 80 tbh..... And purely on the strength of Freddie Mercury.... If this is a list of All-Timers, well NIN (as much as I may love them...) are waaay too highly rated also IMHO (I'd probably put them about 20 personally...). An ALL-TIME Top 10 Hard Rock/Metal list should look something like this folks..... 1. Led Zeppelin 2. Black Sabbath 3. Jimi Hendrix Experience 4. The Velvet Underground/Lou Reed 5. Pink Floyd 6. David Bowie 7. The Clash 8. Thin Lizzy 9. The Doors 10. Deep Purple ------------------------------------------------ Bubbling Under (in no particular order)... Metallica Iron Maiden Tool Nine Inch Nails Slayer Sonic Youth Pixies Smashing Pumpkins Opeth Ministry Anyone gonna argue...? Ohhhh get you acting all 'ard!! :lol: Agreed about NIN, I feel the same about HIM as much I love them their just rated way, way too high. Stupid emo kids ain't got a clue.
April 10, 200817 yr Ohhhh get you acting all 'ard!! :lol: Agreed about NIN, I feel the same about HIM as much I love them their just rated way, way too high. Stupid emo kids ain't got a clue. I think I'm justified in "acting all 'ard" when a bunch of clueless emo/Kerrang kids start spouting blatant bollocks about what the best all-time Metal/Rock bands were..... Evanescence? My Chemical Romance? HIM? (sorry Clare) Oh, come on...... I can remember in the days when Kerrang!! was a proper Metal mag, if they'd done a poll like this, the likes of Zep, Sab, Hendrix and Purple would've featured easily in the Top 10, as well as Maiden, Metallica, Anthrax, Slayer, Megadeth and others. Having My Chemical Romance at No 1 is a bit like 80s Kerrang!! readers putting a band like Bon Jovi or Europe in the top slot.... Those who claim to be into Metal these days just seem utterly clueless....
April 10, 200817 yr What makes me laugh is Emo Girls who think Mcfly are a rock band because they play their own instruments, trust me, I've heard some funny things I have. :lol:
Create an account or sign in to comment