Posted September 14, 200816 yr I didn't see a thread of some sort like this so i thought i would make one :dance: -Give each song a rating of 1-10, one being the lowest and ten being the highest. -You can assign up to four tens. -You can assign up to four ones. -You may give your favourite song a score of an 11 but only ONE. -You may give your least favourite song a score of -1 and only ONE. -You do NOT have to give an 11 and a -1, this is optional! -Post your rates in this thread -Leave comments on the songs too if you want, because its fun to read! -Please turn in your rates by: TBA -The results thread will be announced upon a later date. http://simplykathy.com/wp-content/gallery/leona-lewis/leona-lewis-11.jpg I'll Be There = The First Cut Is The Deepest = Summertime = Chiquitita = Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word = Bridge Over Troubled Water = I Will Always Love You = Lady Marmalade = Could It Be Magic = Without You = Somewhere Over The Rainbow = I Have Nothing = I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) = A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) = All By Myself = A Moment Like This = Edited September 14, 200816 yr by Johnjo07
September 14, 200816 yr Author I'll Be There 10 - Her first EVER live performance and i was BLOWN away :wub: The First Cut Is The Deepest 8 - TBH I think she could have done this a bit better, but she had HIGH expectations. Summertime 10 - Without a doubt one of the most amazing performances EVER on X Factor! Chiquitita 9 - This song annoys me but Leona actually made it bearable Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 8 - I liked this, but it wasn't her best IMO. Bridge Over Troubled Water 9 - Much preferred it to the SSTBTHW performance. I Will Always Love You 11 - I liked this version more than the final one But both were Off the Chart. BY Far my favourite. Lady Marmalade 9 - I liked this performance. It showed that she could do anything if she was set t :wub: Could It Be Magic 6 - I hate the song, and this is my least fave performance from Leona :( Without You 9 - Beautiful Performance. I thought she was very daring to do this song but i knew she would nail it! Somewhere Over The Rainbow 9 - Stunning! Absoloutely Stunning! I Have Nothing 10 - Another great performance of another great Whitney song :heart: I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 10 - Just as good as the first performance. But I thought the first was slightly better A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 9 - WOW. Loved this performance, mainly because it was the final, but it was still... WOW! All By Myself 9 - She nailed this one just as well as she nailed the other BIG songs. A Moment Like This 9 - The Winning performance from the winning song. Was definately a memorable moment. :heart:
September 14, 200816 yr I'll Be There 10 The First Cut Is The Deepest Summertime 9 Chiquitita 8 Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 9 Bridge Over Troubled Water 7 I Will Always Love You 11 Lady Marmalade 9 Could It Be Magic 8 Without You 10 Somewhere Over The Rainbow 9 I Have Nothing 7 I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 10 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 9 All By Myself 8 A Moment Like This 10
September 14, 200816 yr I'll Be There 7 - She was ill just before this and it shows in her vocal. Didn't blow me away but still good. The First Cut Is The Deepest 8 - Again, wasn't amazed but it was still decent. Summertime 11 - My favourite ever XF performance! She floored me and this was when she became the favourite to win. AMAZING! Chiquitita 6 - From amazing to boring. This was a really bad song choice by Simon and the vocal coaches didn't challenge her either. Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 10 - Loved this, very emotional and great vocals. Bridge Over Troubled Water 9 - Simon started getting lazy with song choices. Bit screechy in parts but good overall and amazing high note run at the end. Lady Marmalade 8 - A shame she was ill and was saving her voice for IWALY. Still loved her little dancing and camera interaction. Also I love the run from low to high. I Will Always Love You 10 - Absolutely amazing, just as good as Whitney IMO. Could It Be Magic 10 - So underrated it's unreal. Her voice was flawless throughout and she enunciated in her high register for the first time. ("Come into my arms..") Without You 7 - Not one of my favourites, weak in the low parts (her lower register has improved so much now) and too similar to Mariah. I Have Nothing 10 - Fantastic performance. Really flawless vocal again and she changed it up a bit from Whitney's verison. Over The Rainbow 8 - Really loved the emotional connection but a bit too much vibrato. She did a stunning acoustic version on the XF tour though which is miles better. I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 9 - First was better. A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 9 - Really loved this, she totally took over at the end too and you can see Take That step back lol. All By Myself 10 - Incredible, she held that big note so strong and then followed it up with the high notes too. Definitely led to her winning IMO. A Moment Like This 9 - Love this song and her version. :) Edited September 14, 200816 yr by Ethereal
September 14, 200816 yr I'll Be There - 8/10. Loved this performance. Not one of my faves, but it was a great standard for the first live show. The First Cut Is The Deepest - 7/10. Nothing outstanding to me, but still very good. Preferred the first week performance though . Summertime =-11/10. Wow. This was the performance when she blew the competition away while also proving that she could truly be a world-wide star. Amazing vocals. :D Chiquitita - 7/10 Nothing special, although it was always going to be tough to follow up the previous week. However, she did make the song her own. Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word - 9/10. An emotional performance with outstanding vocals. Bridge Over Troubled Water - 8/10. Again, not a personal favorite, but the vocals were on top form and the high notes at the end ere immense. :) I Will Always Love You - 10/10. An incredible version of probably the hardest song to sing. On par with the original Whitney version IMO. Lady Marmalade - 7/10. It was great to see her finally do something up-tempo. You could tell that her illness was affecting her performance which was a shame. Still very good nevertheless. Could It Be Magic - 9/10. Another one of my faves. She was having fun and the high note was almost inhuman lol. Without You - 9/10. Lower register was a bit too soft, but her belting was fantastic. Great emotions too. Somewhere Over The Rainbow - 9/10. A very powerful and emotive performance. I believed every word she said. Loved the long note at the end. I Have Nothing - 9/10. Almost perfect performance of another Whitney classic. Sounded great once again. I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) - 8/10. Not on par with the first performance as you could tell her nerves affected her voice a little, but it was only natural for it to happen. Still outstanding with the nerves. A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) - 10/10. This has recently became one of my favourites. Loved the soft first verse and the nig notes at the end. Gary Barlow couldn't keep up. :lol: All By Myself - 9/10. Incredible performance. The only flaw was her lower register was too soft on the verses again, but the "money note" was spot on. B) A Moment Like This - 8/10. I'm not crazy about the song tbh, but Leona did a great job and you could tell she meant what she was singing.
September 15, 200816 yr I'll Be There 7 The First Cut Is The Deepest 7 Summertime 11 Chiquitita 8 Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 8 Bridge Over Troubled Water 9 I Will Always Love You 10 Lady Marmalade 9 Could It Be Magic 8 Without You 10 Somewhere Over The Rainbow 9 I Have Nothing 8 I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 10 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 9 All By Myself 8 A Moment Like This 10
September 15, 200816 yr I'll Be There [8] The First Cut Is The Deepest [8] Summertime [10] Chiquitita [7] Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word [10] Bridge Over Troubled Water [8] I Will Always Love You [10] Lady Marmalade [6] Could It Be Magic [9] Without You [8] Somewhere Over The Rainbow [11] I Have Nothing [9] I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) [9] A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) [8] All By Myself [10] A Moment Like This [9]
September 15, 200816 yr I'll Be There = 9 The First Cut Is The Deepest = 8 Summertime = 10 Chiquitita = 11! (my favourite performance) Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word = 8 Bridge Over Troubled Water = 9 I Will Always Love You = 10 Lady Marmalade = 6 Could It Be Magic = 7 Without You = 8 Somewhere Over The Rainbow = 10 I Have Nothing = 8 I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) = 9 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) = 9 All By Myself = 8 A Moment Like This = 8
September 20, 200816 yr 8 I'll Be There 7 The First Cut Is The Deepest 11 Summertime 9 Chiquitita 9 Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 10 Bridge Over Troubled Water 9 I Will Always Love You 10 Lady Marmalade 9 Could It Be Magic 9 Without You 9 Somewhere Over The Rainbow 10 I Have Nothing 9 I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 9 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 10 All By Myself 9 A Moment Like This
September 29, 200816 yr I'll Be There 8 The First Cut Is The Deepest 8 Summertime 10 Chiquitita 8 Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 9 Bridge Over Troubled Water 8 I Will Always Love You 10 Lady Marmalade 8 Could It Be Magic 7 Without You 10 Somewhere Over The Rainbow 9 I Have Nothing 9 I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 10 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 10 All By Myself 9 A Moment Like This 9 :D
September 30, 200816 yr Author Thanks Chapman but you can only give 4 ten's and one 11 (Maybe you was meant to give one of them 11 I don't know. But PLEASE edit your vote
October 6, 200816 yr There is no doubt that Leona can sing! :wub: I'll Be There 8 The First Cut Is The Deepest 8 Summertime 11 :wub: Wow. Chiquitita 6 Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word 9 Bridge Over Troubled Water 7 I Will Always Love You 9 Lady Marmalade 7 Could It Be Magic 6 Great high note, but I don't like the song. Without You 9 Somewhere Over The Rainbow 8 I Have Nothing 10 :heart: Very strong performance! I Will Always Love You (2nd Performance) 8 A Million Love Songs (Feat. Take That) 6 All By Myself 10 A Moment Like This 9
October 7, 200816 yr Author CLOSED! Thanks to every one of you who voted. I will post the results soon. :cheer: :w00t: Any ideas on which performance will win? :cheer:
Create an account or sign in to comment