In fairness the end WAS really good. Started out poor. Shock lack of praise from Simon? 6

some of those bigger notes actually sounded ok :o

 

Yes, and there were only 2 which is where my marks came from :lol: - they're annoying me with the whole it's Britney and I'm a 16 year old GUY... thing :puke: You should be able to do anything, that's what the X Factor is!

04. Eggnog Quinn | Sometimes - He actually hit some of the bigger notes :o Not a very good performance though, but one of his better songs, 6/10

eggnog - ok bland voice though as usual 5/10

Awaits Vickers-claw...

Eggnog was awful! :o

Time for Diana!!!!! :)

Eoghan - Sometimes - What's the point in even reviewing that. Terrible at the start, then he opened his sub Gareth Gates vibrato and it got better but was still predictably pitchy (as ever). It is irrelevent what I think because he is going to win and the judges all know it. 3/10

"This will make her or break her".

 

No it won't, its up to you Simon and the way you manipulate the show.

Sometimes I think she plays up to her voice a bit.

Bring back the swing! :wacko:

Everytime would have been better for her, vocals on this sound a bit raspy, bit tuneless in places, pretty average, hope she does better with her second track. 7/10

Eughonahnfifnfnfnneneowen- Sometimes

 

Meh, it was allright, he just didnt seemed to get lost in the backing vocals and music.

 

Dianna- I'm Not A Girl.... Not Yet A Women

 

She looks like she was dragged through a bush backwards just before she got on stage. Her best preformance since her illness though.

05: Diana Vickers - I'm Not A Girl Not Yet a Woman Here we go! :wub: Fantastic start! AMAZING! Diana's 100% back now! :wub: That was incredible! Can't wait to download that one! :heart: 10/10

Oh no, he is the flattest singer the show has EVER had! 2/10

I dunno, you can't get much worse than Leon. I was thinking a similar thought though. Britney hasn't got the most powerful voice but his vocals were even weaker than hers. (but I am a Britney fan :lol:)

The opening half of that was Diana's worst performance by FAR... it got a BIT better but still, she cannot sing for sh!t. It's just awful... worse than Eoghan. Srsly.

Louis is right, she does the same thing every week.

05: Diana Vickers - I'm Not A Girl Not Yet a Woman Here we go! :wub: Fantastic start! AMAZING! Diana's 100% back now! :wub: That was incredible! Can't wait to download that one! :heart: 10/10

 

Were you watching the same show ? :unsure:

 

Dull as f***, 5/10

everyone seems very average tonight (apart from Ruth) Diana wasn't great, a bit boring.....5.5/10

Whoa. Based on the 5 performances, I'd actually place Eoghan 3rd tonight :mellow: [above Diana and JLS]