And can I be Honest... when Britney sings this song I think it's out of tune in places... but it's the song, NOT the person singing it :lol: I thought her vocal was great on that one :wacko:

05: Diana Vickers - I'm Not A Girl Not Yet a Woman Here we go! :wub: Fantastic start! AMAZING! Diana's 100% back now! :wub: That was incredible! Can't wait to download that one! :heart: 10/10

 

Someone's not listening to the singing :rolleyes:

If I was Cheryl, I'd take a risk on one week and make her sing Shakira's Eyes Like Yours (Ojos Asi). It's the PERFECT song for her.

Eoghan: Not his worst performance but it was still very plain and bland. The high note he did was pretty good and is probably the best I've seen him do but it still wasn't great. 4.5/10

 

Diana: I liked it, it was nowhere near her earlier songs but it was still a very good effort. Just hope it was enough. 7/10

Edited November 29, 200816 yr by Sabrewulf238

If I was Cheryl, I'd take a risk on one week and make her sing Shakira's Eyes Like Yours (Ojos Asi). It's the PERFECT song for her.

Please, NO. You need a vocal for a Shakira song... it'd be great for Ruth. Not for The Claw.

I loved that performance and I'm sticking by it. :dance:

Ruth - 9/10 - weak start but got better and better as the song went on, awesome :wub:

 

JLS - 3/10 - WTF :wacko:

 

Alexandra - 7/10 - Not the right song for her talents, did it pretty well though but one of her weaker performances

 

Eoghan - 5/10 - Cringeworthy but gave him 2 extra points as he nailed some of the power notes pretty well

 

Diana - 5/10 - Jack of all trades master of none, can't sing for $h!t just gets teenage boy votes because she is "different"

i just hope they dont make ruth perform 1st in doing the 2nd songs ruth for me was the only one to deliver the goods tonight so far

Please, NO. You need a vocal for a Shakira song... it'd be great for Ruth. Not for The Claw.

Ruth would do it good, but Diana sounds more 'goat-like', perfect for a Shakira song. :heehee:

Eoghan: Someone pass the sick bucket please, as always he's awful, not his worst performance though. Unfortunelty it's now obvious he will win. 1/10

 

Diana: Oh, something was very wrong here wasnt it. Diana's gone very downhill recently and it's not just becuase of the illness. I hope she manages to pull Everybody Hurts off or she might be leaving. 5/10

 

My ranking of the 1st performances from each act

1. Ruth

2. Alex

3. JLS

4. Diana

5. Eoghan

05: Diana Vickers - I'm Not A Girl Not Yet a Woman Here we go! :wub: Fantastic start! AMAZING! Diana's 100% back now! :wub: That was incredible! Can't wait to download that one! :heart: 10/10

 

 

Did you have your headphones on I heard different :P

First song scores-

 

Alexandra Burke - 10

Ruth Lorenzo - 8.5

JLS - 8

Diana - 7

Eggnog - 6

Why when I ring to vote for Ruth and Alex, does it say I have the wrong number, when I know for sure they are both correct!!!? I might try voting for Eoghan [just to test] but if it goes through then its a fix I swear!

Edited November 29, 200816 yr by Miss Analyst

i just hope they dont make ruth perform 1st in doing the 2nd songs ruth for me was the only one to deliver the goods tonight so far

 

I think they go in the same order :unsure: though...

Anyone notice how the order they performed in was the order of favourite to win reversed? :unsure:

Diana - I'm Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman Oh dear. After that performance it should be retitled that was not good, but not yet awful. The vocal coach has taken the quirks & life out of her voice leaving a dull shell behind lacking in confidence. The alarm bells of Pop Idol 2's Susanne Manning are ringing very loudly after that performance. (For those who don't remember she had a unique folky style to her voice and became early favourite to win, but then picked up a throat infection, had her performances and her uniqueness criticised as a one trick pony and finished 5th.) 5/10

 

 

01 Ruth / Alex

02 JLS

03 Eoghan

04 The Claw

 

Voting opening now might actually benefit Ruth...

I'm now quite worried for her :(

That was an average performance from Diana, but with a song that terrible what are you supposed to do with it? It's a tuneless and flat song.

 

I agree with whoever said 'Everytime' would have been better for her.

Current Betfair odds 2 Hours before the show:

 

8th Elimination:

 

Ruth Lorenzo 11/10 fav

JLS 12/5

Alexandra Burke 17/2

Diana Vickers - 10/1

Eoghan Quigg - 14/1

 

Currently after one performance:

 

Ruth Lorenzo 6/5 fav

JLS 9/5

Alexandra Burke 14/1

Diana Vickers - 10/1

Eoghan Quigg - 16/1