05 (ii): Diana Vickers - Everybody Hurts Not her best performance. :( But I still liked it 7/10

Bottom two will be Ruth & JLS.

Ruth is gone tonight given the appalling taste of 95% of the British public

 

 

Wooo Miley :cheer:

vocally tonight eoghan diana or jsl werent up to scratch and one of those 3 should go

if the competition is about t whos voice can be covered up the most eoghan deserves to win lol

Diana - Everybody Hurts A good vocal performance, but the magic of Man In The Mirror, With Or Without You & Call Me has gone along with her self confidence. 7/10

PUKE. Miley fukking Cyrus. I hate all these pop-stars singing faux-rock, they even dress like it.

X Factor Songs [After Both Performances]

 

ALEXANDRA BURKE - 8.5 + 10 = 18.5

RUTH LORENZO - 8 + 9.5 = 17.5

JLS - 7 + 7 = 14

DIANA VICKERS - 7 + 5.5 = 12.5

EGGNOG QUIGG = 6 + 5 = 11

 

Eoghan: That was absouletly diobolical, one of the worst things i've ever heard. He coudnt hear him sing for most of it. 0/10

 

Diana: Much much improved from the 1st performance, well done Diana. Alex has rather knocked the $h!t out of her though LOL. 8/10

you can tell miley isny actualy there

For some reason I really am nervous for Diana. I agree with Simon, I felt her nerves before she started singing... I'm not feeling good for her tonight... :(

Performance rank:

 

01 Ruth - Always

02 Alex - Listen

03 Alex - Toxic

04 Ruth - Rock n Roll

05 JLS - Hit Me Baby

 

Rest were c**p.

Never heard this girl before but she can sing well

miley is miming tonight why do the star guests mime thats mariah miley and you canguarantee britney will,,finnily the male guest stars all sang live and all the female ones have mimed this year

Ruth is gone tonight given the appalling taste of 95% of the British public

 

I agree, hoping we are both wrong and JLS will go instead.

 

Never heard this girl before but she can sing well

Seriously? :manson:

if ruth goes it shows that it isnt about talent

Did Miley really mime that? It sure didn't sound like it to me...

Do you think Miley will climb on Itunes later then?

Diana's never been the best vocally, especially compared to Alexandra and Ruth, but me for me anyway, having the best vocals doesn't mesn you're the best artists. To be a great artist you've got to have much more. I agree with what TIP says above, Diana lacks self confidence now and just like football players, rubgy players etc. if they dont have the confidence they don't perform as well. I thought it was a decent performance, and it's difficult song to sing anyway.

 

I feel JLS may be going this week though...