September 25, 200816 yr I never thought I would say that but Sarah has been f***ing AMAZING on The Promise :o :wub: She's done her parts perfectly and the final is awesome! Actually all of the girls have been pretty impressive, it's a good thing that Nadine wasn't there so we can see how well the others can sing :wub: I love it immensely :wub:
September 25, 200816 yr I listened to Apologize; it was painfully out of tune. Kimberley did a great job on the intro/outro, and Nicola's bit was good too (except the long note) but the rest was just...argh! I'll listen again probably so I can hear The Promise, unless someone youtubes it.
September 25, 200816 yr The chorus on Apologize is appalling, they just sound FLAT The verses are good though
September 25, 200816 yr I've just heard Apologize and it was just amazing once again :o I don't hear anything out of tune, Kimberley and Cheryl especially are AMAZING! :wub:
September 25, 200816 yr Author OH MY! Flat?! I have to dis-agree. That has to be one of the most impressive live lounge covers ever, their vocals were simply immaculate. The promise wasnt amazing but still great. Considering the (IMO) best and lead singer wasnt there i think they coped amazingly.
September 25, 200816 yr Author Video's are UP. Btw, does anyone have/know where i can find the audio of 'Love Machine' and 'Call The Shots' from the girls previous Live Lounge appearances - i cant find them on youtube.
September 25, 200816 yr my god apologise is soooooo out of tune and difficult to listen to. kimberley did well for a change tho. nicola was not good thought. sarah was ok for a change too.
September 25, 200816 yr the promise was much better however - they sounded better live than they do on the recorded. especially sarah - was very impressed.
September 25, 200816 yr Author my god apologise is soooooo out of tune and difficult to listen to. I cannot agree with that, not that you want me to! Take a look at the video and listen again, its the man who's actually flat ironically!
September 25, 200816 yr The Promise: GYl6VVsRGIY Would've been better with Nadine! But I have to say Sarah sounded good, as much as it pains me to say it! Good performance :D Apologize: cjEYKS745DI I liked it but, I don't like the man on the chorus :( makes it sound awful. Verses were great thought ^_^ Edited September 25, 200816 yr by Wingnut..
September 26, 200816 yr I cannot agree with that, not that you want me to! Take a look at the video and listen again, its the man who's actually flat ironically! ok whats with that comment? i am entitled to my opinion and i didn't think they did the song justice. their performance of the promise was absolutely spot on however - sarah vocals were outstanding.
September 30, 200816 yr 'The Promise' sounded good. Who'd have ever thought Sarah would have been the best sounding on a live clip?! Cheryl was a bit flat though... As for 'Apologize', oh dear. The man is awful yes but there are lots of other tuning issues going on there too :/
