How it works:

> Give each song on Evanescence's 'The Open Door' album a rating of 1-10. 1 being the lowest and 10 the highest.

> You may give up to 4 songs and 4 songs only, a 10 rating.

> You may give up to 4 songs and 4 songs only, a 1 rating.

> You may give only one song a 11 rating and only one song a -1 rating. However these are optional.

> Post your rates in this thread and feel free to comment as much as you like on the songs and album.

> The ratings must be in before 29-09-2008 and the results will be posted on 30-09-2008.

 

http://i34.tinypic.com/23tk3nl.jpg

1. Sweet Sacrifice

2. Call Me When You're Sober

3. Weight Of The World

4. Lithium

5. Cloud Nine

6. Snow White Queen

7. Lacrymosa

8. Like You

9. Lose Control

10. All That I'm Living For

11. Your Star

12. The Only One

13. Good Enough

1. Sweet Sacrifice 11

2. Call Me When You're Sober 10

3. Weight Of The World 9

4. Lithium 9

5. Cloud Nine 10

6. Snow White Queen 10

7. Lacrymosa 9

8. Like You 9

9. Lose Control 9

10. All That I'm Living For 9

11. Your Star 9

12. The Only One 9

13. Good Enough 10

 

Album is perfect :heart:

1. Sweet Sacrifice 9

2. Call Me When You're Sober 8

3. Weight Of The World 9

4. Lithium 10

5. Cloud Nine 11

6. Snow White Queen 10

7. Lacrymosa 10

8. Like You 10

9. Lose Control 9

10. All That I'm Living For 7

11. Your Star 9

12. The Only One 7

13. Good Enough 9

1. Sweet Sacrifice 10

2. Call Me When You're Sober 10

3. Weight Of The World 8

4. Lithium 10

5. Cloud Nine 8

6. Snow White Queen 11

7. Lacrymosa 8

8. Like You 9

9. Lose Control 10

10. All That I'm Living For 9

11. Your Star 9

12. The Only One 9

13. Good Enough 10

Edited September 7, 200816 yr by Katherine.

Good idea. Gonna take me a little while to do mine though ;)

Bump

1. Sweet Sacrifice 10

2. Call Me When You're Sober 10

3. Weight Of The World 07

4. Lithium 10

5. Cloud Nine 09

6. Snow White Queen 08

7. Lacrymosa 09

8. Like You 06

9. Lose Control 05

10. All That I'm Living For 11

11. Your Star 06

12. The Only One 06

13. Good Enough 07

Edited September 8, 200816 yr by Lukuzz

Thanx Lukuzz for your rates. I must say im a bit shocked to see some 6's for some of the songs.

Bump

 

1. Sweet Sacrifice 10

2. Call Me When You're Sober 9

3. Weight Of The World 10

4. Lithium 11

5. Cloud Nine 9

6. Snow White Queen 10

7. Lacrymosa 10

8. Like You 6

9. Lose Control 9

10. All That I'm Living For 8

11. Your Star 9

12. The Only One 9

13. Good Enough 10

 

Absolutely amazing album

Sweet Sacrifice ~ 7

Call Me When You're Sober ~ 7

Weight Of The World ~ 7

Lithium ~ 10

Cloud Nine ~ 6

Snow White Queen ~ 9

Lacrymosa ~ 9

Like You ~ 10

Lose Control ~ 7

All That I'm Living For ~ 10

Your Star ~ 10

The Only One ~ 9

Good Enough ~ 4

1. Sweet Sacrifice 7

2. Call Me When You're Sober 6

3. Weight Of The World 9

4. Lithium 11

5. Cloud Nine 8

6. Snow White Queen 10

7. Lacrymosa 6

8. Like You 6

9. Lose Control 7

10. All That I'm Living For 8

11. Your Star 8

12. The Only One 9

13. Good Enough -1 (fukkin' DREADFUL song.... :puke2:)

 

The album is overall an 8 (and I like it a lot more than "Fallen", most of the songs on that work better for me as demo/original versions on "Origin" and "Not For Your Ears" tbh..), not quite in the Within Temptation league ("Heart of Everything" I rated a 9)... I usually skip "Good Enough" though, it has to be said....