The greatest thing she has ever done much?

 

Took it's time to grow but once it does :wub:

 

Everyone needs to agree tbh.

It was one of my fave on the album but it's quickly losing that crown to 'If U Seek Amy', 'Kill The Lights', 'Circus', 'Shattered Glass', 'Amnesia'. It IS the best ballad though.

 

"Didn't anyone tell you you're supposed to break my heart?" :wub:

LOVE THAT LINE! ^

 

better than out from under, indeed best ballad!

My signature expresses my love for the genius lyrics/production/vocals the song has to offer.

 

I really wish it would be the 3rd single instead of Out From Under (I love OFU but not as much as UY) I think it would also grant her respect from older audiences and other genres.

'Out From Under' is so under-rated on here :( It's my fave on the album. 'Unusual You' is slightly growing on me though, i have liked it from the very beginning but I felt let-down after reading the AMAZING comments people were giving it :lol: Good song though!

This song is pure wonderful.

One of my personal faves off this album :wub:

not sure yet if it woks as a single :unsure:

fan favorites usualy DO NOT make smash charting singles :P

Very beautiful song indeed. And I agree with Ryan, it's a grower, but once it grows on you it's something else, something very special!

 

It's like a new much better version of "And Then We Kiss", imo (that song I really really love!). It also has everything that "Heaven On Earth" lacked.

I agree, it's like everything HOE wanted to be.

Oh, I like it very much as well :) Definitely one of my favourites on the album!!!

Easily the best song on the album. :wub: Gorgeous.

Loves it

One of my favorites on Circus. :wub: I want it to be a single.

I want it to be the NEXT single, and not the gimmicky Amy.

I like OFU and UY, but I like Out From Under better.

 

IF U SEEK AMY sucks....why do people like that song? It sounds like a song a 5th grader would like. Very immature and boring song!!

I highly doubt that IYSA will be the third single.

 

It is so predictable, it will most likely go like this:

 

3.Out From Under

4.Kill The Lights

5.If You Seek Amy OR Shattered Glass

 

Though I think the 5th and final single should be UY.

Sadly, I agree with Tyler :(

 

But I'd love it to go like this:

 

3rd Single "Out From Under"

4th Single "Unusual You"

I think that releasing two slow songs back to back would not be a good idea, especially with a tour in full swing. Kill The Lights definitely should be 4th single imo :P

I think that releasing two slow songs back to back would not be a good idea, especially with a tour in full swing. Kill The Lights definitely should be 4th single imo :P

 

I know, but that's what I'd like anyways.

 

A real dream come true would be if "Amnesia" was the third single, but that'd never happen.

Amnesia and Phonography :(

 

In a perfect world:

 

Womanizer

Circus

Unusual You

Phonography

Amnesia

Quicksand