Laura: Another Ballad :lol: OH NO! She is singing my favourite MJ song. Her voice really annoys me. I actually liked how she held on those notes. But everything in between was quite boring actually. I wish she would stop with all the random warbling she does before the end of her performance 4/10

Edited October 18, 200816 yr by J*hnJ*07

Aww Same Dif :wub: I did love them last year :lol:

Second half of the performance was great. I didn't like the forced adilibs at the end, though.

this show is so boring tonight, I long for wacky song choices now I've seen Britain's Got The Pop Factor :cry:

Laura - very good performance she is a great singer - liked it! 8/10

Girlband, i should have hated it but there was something that i actaully quite liked about it.

 

Laura was good but some parts of it werent great and she was just screching and not singing. Last week was better.

 

My ranking so far

1. Alexandra

2. Laura

3. Girlband

4. Ruth

5. Scott

Laura I honestly don't get the bad reaction to her, I thought she was really good. The performance was a tad stale at the start I'll admit but at the end she really performed well. 8/10

Edited October 18, 200816 yr by Sabrewulf238

They're all doing Ballads! We need a Ballad, then an uptemp, then a ballad etc... etc... not all the ballads and then Upbeat songs! :lol:

My Ratings So Far:

 

1 - Alexandra

2 - Ruth

3 - Scott

4 - Laura

5 - Girlband

looking forward to hearing Austin

Girlband:

I hate Heal The World in the MJ canon, and Simon was right it had all the cliches in the book so it resembled a Peter Kay p*** take. (I burst out laughing when the paper bits came down as I expected one of the girls to start coughing where they swallowed one of the strips). Clearly not as good as the first three acts tonight, but better than last weeks performance. 5/10

 

Laura:

Taking on MJ's last USA #1 to date, penned by "watersporter" R Kelly (not to be confused with the superior R Wayne :lol:), first half was a bit meh, second half was oversung. Technically the best singer in this competition but like Celine/Mariah/Whitney it leaves me cold emotionally. But the blatant bumming by the judges of her performances is an embarrassment IMHO (But I said that virtually every week last year about Leon Jackson & look what happened). :thinking: 6/10

For fukks sake.

this show is so boring tonight, I long for wacky song choices now I've seen Britain's Got The Pop Factor :cry:

 

:D

 

Fair enough here is the first of three:

 

R Wayne - Britain's Got the Pop Factor Medley

Austin: Billie Jean

He has a good voice. Different? No, check Chris Cornell – Billie Jean. But a nice dynamic version which really suits him. Quite epic.9/10

 

great to see Louis pick up on the American Idol rip off :rofl:

Austin: Why have they made this into a flipping ballad! FFS I used to like Ballads but this is Ballad OVERLOAD! And it's AWFUL! Seriously! His voice is OK but this version is TERRIBLE! I think Austin's in the bottom tonight! :o He reminds me of that Andy from last year. 2/10

I think Austin was very good this week.

YAY did you see that, I got the Chris Cornell thing right. :D Wayyy

i hope to god that Rachel's singing Bad

great to see Louis pick up on the American Idol rip off :rofl:

 

 

Louis does my head in :angry: